• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

After 9 Months of Research - Rate My First System (Before I Buy It)!

If you spend that much on a trunrtable, get a technics SL1500 or other model. No Project is worth that money if you can get a technics for that price. They are far better. And don't spend so much on cables, get decent generic ones and you have more money left for something elsse. You may want a subwoofer for instance....
And like said above, if you just start with a turntable, a Audio Technica LP120 will be good enough (as long as you don't use the internal preamp, it's absolute crap) for starts and as good as that Project you suggested (for a fraction of the price). A technics is a lot better and worth their price, but no project or other similar hifi turntable. But as starter a AT is good enough (and for many it stays good enough for the rest of their life).
 
Good question. No.

I have a Dual CS-3000 because /me loves semi-auto.


I still would. Two say it has motor noise, one explicitly says it does not and the rest are satisfied. I might return it.

If Amir tested TTs I'd buy one for him. I could try one myself but am not set up for testing and am not motivated to get so.
Me loves vintage Duals (and I have a few as well - cough), but my 701 remains in the main rig - it's overall around Rega 6 level, the arm may be not as good but drive and isolation tons better :D )
 
If you spend that much on a trunrtable, get a technics SL1500 or other model. No Project is worth that money if you can get a technics for that price. They are far better. And don't spend so much on cables, get decent generic ones and you have more money left for something elsse. You may want a subwoofer for instance....
If you're thinking original mid 1970s SL1500, I'd agree as I can make it sound as good or better than anything under a grand at least these days and maybe beyond. However, time may be the issue. I have an SL1500 here belonging to a pal who asked me to store it while he moved. That was five years or so ago and it sits there with a dicky main switch, the bad contacts within causing the speed to jump up and down all over. It's definitely the three position switch and Technics no longer stock spares. Maybe an alternative can be sourced although I haven't tried, the only other option may be to remove it and soak it in an alcohol bath or something to trey to clean the sealed internal contacts as switch cleaner is difficult to spray into it?
 
Another 'desktop' system.

Don't overspend on cables. And the listening position looks to be close nearfield, so make sure the speakers have excellent on-axis response. Probably you should move them c to the front of the desk, to avoid bounce off the desktop. Bass may well be lacking without a subwoofer.

As for room modes and reflections, again, with close listening like this, and toed in speakers, I'm not sure they are going to matter much. It will be approximating a set of headphones.
 
I would throw most of my budget to the best active speakers/stands I can buy, then for room treatment and then for everything else. I never had a vinyl system so I don't know if a quality phono stage and turntable is more important than the speakers though.

Last year I got the usb audioquest cable (around 40-50 euros) and unfortunately I had zero difference than the ifi stock usb cable. I guess that the implementation of the dac and your digital transport has a role to play in that too.

If you don't mind a suggestion there are very good active speakers with built in dac..and even streamers so you would only need your laptop as a transport. I think KEF and dynaudio has speakers like that.

Cheers
 
You are getting a lot of ASR feedback - sorry about that. I hope we're not throwing too much water on your campfire. You've done a lot of work already, and I sincerely hope that whatever you end up getting, you are really happy with it!

Making it all work in a room that small is indeed a challenge. My upstairs workroom is about 8' x 20' but it allows me to have nice speaker placement for nearfield on stands to L/R of the desk and then the main stereo console is off to my left, so I can easily reach the integrated amp and various sources, including TT. A more square room is a tough thing to make work.

Small advice again on the subwoofer front, if you go that route, be sure you can return it. Depending on the speakers you get, it really could just add boominess without any positive effect.
 
If it were me, like many others in the thread, I would:

  • Save some $$ on the TT and phono pre
  • Save some $$ on the fraudioquest cables and get normal cables
  • Upgrade to the Neumann speakers
  • Look into a sub
With $2K+ budget you can do better than the Kalis - there's nothing wrong with them, but the limiting factor on sound quality is 95% the speakers and the room, everything else a distant third. Maximize what you can there.

The WiiM is a good choice and can be used to EQ for the room / sub, very important. Might be worth investing in a UMIK also.

What you have planned is good, no question, but if you are looking for opinions, well, there's another one. :)
 
Are there recommendations for cables, or specific materials or details I should look for?
With cables, just look for a semi-reputable brand, good construction, and the proper length.

In the US World's Best Cable is about as high-end as you need to go, they use quality parts and the price is fair.

