Thanks GaryH for replying. I have an update after testing it quite extensively over the past week. Will try to summarize what I found.
Test Setup
Music App
1) Amazon Music HD/Ultra HD
2) Youtube Music (Always High)
Player
1) MacPro 2020
2) Samsung S21
Headphones
1) Arya
2) 4xx, 6xx (quickly tested these but decided to stick with Arya for all my testing)
Amp
1) THX789
2) Qudelix 5K (Q5K)
Precondition to all testing:
I volume matched using umik-1 (stuffing its head in between the pads centered), playing pink noise from REW and capturing the db levels. This was the only way I could do it without relying on my ears.
Music App Comparison:
I started the first test to figure out if there is any benefit of using Amazon HD vs YTM.
Setup: Mac > THX789 > Arya
I couldn't hear any difference between both. For subsequent tests, I decided to stick with YTM.
DAC/AMP Comparison:
I wanted to get answers to the following questions:
- How does MBP 2020 DAC compare to Apple Dongle/Q5K wired?
- I couldn't pick any difference between any of these 3.
- To be sure, I connected the output of these 3 and ran it via 789 to make sure I was not leaving anything out during the tests. Same thing, no difference at all.
- Apple Dongle ($10) is an absolute beast of a DAC. It has the same level of audible performance (to my ears) as MBP. You can essentially put this in any Desktop/Windows laptop or phone and get amazing audio quality. Absolute bonkers! I was pleasantly surprised.
- I was expecting Q5K to sound a bit different (sound signature maybe?) but it had the same sound as the others.
- Also compared the players here: MBP vs Phone. Again, no difference. It was the same.
- Do we benefit from adding AMP to MBP/Dongle/Q5K?
- With Arya running directly from my MBP/Apple Dongle. I heard no difference compared to adding 789 in the chain.
- Mind you, on Arya with no EQ, I was listening at 90% volume on MBP and 95% volume on my phone. I use EQ with -5.5 gain so it was a bit low on volume. If you don't need/use EQ and don't listen to much of classical music, then just using MBP/Dongle is sufficient. No sonic differences.
- Q5K Wired vs Q5K BT LDAC 990?
- Coming back to my previous post where I mentioned Apple Dongle sounded better than Q5K. It did not. In reality, Q5K was running off BT even when it was wired. My bad, I should have checked it in settings and set the priority right in the app. So conclusion from DAC comparison still holds.
- Coming back to wired vs BT. Both sound 95% same to me. The only difference that I can discern is that with wired:
- Bass is less but much more controlled (which I like). BT seems a touch boomy to my ears, reducing the overall clarity in general.
- The Dynamic range is slightly more. The difference b/w loud parts of the music and quiet parts seems to be higher when wired.
- Mids are brought forward and much more clear.
- Now I don't know why its happening. I got stuck doing this test for 2 hours but reached at the same conclusion again and again with a bunch of different songs. If anyone can chime in and share their experience, it would be great!
Please note these are from my subjective listening so YMMV. A big motivation for doing these tests was to satisfy my own mind. I tried looking for definitive answers about the performance of MBP as a DAC but couldn't find much info. These tests at least confirms that it is an excellent one, if you have efficient headphones you don't even need a DAC/AMP. Heck it can even drive the Arya's without EQ. Please let me know if you have any questions!