I just read the article you quoted and it doesn't say Midrange compensation should be ignored or that you shouldn't turn it off.
No, of course it doesn't say that, and I have never said such a thing neither so I don't know where you got it from.
The article simply tried to suggest you should probably enable or disable MRC by first determining if your speaker's FR has a dip (presumable by design) at around 2000 Hz. If it has that dip (by design, not imposed by Audyssey), then you should try leaving it there, by enabling the MRC feature, that would allow Audyssey to
not EQ it out. If you EQ it out by disabling MRC, then you would be going against the original design, but if it sounds better that way then by all means disable MRC so that Audyssey would try to flatten it. So the author is only recommending you to not automatically set MRC to be disabled, but to investigate first if your speaker has the dip there by design and if so, try to listen with and without the dip before making a decision. That's just his recommendation and it is consistent with what Audyssey and Denon suggested in that video I mentioned.
The claim that Audyssey Midrange compensation doesn't do anything in some cases and that the detailed Audyssey FR response in the app is incorrect certainly seems questionable. If you post REW charts showing with and without MRC and no change occurs with various speaker designs that would certainly indicate the Audyssey App is intentionally reporting incorrect FR data. If Denon can't correctly show how the feature works in the app I would seriously doubt they can implement it correctly. Either way, I would prefer the MRC feature turned off unless it sounded better to my ear to leave it on. Your mileage may vary.
No offence, you are still confused on this topic, and me too actually, along with many Audyssey users for years, until recently..
Let me try and make it clearer below in point form:
1) When you use the app, you can see the before and after, though we both know that the "after" graphs are not actual, but just a predicted FR after the calibration.
2) On the "after" one, again because it is a predicted FR only, so if you have MRC enabled it will show a dip at 2,000 Hz but it is not Audyssey that would cause the dip. In other words, if you speakers are not designed to have MRC, aka BBC dip, then you won't see a dip at 2000 Hz in your actual FR graph whether you have MRC enabled or not.
3) If your speaker is in fact designed to have the BBC dip, then if you have MRC enabled, Audyssey will not EQ it to flat, that is, it will just leave it there untouched. If you have MRC disabled, then Audyssey will EQ that dip to flat as it would EQ the range you selected to be EQ.
So the bottom line is, Audyssey does not create the BBC dip for you, it is the manufacturer's design to have the dip or not. If not, then Audyssey (with MRC enabled) will leave that dip alone without EQ it to flat, and if you have MRC disabled then Audyssey will EQ it flat along with everything within the frequency range you selected to be EQ.
I says the App's "after" graph is misleading, and obviously you were misled to think that with MRC enabled, Audyssey would put a dip there, when in fact all the graph meant to show is that when MRC is enabled, it won't EQ it to flat, so the target will then obviously show a dip but again, whether the actual FR graph will have a dip or not will depend on the speaker and the room. Audyssey simply won't EQ out the dip if it is there and if not then you won't have the dip even with MRC enabled.
To recap one more time, remember, the default roll off 1 don't start until about 5000-6000 Hz, so Audyssey will try to EQ everything from 20 Hz to the roll off point to
flat, unless you enable MRC, in that case it
will not EQ around the 2000 Hz point. That is not the same as "EQ in" a dip at 2000 Hz that a lot of people thought it was!! It simply will not EQ out a dip that the speaker and the room themselves created, when MRC is enabled. That's the only point I referred to earlier as a misconception, or misunderstanding of the MRC feature.
I have tons of REW graphs that confirm the MRC feature does work as described above. If you use REW you can easily find out for yourself.
In another thread I posted the Audyssey MulEQ X video with the time mark where Jeff (Audyssey) and the Denon rep explain the MRC thing in much greater details.
For you, I search and found it again to save you time.
Please fast forward to about 54:50 and watch it for a better understanding of how it works. I think that part lasts about 6 minutes.