When people say ASR is full of impolite, unhinged cultists who treat Amir like a messiah, they are referring to posts like this.
Whatever you think of Stereophile and its methodology and sins (and I’ve been plenty blunt myself),
@John Atkinson himself is an unfailingly kind man who doesn’t deserve to be likened to a “rat” caught lying on the witness stand. To say that’s uncalled for is a huge understatement.
Plus, you have to remember that without JA’s work these past decades, we’d have no measurements at all on a countless number of products. I imagine he’s had to fight to keep measurements a part of Stereophile many, many times. Yes, I also think he lets too many manufacturers off the hook in his brief wrap-up comments, but his graphs are the only speck of Stereophile that is free from marketing spin.
Adding a whole “don’t you
ever compare yourself to Amir, mister!” spin on things just makes you come off a bit crazy or overly emotionally invested and makes us look bad.