Lol I'm an idiot
-
Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!
Hifiman Edition XS
- Thread starter mr.at
- Start date
Hi, these sound really interesting. Just wondering if someone who owns these can tell me the approximate dimensions of the ear pads and particularly the recess? It's always the case but for something you have to wear on your head (and your ears) it's surprising how hard this information is to find sometimes!
Dekoni aftermarket pads provide the dimensions at the bottom of the product page for each of their products.
So you won't get the depth of the pads, as that could be different. But look for the pads for the Edition XS on their website to find out the size of the recess.
They’re not similar headphones in application.
The HE6 is supposed to be a phenomenal headphone if it has enough power; whereas the XS is easier to drive and Mikey fine with a portable amp. Most comparisons are between the Sundara, Ananda and XS.
Thanks. I am aware of the difference. I am looking for sound impression from those who have owned both. I am interested in the XS because it is the latest. I am interested in the HE6SE just because I want to use the high gain option on my amp, lol.
Carlo2AC
Active Member
Why? high gain is usually worse in most setups in regards to SNR, THD, etc
Carlo2AC
Active Member
For sound impressions Resolve has published a review recently, as always.. take the subjective side with a grain of salt.
I have both (grill modded v2 too). I prefer and reach for the XS 9 times out of 10.
The biggest draw of the V2 is the substantial bass impact... but the XS can match it and physically rumble the housing with enough subbass. The XS wins at just about every other area (Soundstage, Imaging, etc), especially if you boost the mids a bit via EQ and cut the peak in the highs a bit.
Ah, that's good to know because I have already ordered a XS. I like when a company put out a new product that outperform more expensive older products.
DavidCondit
New Member
- Joined
- Feb 3, 2022
- Messages
- 1
- Likes
- 0
@mr.at can you advise how to remove the ear cups from the band? I just bought the XS a couple days ago and find the band to be uncomfortable. I'd like to remove the cups and swap the band, but I'm not 100% sure if I just press them off or what. Also, would you happen to know what kind of band I could buy to replace the stock band? The suspension bands look interesting... they seem like they'd be more comfortable on my head but introduce more clamp on my ears.
- Joined
- May 15, 2019
- Messages
- 1,091
- Likes
- 4,608
Yep. I did not see distortion measurements so far. Anyone?
Nothing I have seen. Maybe @Resolve took them already? Don’t see them in his review.
Last edited:
- Joined
- May 15, 2019
- Messages
- 1,091
- Likes
- 4,608
This one looked too promising - ordered one for below 400 bucks at AliExpress. I hope it works for my ears as it does for so many others. And not seeing horrible distortion and group delay plots later on from amirm...
I am with you on that. I just purchased mine direct from Hifiman. $480 usd. Plus an extra 6 months warranty for free.
You could sell both and just have 1 pair of the XS. Worth it!
IMO THD is a bit of a red herring, as has been demonstrated by multiple papers on the subject (the Temme & Olive paper, or the Geddes & Lee to name a few important ones). But there are times when it's worth noting it, like if it's bad enough to be audible or cause problems for important EQ adjustments for a given headphone.
For the Edition XS, no such issues showed up, but with that said, here's a result around 95dB:
You see some 2nd and 3rd harmonic stuff there but again, not at all audible.
Edit: You could expect it to be higher with higher volume level of course, but as mentioned, you'll never hear that with music. For those who are seeking the lowest THD they can find, you can certainly find better out there, it's just not a windmill I'll be tilting at.
Last edited:
Similar threads
