I have top notch analogue, Goldmund Reference, T3f arm Ortofon A90, also 3 others from EMT, Roksan and B&O.
I also own a plethora of DACs from dCS, Chord, Metric Halo, Resolution Audio, Goldmund, SMSL and RME.
I find all 4 turntables sound different to each other.
When I level match compared some of the DACs all the differences I thought I heard turned out not to exist.
What was audible though was the effect of reconstruction filters, when they were switchable like on the dCS, but with the normal filter they were all the same sounding. I do know people who prefer the sound with an inaccurate reconstruction filter, I don’t.
I wish I had learned this years ago, I would have saved a lot of money.
Whether the turntable sounds better or digital depends far more on the actual recording, not the medium, IME.
I have superb CDs and awful ones.
I have superb LPs and awful ones.
The reality is that sound quality is much more dependant on the source recording than DACs and good turntables.