If you don't understand the circuit or the OpAmp specs you are basically engaging in a lucky-dip activity. Same with tube rolling.
But what happens when some conditions are not specified in the datasheet? And spice model doesn't include distortion.
First hunt down to a few parts and compare the performance of them in the circuit, how wrong is that?
Stable with 10nF load in simulation
Flat open loop output impedance
Low noise low distortion with 2kohm load at least
Better have performance with lower impedance load
100ma current output capacity
Most opamps don't specify performance with low impedance load like opa1622, tpa6120 etc But they also have their own issues. AGAIN what's so wrong about component rolling with measurements? Douglas Self has done it, basically everyone does it. Take measurements first then you can try to explain some phenomenon that causes the results.