You can definitely go a step down to Monoprice or even Amazon Basics and not hear any difference whatsoever, you're basically just paying for durability and feel in the hand, honestly.
 
Me loves vintage Duals (and I have a few as well - cough), but my 701 remains in the main rig - it's overall around Rega 6 level, the arm may be not as good but drive and isolation tons better :D )
Part of my answer should also have been that I find the dusty groove shops like RRRecords (Lowel) and 8mm (Porto) and the associated not so hi fi approach to playing vinyl more appealing than the audiophile version, which seems no fun and a losing proposition to me. I know how to get great audio and it's easy but it's really hard with vinyl. Otoh, I fully support playing with vinyl as a hobby (especially when avoiding new record releases) so a cheap DJ deck seems like the ideal compromise for someone to get started easily, have fun and not have to invest into the terribly serious Rega, Pro-Ject, VPI, Stereophile lifestyle treadmill of gear worship.

And that AT deck appears to be selling at a rate well into the kiloton range and be well ahead of its competition in that price class. So...
 
@56suited I would also say, don't overthink this too much. Don't wait months to get this system together, that's just months you are missing out on listening to music on good speakers.

The specific advice in this thread is good, I think picking a TT can be tricky, but the general advice is something you can act on quickly: Get the best speakers you can afford and don't worry about the rest of it too much. :)

e: Also if you want to stretch the budget to *even better* speakers, I always recommend checking your local secondhand marketplaces. I got some Genelec 8030s for about 1/3 of retail price that way. With some luck even the KH310 is within your budget, secondhand...
 
Last edited:
I am back down a rabbit hole again, restructuring everything with either the Adam A7V or Neumann KH120 II. More than likely killing the phono stage and repurposing that money to the speakers. I'll come up for air again in a few months.
@56suited I am sorry if we did anything that will cause you to delay the project. It can be like that here. By being flippant and long winded I played my part. (´;︵;`)

When I asked my first question here I was in the market for floor standers for our living room. I ended up in the Circle of Confusion and eventually found myself on the Lost Highway. But I stuck with it and eventually acquired Ascend Acoustics Sierra Tower speakers and I would choose the same today.

Your feeling of rabbit holes and drowning is familiar. I believe this disorientation is part of the process of becoming independent of the marketing memes that dominate this corner of consumer culture. If you have time and motivation you can learn enough to be largely independent. If otoh you want to hurry up and go shopping then I promise to help.

First question: Do you want digital streaming, and TV, and TT all on day one or are you willing to delay on any of those?

What online shopping sites do you like? (URLs with country code please)
 
Well done on your presentation! And welcome to our party of shuffling nerds.

As for my rating, I'll give you 2 out of a possible 4 stars.

The biggest problem here is the room's honking bass modes. What's your solution there? Your GIK panels won't help that. How do you measure them? Does the WiiM Ultra provide EQ? I think WiiM added some kind of room EQ and I have a Pro so I should know but I don't.

If you're budgeting up to 3000, why Kali IN-5? Well-engineered speakers your top priority and in your small room you'll need ones with near-field integration and very smooth radiation. Not sure what to suggest until we renegotiate the next items on my list.

That TT is overpriced and yuck. Either get a new AT-LP120XUSB or if you want to spend more money on a TT, a used SL-1200. We've had this punch up about three times here recently and the low-mass belt-drive brigade took a pasting every time 8^}} The AT-LP120XUSB is truly awsome and you will enjoy it very much for sure so I suggest you save money with that and put it into speakers.

You'd be amazed who uses the Art PrecisionPre Phono around here (read this thread) and the systems they use it in, myself included. Save money here and put it into speakers.

AudioQuest cables?! You come to ASR asking for our rating of your choice of AudioQuest cables? The cheek of it :P

Back to the speakers. In such a small room I hesitate to recommend larger woofers. I use 5.5" in a study larger than that and I'm ok with it. But many people here are bass heads and insist on sub 40 extension. It's up to you. But it's tricky in that room and there are pros and cons. I would rather you start with getting the "best" mid-size boxes you can afford. For example, can we get you into a pair of Neumann KH 150? If, after living with that until you have saved up some money for upgrades, you feel sure you desire another octave on your bottom, add a Neumann sub. That Kali is a great budget option if you're really on bugdet but you're not.

