- Joined
- Jan 27, 2019
- Messages
- 7,291
- Likes
- 12,203
If you are seriously arguing that it is impossible to communicate effectively about sonics in an audio production environment using verbal language, then aren't you just arguing for some variety of willful autism?
This is a re-hash of the "warm" thread where some insisted it was impossible to assign useful meaning to commonly used idioms because said meanings depended on context. As if humans aren't aware of immediate context in a working environment, and correlate language accordingly, etc.
Very well put!
This is of a piece with the "Useless To Me = Useless For Thee" false generalizations.
The fact someone doesn't care to understand, for instance, what musicians mean in reference to musical nomenclature (e.g. Adagio, Forte etc) doesn't render those terms meaningless or useless. That's more about the individual rejecting those tools. You can't force anyone to accept the terms. But if someone rejects them, you just go on to get work done using them among people who care to understand the context and relevance.