Why use heatsink at all? Let the TPA3255 touch the metal enclosure with little bit of thermal paste and be done with it
Anyways, even without thermal paste, the larger heatsink will stay cooler because its greater surface area provides a much more effective pathway for heat to dissipate into the surrounding air through convection, resulting in a lower thermal resistance to the ambient environment. While the lack of thermal paste at the heatsink-enclosure interface is a major bottleneck for heat transfer to the enclosure, the larger surface area of the bigger heatsink will still offer superior cooling compared to the smaller one. That's why 07 Max on 48/5 PSU will barely get warm > much larger heatsink. That goes for Fosi too.
But Douk Audio decided to cheap out in V2 with lack of aluminim. And Im not supporting it.
If they did V2 heatsink in the first place and and call it a day - I would be dissapointed, but not even close like in a way of acknowledgment of shrinked heatsink x5 times from V1 to V2!