And I took a whole star off for the nested indentation of your bullet list. You made me get up and go get my lap top to just read it.
A well-thought out response and very in-depth. Thank you for your help! Especially on the 'bigger woofers'/'get a sub' topic.
 
Why cheap out on the speaker yet buy a $800 turntable
  1. Because I am learning the ropes.
  2. Because I have a very small room.
  3. Because if I go full blast on speakers, and in the odd chance I end up being able to upgrade to a larger space...I then have to buy new speakers all over again.
Maybe not excellent reasons, but reasons nonetheless.
 
I'd second the advice from most here to select (much) cheaper cables and a cheaper turntable.
WiiM Ultra already has a built-in phono input so I'd drop the separate phono box completely. WiiM products also implement both Room EQ, bass management and even a manual 10-band PEQ - I don't believe you would necessarily get any better results with miniDSP.

Loudspeaker placement near the wall behind them is not an issue (actually it is usually even preferable in such small rooms - see this article by Genelec).

Regarding speakers - for such a small room and short listening distance, I believe ~5" woofers should be perfectly fine - assuming you don't plan to blast it to very high listening levels. Even 4" woofers might work, depending on how loud you listen and whether or not you have a sub.

Here's my view on woofer size, which I guess some will see as controversial: going up for a 7" or 8" woofer on the loudspeakers won't provide as much additional bass extension as you may think, and IMHO doesn't ever truly replace a subwoofer. In this case a bigger speaker mainly means it can play louder without noticeable distortion.
So you'd need to know how loud you want to listen (and how far away you want to sit) to make an informed decision if you need a bigger speaker or not. E.g. Neumann and Genelec both have official guides on speaker size selection which are based on listening distance and required SPL.

To illustrate, here's an example of Neumann KH 120 II vs KH 150 (source) - you can see that with the larger woofer you'd get only 5-6Hz lower extension:
View attachment 391816
A subwoofer on the other hand should gives you an extra octave below, and it can also be used to offload the bass from the loudspeakers, smooth out the upper bass response and in some cases even to combat SBIR effects (I wrote about this a little before). Here's how adding a tiny sub helped me greatly reduce audible bass-suckout in my desktop system.
With multiple subwoofers (optimized with measurement and DSP) you can even achieve a consistent bass response across a wider listening area - though this is not necessary if you have only one listening position.

All of the above can go a long way towards taming the undesirable room effects on the bass, which has a significant influence on sound quality.

However, properly integrating a subwoofer for the first time is not trivial (there's a learning curve to it), and could lead to less-than-desirable results if done poorly. But it is important to understand that it is possible to do it well, and your room size would not necessarily be an issue.

If you want to have room correction and a well integrated subwoofer, how much you need to spend will also depend on how automated you want this process to be.
You could get away with a cheaper system, but then you need to learn more about in-room response measurement, manual room EQ and subwoofer integration as you will be doing all of that manually.
For a higher price you could get slightly more automation and ease of use (e.g. have a look at Genelec GLM and Neumann MA 1 solutions), but that would probably break the budget, and especially if you also need an additional streaming box and a turntable.

All that being said, for simplicity (and to avoid being overloaded with new information), it may indeed make sense to start without a sub, learn to measure and do room correction, and add a sub later.

Hope you'll find some of the information interesting and useful. Good luck and have fun! :)
So much helpful info - thank you very much. Interesting point of view on larger woofers/need for a sub-woofer. This makes me feel alright then with a 5-7" woofer (ex: Kali IN-5, Adam Audio A7V, Neumann KH 120 II, etc.). I might even switch it up and go for Adam T5V, T7V, or T8V with the T10S sub. That sub is made specifically for the T series, and sounds like something a rookie can handle on a bargain. Lots to think about.

I really appreciate the kindness and effort you put in.
 
Given the room dimensions (L, W, H please @56suited ) and assuming KH 150 and max in-room SPL, say 75 or 80 dB then we can add a low shelf to get a bit more LF and predict the in room response with REW's simulator.

Roughly 2m x 3m x 3m (W, L, H)
 
Because I have a very small room.

Because if I go full blast on speakers, and in the odd chance I end up being able to upgrade to a larger space...I then have to buy new speakers all over again.

The biggest risk of big speakers is that you cannot get the on axis response relative to the physical layout of the speakers. 1m isn’t bad though. A coaxial speaker like a Genelec would be a good option for you.

