That is not an answer to the question I am asking you.
My question does not involve processes on the recording side of the chain. In fact I specifically limited the question to the playback part of the audio chain.
Again, never said it was and again this is not an answer to my question.
Really? Your replay system has no added cross talk? How did you manage to prevent any of the sound coming from the left speaker from entering your right ear and any of the sound from the right speaker from entering your left ear? You must be listening on headphones then. Because I am pretty sure that no loudspeaker system/playback room completely prevents this sort of cross talk. Only headphones do that.
I have no idea what you are asking. You have been told my views on the subject (which appear to be shared by others here and supported by research), yet you repeatedly keep trying to argue points regarding the recording side of the chain. These points are acknowledged, however are not considered relevant to the validity of neutral playback.
No you didnt provide a cogent argument against Tooles research. You keep trying to misconstrue what is said by implying everything is and has to be related to the original performance as would be heard by an individual if they were in that space. How many times do you have to be told that is not the case?
Oh BTW this crosstalk is a complete red herring. Any speaker monitoring will have crosstalk. In a studio or at home. Whats your point? My room has known acoustic properties, I designed it to minimally interfere with the sound. To make it as neutral as possible. This will not sound identical to the studio. We do not know what the studios acoustic or speaker properties. This however has no relevance to the validity of a neutral speaker and system.
Last edited: