• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required as is 20 years of participation in forums (not all true). There are daily reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Do Audio Speakers Break-in?

Killingbeans

Major Contributor
Joined
Oct 23, 2018
Messages
3,772
Likes
6,866
Location
Bjerringbro, Denmark.
A lot have been talked for thousands of years, like flat earth….

The idea of a flat Earth was more or less eradicated a couple of millennia ago, making the radical stupidity of the new version way greater.

When the world becomes too complicated for people to handle, they have a tendency to elevate the nonsense in a desperate attempt at bringing things down to their level.

Fairy tales give far less headaches than having to learn stuff.

It also hurts our ego less to go "My speakers changed over time" than "My brain is f¤¤king with me in ways I couldn't imagine".
 

Mart68

Major Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Mar 22, 2021
Messages
2,261
Likes
4,187
Location
England
As with most hi-fi myths it all started with some know-nothing reviewer many years ago who thought he would mention in his review that he let the speakers break-in before starting any 'serious listening'.

It gives the impression, to the uneducated reader, of thoroughness, professionalism, and technical savvy.

It caught on and became the accepted practice to drop into reviews that the equipment (not just speakers) was given time to warm up, break in, settle down and so forth.

Now everything, even nonsense like grounding boxes, needs time to 'bed in'. Regrettably this is just accepted as fact by audiophiles and you read comments like, 'It sounds fantastic I can't wait to hear what it will sound like once I have fifty hours on it!'

Because, of course, it always improves. You even get regular update reports from some users about how it 'sounds now' after 10 hours, 20 hours, 50 hours, 100 hours.

I mean get a life.

It's all very sad but also quite funny.
 

Fowly

Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2023
Messages
11
Likes
16
So what does it say? I don't watch videos :/
He says that driver break-in can make a difference, but it is so minute that it shouldn't be audible. He also says that he worked at JBL before, and they did power tests where new PA drivers were blasting 140dB SPL for multiple hours, as a stress test to make sure they could withstand the power and heat. Even with that, it made no significant difference. He also adds that everything can age, but newer drivers are using materials that should last even longer that what was used in the past.

His explanation for this myth is both because of the time it takes for the brain to adapt to a new pair of speakers, and also the difference that driver temperature makes. People that measure a new driver at cold temperature, feed a loud white noise for hours, and then measure right after, are just measuring the effect of temperature.
 

fpitas

Master Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Jul 7, 2022
Messages
9,077
Likes
12,598
Location
Northern Virginia, USA
Drivers' parameters do change, and quite measurably...if you're a speaker designer. But the parameters that change tend to cancel once the driver is put in the cabinet. So end users won't see much, even if they do measure.

Some driver manufacturers do a driver burn-in, although mostly for QA reasons.
 
Last edited:

Purité Audio

Master Contributor
Industry Insider
Barrowmaster
Forum Donor
Joined
Feb 29, 2016
Messages
8,002
Likes
10,123
Location
London
Phil Ward dropped an 8C that broke it.
Keith
 

jhwalker

Active Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2018
Messages
125
Likes
242
Location
Dallas, Texas
He says that driver break-in can make a difference, but it is so minute that it shouldn't be audible. He also says that he worked at JBL before, and they did power tests where new PA drivers were blasting 140dB SPL for multiple hours, as a stress test to make sure they could withstand the power and heat. Even with that, it made no significant difference. He also adds that everything can age, but newer drivers are using materials that should last even longer that what was used in the past.

His explanation for this myth is both because of the time it takes for the brain to adapt to a new pair of speakers, and also the difference that driver temperature makes. People that measure a new driver at cold temperature, feed a loud white noise for hours, and then measure right after, are just measuring the effect of temperature.
Thank you so much!
 

