- Thread Starter
- #121
I actually find this one of the most adequate and reasonable judgements a good reviewer should apply to any speaker (and a consumer should keep in mind as well):
1) A mere glance at the [speaker] “spin-o-rama” curves would likely be misleading as to the tonal sense that these speakers impart in real-world listening. If I had judged it only from this graph, I would not have guessed that I would like the [speaker] as much as I did.
2) The [speakers] deserve more than a superficial analysis of measurements. This isn’t to say measurements aren’t indicative of how the speaker will sound, but rather that these need a deeper dive to get a full understanding of how they behave in real-world situations. Despite the erratic anechoic frequency responses, the [speakers] sounded good and measured well in my room, even when compared to a nearly perfect reference speaker.
That doesn't mean that any speaker with subpar measurements sound good.
But as far as all the "awfulness" happening with OPALs and some other speakers keeps within +-3 dB, one must be really not very bright to make bold statements by just looking at graphs only. "Reeee $100 Micca is better" etc
But oh wait, it sells so well nowadays
Much respect for the reviewer.
Have not heard these personally, but they may sound decent. If I was interested though, would put more faith in Erin as reviewers go. If no subjective reviews are available, then am thankful for the measurements. Parts Express measurements are woefully lacking for a contemporary speaker.
I get that many will choose what speakers they like over accuracy. Many do the same with electronics. I can respect freedom of choice, am just not likely to buy or recommend if the measurements are lacking. I can also respect Larson’s overall efforts but not accept his subjective opinions. I do not always agree with Erin’s (or Amir’s) subjective reviews either. Am also not a fan of gloss black finishes so would not spend my time or money to order these even if I can easily return them.
As for the Micca MB42X, it does measure well AND is only $100 but would need a subwoofer for low bass. In any case, would be comparing OPAL1 to other speakers around the same price if I were in the market. Since I know I can find good sound AND better measurements for around that price, the OPAL1 is not a standout in that respect. That said, it may be decent tradeoff for someone else.
Last edited: