svart-hvitt
Major Contributor
- Joined
- Aug 31, 2017
- Messages
- 2,375
- Likes
- 1,253
The challenge thread at PS Audio:
https://forum.psaudio.com/t/ethan-winers-challenge/8639/14
«His reference system at home is reported to be a vintage Crown 300A and a pair of JBLs of some vintage type. It’s no wonder he doesn’t hear any differences».
Mr. Mcgowan
And there’s more:
«I believe the null test is a great way to determine if there is or isn’t a difference (not giving much information about what the differences are).
But, Ethan snips a piece out of the context of the whole system and expects there to be something different at the single output. This doesn’t account for any number of possibilities that can affect the system itself.
The only ethical way to do this is through the entire system using a system that you can actually
hear the differences on. I don’t believe he possesses such a system and if he did he’s certainly not doing this test properly.
His findings are meaningless.
He’s not actually attempting to find out why we hear a difference, just working hard at proving his own theory there isn’t one is right.
And, I understand the logic. Which is why I am ignoring him».
https://forum.psaudio.com/t/ethan-winers-challenge/8639/14
«His reference system at home is reported to be a vintage Crown 300A and a pair of JBLs of some vintage type. It’s no wonder he doesn’t hear any differences».
Mr. Mcgowan
And there’s more:
«I believe the null test is a great way to determine if there is or isn’t a difference (not giving much information about what the differences are).
But, Ethan snips a piece out of the context of the whole system and expects there to be something different at the single output. This doesn’t account for any number of possibilities that can affect the system itself.
The only ethical way to do this is through the entire system using a system that you can actually
hear the differences on. I don’t believe he possesses such a system and if he did he’s certainly not doing this test properly.
His findings are meaningless.
He’s not actually attempting to find out why we hear a difference, just working hard at proving his own theory there isn’t one is right.
And, I understand the logic. Which is why I am ignoring him».