OldHvyMec

Active Member
Forum Donor
Joined
Oct 5, 2022
Messages
251
Likes
172
His explanation for this myth is both because of the time it takes for the brain to adapt to a new pair of speakers, and also the difference that driver temperature makes. People that measure a new driver at cold temperature, feed a loud white noise for hours, and then measure right after, are just measuring the effect of temperature.
All equipment need to be brought up to operating temperature before turning up the volume. No different than anything else that has moving parts
or is building and dissipating heat. There is a lot of equipment that is made for harsh, quick movements and there is equipment that depends on very
smooth, detailed and precise movement. BOTH require a warm-up to be able to maintain those qualities.

That warm-up period is also what contributed to the equipment's life, LONGTERM.

30 minutes to warm up equipment from preamp tubes to TWO different size voice coils in a single sub driver should be more than enough time to get
consistent performance without deviations. When equipment passes IM (infant mortality), breaks-in, is serviced correctly, those warm-up times decrease
and become more consistent with the environment they are in. Stereo gear and electronics in a room comfortable enough to set in is more that ample
to keep equipment safe from extreme cold start-up issues.

Mid life failures are usually poor AC voltage feeds. The reason for a maintainer and a FAST acting surge suppressor. 105-120vac wasn't uncommon
in my neighborhood in the summer. Low voltage is a killer for a lot of equipment and plugging into a wall receptacle without protection will
insure one thing, little if any LOW voltage protection.

All wood product breath until they are SEALED. That sealing is inside and out. If the speaker breathes through ports, surrounds, leakage and unsealed
surfaces it changes in accordance with what it's breathing and the material that is moving the air. Untreated paper, to woven carbon fiber (shark skin).
Materials prone to absorption will increase the dampening in high humidity areas and if its seasonal it's worse. Where I live, is BAD for ported speakers,
if you're subject to Delta "Tule Fog." The water is brackish and the fog is year round in some places. You will know when you get a set of those speakers
the metal will rust and the wood will swell. I've seen at least 12-15 pairs of great speakers ruined by coastal, misty, foggy, moist conditions like house
boat speakers.

I keep reading about "Myths." Depends where your from. Breaking-in is as real as a person's understanding of what it is.
The slowing down of wear through the reduction of resistance from the components parts (surrounds and spiders), not the environment.

Good example of longer breakin times vs lower break-in times. Nothing is written in stone as far as how long it takes.
THICK Butyl Rubber surrounds vs pleated silks. 50 hours or more vs less than the time to warm up a voice coil, 30 minutes or less.
The question is: is break-in or normal wear happening or is there something else contributing to shorter equipment life and the quality
of that service life for the user?

I like Rolls Royce, while breaking in Rolls leather to my bottom would be a bit of an issue, I could live with it. Good leather gloves, they just
fit one day, just like a glove. :)

Happy harvest!

Regards
 
Last edited:

fpitas

Master Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Jul 7, 2022
Messages
9,077
Likes
12,598
Location
Northern Virginia, USA

Fowly

Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2023
Messages
11
Likes
16
I keep reading about "Myths." Depends where your from. Breaking-in is as real as a person's understanding of what it is.
The slowing down of wear through the reduction of resistance from the components parts (surrounds and spiders), not the environment.
I don't think anyone will disagree with what you said, but the "myth" is that breaking-in a speaker is absolutely necessary for them to operate in the way their intended. It's different from a warmup that needs to be done everytime you power on the speakers. This is supposed to be done one time only, and we are yet to see an example of a speaker out from the factory where this process makes a significant difference.

So it isn't a myth because it's not real (it is, it can sometimes be measured), it's a myth because it's inaudible, which was the point of the engineer from Kali/JBL. He also said the same for fresh single drivers, but maybe he just didn't run into one that needs this.
 