You should still spend the most on your speakers. If you buy a budget speaker, resale value will take a pretty big hit because people would rather just buy a perfect brand new one for just a little bit more. If you buy a super premium speaker with great resale value, you will still lose a lot of money in the absolute sense but your ability to convert it into cash is good and then you have to have the discipline to have kept your gear long enough that the rental fee makes sense.

The goal is that if you buy a speaker that is overkill today like a premium Neumann or Genelec, you will be fine at 1m and underutilizing the capabilities. When you move and have a 2m or even 3m listening distance you are still going to be fine.
 
Hi

I do not full understand the TT . I hope the OP does not fall for the lies about Vinyl superiority to digital.
This said, I would suggest the following system:
Wiim Streamer around $ 90
RME ADI-2
Neuman KH-150...
UMik-1
Download REW

Come back here, ask questions. After proper EQ, perhaps some light room treatment... a SOTA audio system. Yes.

Peace.
Not falling for lies. Going in with eyes wide open, purposely wanting to build a vinyl collection because I miss having one. That's illogical perhaps, but it makes me happy having a routine of going to a record store, crate diving, finding a gem, bringing it home, and physically interacting with the medium while I read the jacket notes.

I am not interested in the UMik-1, or REW. I am nowhere near ready for that type of deep dive, especially for a "use it once" type of vibe. The WiiM Ultra has room correction and an assortment of tools to help me getting the sound just right...and if I don't/can't, that's part of the learning process.
 
Just go full balls deep and buy Genelec 8331a

Do it
Holy s**t. At that price, I'll buy them and just stare at them every day until I can afford a source to feed them. That is way too much speaker for me. That's like Sofia Vergara when all I can actually feel comfortable with is a Julie Bowen.
 
Be kind to the rookie (please). I've been lurking and reading everything I can, putting off my purchases as long as I can bear...and the moment is finally here. First, some details:

Room Details
  • ~5.5-6m sq (small office)
  • just a couple acoustic treatments from GIK (not currently installed as they are on their way)
  • listening distance is ~1-1.25m
  • Disregard the stupid speaker positioning in the picture. I used freeware room design software that expired so I can't change it. The speakers will be next to the TV, and I will be sitting on-axis with a very slight toe-in for the speakers.
View attachment 391757

Budget & Other Details
  • ~€2,500 - €3,000
  • Vinyl, and streaming from Spotify Connect. I want the tactile vinyl experience. Non-negotiable.
  • Saving space by going with active studio monitors, and limiting number of components without sacrificing upgrade paths. Also, monitors with dip switches seem more forgiving of placement near walls.
  • Upgrade paths cannot include larger spaces. My office is my cave, and my wife asserts dominance over design decisions for the rest of the house. My office has a lock for my own safety.
The System
  • Pro-Ject X1 B Turntable (note: getting it price matched to €850 from richersounds.ie)
    • mini-XLR
      • Pro-Ject Phono Box S3 B
        • RCA
          • WiiM Ultra (with HDMI eARC from Samsung Smart TV)
            • RCA
              • Kali IN-5s (not included in the screengrab; I am getting them from Thomann for ~€344/ea)
View attachment 391758
Final Thoughts
  • I considered Neuman KH120 II as an option pretty hard, but that is way too evolved a monitor for my rookie capabilities. I also do not have a personal computer to take full advantage. I will covet them from a distance.
  • I considered Adam A7V pretty hard as well due to their great warranty and various reviews (here as well as elsewhere).
  • I landed on the Kali IN-5 (instead of the IN-8) because of space limitations. Worried I will regret this decision, as I know a sub is out of the question for such a small space, not to mention tricky placement (ex: under the desk is pretty much the only place).
  • I contemplated a WiiM Pro Plus and a Topping A70 Pro as an alternative to the WiiM Ultra, and decided against it because of no HDMI eARC.
  • Room correction through the WiiM app will have to be good enough, as well as the dip switches on the Kalis. I cannot justify the spend on miniDSP products (but appreciate and respect their quality). Maybe a consideration for the future.
So...tell me what you think. I'm excited to actually buy something, just in time for my birthday. Thank you for embracing rookies in this wild and lovely world of HiFi.
I'm gonna second the cable comments - you are planning to pay at least 3x what I would.

Regarding turntable - do you already have a vinyl collection you want to play? If not, I'd strongly suggest thinking hard if you really want to go down that road.
 
Back
Top Bottom