Thanks guys, I am hearing from you a lot about the negatives of inductors, which is all well and fine.
But the thread question is, what is the mechanism, even if it is incorrect, that these guys are saying makes inductors a good choice? What possible line of logic are they buying into?
It all has to do with capacitor size. The VU product. A high voltage electrolytic capacitor can't have a substantial capacitance.
A 2200uF/50V capacitor has the same size as 220uF/400V capacitor.
Currents drawn (both peak and continuous) differ of course.
The ripple on a tube amp power supply is bigger than that on a low voltage (higher capacitance) power supply in an absolute sense. Relatively they are about the same.
Often tube amp circuits have a poor PSRR so any ripple can make it into the audio path. For this resistors are often used to create a low-pass filter.
This is only 6dB/oct. You can double that to 12dB/oct. and get the cutoff point lower using an inductor instead of a resistor so a smaller ripple.
Whether that is audible or not is another matter. It would have to be tested blind (instead of knowing and believing an inductor contains magic)
So in a DC powerline adding an inductor lowers ripple and a dip on voltage of the capacitors after a large current was drawn can be replenished a bit faster than when a resistor was to be used that had the same ripple.
Of course one can also use regulator tubes but these require a higher rectified DC (to compensate for the voltage drop) and eat up energy (heat) and limit the max available current.
He has in mind an RIAA circuit that “is entirely inductor based”… not sure if that means no capacitors, or also minimal resistors. He showed me a test inductor that he is winding with what looks like a ferrite drum sleeve.
He probably wants to replace the RIAA filter with inductors. That can be done of course but will require excellent shielding of the inductors in order for the circuit not to pick up hum from nearby power transformers etc.
Probably just a guy who wants to do things different for the sake of being different or a curious belief that somehow this is better or contains more 'magic'.
The latter will be confirmed as the listener will know what's in the circuit.
Time to ignore them and when they built it have them do a blind test.