Larry B. Larabee
Senior Member
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2021
- Messages
- 347
- Likes
- 194
Poll is open for 30 days.
-
WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!
Noise or distortion-which is most objectionable?
- Thread starter Larry B. Larabee
- Start date
MRC01
Major Contributor
The question is too vague to be answered. The frequency distribution and levels of the noise and distortion determine how audible it is, so that is essential to decide which is more objectionable in any given case.
All playback systems have noise.
All playback systems create distortion.
Depends on which one is strong enough to notice and cause annoyance.
Probably noise would be more obnoxious for me, since music is loaded with distortion - it's what makes instruments and voices sound like they do.
A single electric Bass guitar note - electrical signal spectrum:
Findamental is 96.5Hz, with harmonic multiples - 96.5 x 2, x 3, x 4 etc
Red is the peak level, black is the current level - the note decays after you play it.
22.7% distortion, or next to none, depending upon how you feel about it.
47.6% noise? Well, it was me playing it.
All playback systems create distortion.
Depends on which one is strong enough to notice and cause annoyance.
Probably noise would be more obnoxious for me, since music is loaded with distortion - it's what makes instruments and voices sound like they do.
A single electric Bass guitar note - electrical signal spectrum:
Findamental is 96.5Hz, with harmonic multiples - 96.5 x 2, x 3, x 4 etc
Red is the peak level, black is the current level - the note decays after you play it.
22.7% distortion, or next to none, depending upon how you feel about it.
47.6% noise? Well, it was me playing it.
Tom C
Major Contributor
Like Pavlov’s dogs, pops, clicks and low-level hiss put me in the mood, because you know something good is about to start. Having spent childhood in the analog era, noise like this meant it was time for relaxation and enjoyment. It’s actually part of the magic of sound and movies. Hum is pretty annoying, though.
BoredErica
Addicted to Fun and Learning
I hate hiss in speakers.
50% of why I'm going to upgrade my setup is because the noise in my speakers bother me and I hate it. Are my speakers colored? Yeah. Am I missing a sub right now? Yeah. But you know what's way worse? Hearing the stupid noise coming out of my idiotic speakers.
There are "good" speakers that get recommended which perform great on spinorama but in practice I cannot tolerate.
50% of why I'm going to upgrade my setup is because the noise in my speakers bother me and I hate it. Are my speakers colored? Yeah. Am I missing a sub right now? Yeah. But you know what's way worse? Hearing the stupid noise coming out of my idiotic speakers.
There are "good" speakers that get recommended which perform great on spinorama but in practice I cannot tolerate.
BoredErica
Addicted to Fun and Learning
In powered speakers the amp comes with the speaker. Nobody calls a powered speaker an amp, they call them speakers.
Last edited:
Noise of course.
A distorted sound can even sound pleasant to some.
But noise is noise, like the one that is buggering your brain, or listening to music in a noisy area.
Noise is my enemy for sure.
I would even relocate because of noise and changed my hotel room so often for such reason.
Don't you plug out the hotel's room fridge?
A distorted sound can even sound pleasant to some.
But noise is noise, like the one that is buggering your brain, or listening to music in a noisy area.
Noise is my enemy for sure.
I would even relocate because of noise and changed my hotel room so often for such reason.
Don't you plug out the hotel's room fridge?
OP
Larry B. Larabee
Senior Member
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2021
- Messages
- 347
- Likes
- 194
- Thread Starter
- #11
Extended Results:
1600 members think that something that has been virtually eliminated since the advent of the compact disc is an important issue.
500 members think that something that has been virtually eliminated in electronic components and not in transducers (or source material) is an important issue.
The remaining members may have not understood the question.
My vote: distortion
1600 members think that something that has been virtually eliminated since the advent of the compact disc is an important issue.
500 members think that something that has been virtually eliminated in electronic components and not in transducers (or source material) is an important issue.
The remaining members may have not understood the question.
My vote: distortion
relmu
Member
distorsión
Similar threads
- Poll
