I'm pretty sure I would have an idea if it's on or off, especially when it's in the +4dB position, because it fattens and saturates the sound. I think of it as it harmonic saturation which to me is "warmth".
I really do love my system without the tube so using it is just for fun. I'm not a fan of distortion generally but this little thing definitely can add something to music. I find it works well to "enhance" some recordings more so than others. (I do wonder if the fun factor will go away over time and I'll get bored of this, though?) It's just not practical to go the full tube pre-amp route right now (I was looking at the PrimaLuna EVO 100 pre since it has two sets of outputs and a remote), because I don't like using any tubes with home theater, and my setup is for both music and movies/tv. So the tube buffer idea seemed to make sense.
I'm actually trying to get away from tubes. I used to own more tube gear and had a small collection of tubes but got tired of the distortion and all the tube rolling options so I sold all of it. I only kept my tube headphone amp. But somehow the tube gear crept back into my speaker system. I guess I'm a fan of tubes. I like 1950's audio recordings a lot too.