He may have used the same "master", but certainly not the same
re-mastering.
Again,
I repeat; the canopy has been clipped.
One (+hundreds) of examples ...
Same relative music timeframe; notice the severe limiting/clipping, absent on the LP.
right channel, hey joe, re-mastered CD.
View attachment 13607
right channel, hey joe, re-mastered LP rip.
View attachment 13608
As you suggested, take ~3dB off the re-mastered CD, and re-calc the DR values:
version: re-master / re-master(-3dB)
right channel: 0.00 / -3.04 dB
Avg RMS: -12.40 / -9.35 dB
DR channel: 7.39 / -7.39 dB
Everything changes by about 3dB, except the DR value, which remains identical!
Nope, been ripping for decade; it's not
commonly known, and if it is,
it's mistaken!
With a fine turntable, DR values will remain relatively the same ... as I've witnessed
countless times over, with numerous rips.
Yes I can if the evidence points in that direction. In this case; I can safely state the "re-mastering" is NOT the same (even if the same master was used). The so-called vinyl process, in this case, is not in question, its Marino's choice of slamming the CD that's questionable.