• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Open baffle speaker pitfalls

... I could be romanticizing the experience at this point.
This is a good point. There's a nostalgia at play here... Like the first time you expereince a thing - it's just so notable being novel, but in reality maybe hardly worthy of admiration. Still - I think we both agree that the key word here (that we both used) is "fun", and how can fun not also be enjoyable, and thus admirable.
 
Old thread, but still... do I understand correctly, recommended/needed crossover point depends on rather sidewall depth, not on the U-shape or H-shape ?

If depth was 40 cm. crossover point should be around 100Hz, but in case of 20 cm. one can go high as 250Hz ?

Reason being - depth makes kind of "tube" which acts like horn or TL and shorter "tube" lessens the effect ?
 
sorry for late reply, hardly have time for the hobby...

do I understand correctly, recommended/needed crossover point depends on rather sidewall depth, not on the U-shape or H-shape ?
Yes, the cabinet depth is critical for U-, V-, and H-shaped open baffles (OB). Approximately, the cabinet can be considered a half-open tube (a lambda/4 resonator).

The resonance frequency can be estimated with the formula f = c / 4*Depth. For a cabinet with a depth of 0.4 m, this results in a resonance frequency of about 214 Hz, and for a depth of 0.2 m, about 428 Hz in a rough approximation (in reality, the resonance frequency is slightly lower than theoretically calculated).

For U- and V-shaped OBs, the crossover frequency should be well below the resonance frequency (as a guideline, I’d suggest 0.5 to one octave lower, depending on the slope of the crossover filter). So for U-shape cabinet with 0.4m depth, resonance frequency about 214Hz, one octave below would be 100Hz as XO frequency - as you suggested.

In H-shaped OBs, the resonance is symmetrically radiated, which doesn’t impair the dipole character as much, but for the same resonance frequency, it requires double the cabinet depth.

Reason being - depth makes kind of "tube" which acts like horn or TL and shorter "tube" lessens the effect ?
Yes, as mentioned above, for U-, V-, and H-shaped open baffles, the resonance frequency can be roughly estimated by considering them as a half-open tube.
An U-, V- or H-shaped OB design resembles a transmission line (TL) more than a horn when considering the effect of the air's radiation resistance.

In my next post I will provide a comparison of a 1m wide classical/flat OB and a 0.3m wide but 0.35m depth U-shape OB, the "folded version" of the flat OB, to show the differences in more detail.
 
Back
Top Bottom