Head_Unit

Major Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Aug 27, 2018
Messages
1,281
Likes
642
Phil Ward dropped an 8C that broke it.
Keith
Did the parameters change? ;)

I will call this a myth because there is no way I will agree that physical changes from playing music or noise or whatever at any sane levels will "break in" the SOUND out of the speakers, and that is really what proponents are saying, that the speakers will "sound different" meaning physically not p

There can absolutely be physical changes, and I've measured them, but unless the woofer design is what I would consider defective the parameter change is small and gradual and then as @fpitas says the cabinet then reduces that effect further. See also
https://www.audioholics.com/loudspeaker-design/speaker-break-in-fact-or-fiction
and note that the "changes" measured after "break-in" might well be no different than just measuring the unbroken driver day after day after day.

Therefore sorry believers, it's literally all in your head. Which doesn't mean you can't like the speakers more!
 
Last edited:

Lsc

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 27, 2020
Messages
392
Likes
362
Whether a speaker break-in is a myth or not is a pretty small point and is irrelevant to most folks.

Unlike high end cables that people can potentially spend thousands on with no benefit.

Now if someone is saying a $20k speakers is no better than $2k speakers- that would be a much more beneficial conversation if it were true.
 

YSC

Major Contributor
Joined
Dec 31, 2019
Messages
2,982
Likes
2,325
Whether a speaker break-in is a myth or not is a pretty small point and is irrelevant to most folks.

Unlike high end cables that people can potentially spend thousands on with no benefit.

Now if someone is saying a $20k speakers is no better than $2k speakers- that would be a much more beneficial conversation if it were true.
hum~ but it could potentially cause the consumer to run the new gear at excessive level for extended time just to "break it it quickly before listen", wastes power, annoy neighbour/wife, and reducing the useful life of components if it was ever a concern.
 

DonR

Major Contributor
Joined
Jan 25, 2022
Messages
2,389
Likes
4,392
Location
Vancouver(ish)
It is worth talking about because subjective reviews (on which some people base buying decisions) often promote this myth claiming permanent alteration in sound after extended periods of listening.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MAB

MAB

Major Contributor
Joined
Nov 15, 2021
Messages
1,742
Likes
3,723
Location
Portland, OR, USA
Whether a speaker break-in is a myth or not is a pretty small point and is irrelevant to most folks.

Unlike high end cables that people can potentially spend thousands on with no benefit.

Now if someone is saying a $20k speakers is no better than $2k speakers- that would be a much more beneficial conversation if it were true.
I would agree, except lots of YouTube videos show speakers driven to max for extended time. This is wear-out. One of the videos posted earlier in this thread is some believer driving a woofer to maximum excursion for 30 hours, which is wear-out or breakage for no gain. Scanning random forums, I see recommendations for putting speakers face to face and driving them out of phase at full beans to break them in.o_O This is crazy, the waste is blown and worn out drivers, and the tolerance of everyone within earshot! So I do lump speaker break-in in with the mega-wasteful things that audiophiles do.
 

Lsc

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 27, 2020
Messages
392
Likes
362
I would agree, except lots of YouTube videos show speakers driven to max for extended time. This is wear-out. One of the videos posted earlier in this thread is some believer driving a woofer to maximum excursion for 30 hours, which is wear-out or breakage for no gain. Scanning random forums, I see recommendations for putting speakers face to face and driving them out of phase at full beans to break them in.o_O This is crazy, the waste is blown and worn out drivers, and the tolerance of everyone within earshot! So I do lump speaker break-in in with the mega-wasteful things that audiophiles do.
You are right…that would be stupid. No one ever said breaking in speakers is to play at full volume. For those people, there is no hope and it’s most likely an edge case. But for the rest of the normal people, I still stand by that speaker break-in is a non-factor. Folks will buy speakers based on the sound they hear, not based on how well it breaks-in.

There are those retailers- almost all - who say listen to how good these speakers sound and they are not even broken in yet etc etc lol.

I’m just trying to stop the gospel according to speaker break-in is a myth crusade because it doesn’t buy much. The best is when someone buys speakers used but still needed to be broken using their amps since that combo wasn’t used before hehehe.
 
Top Bottom