Complicated is not the same as valid. The title "scientist" doesn't convey an inability to publish bad science.This is a big site and it will probably take a long while for me to dissect everything. So you don't agree with Kunchur? But he is a scientist with credentials? Otherwise he wouldn't be posting papers like this I'm assuming. So you do not agree with his conclusions or are you suggesting he is a quack? Help me to understand this a little better because as a layman when I read his paper it seemed pretty complicated and I think has references for his work.