You failed to understand the experiment where listeners were given a choice to adjust the LF and HF levels to their preference (which most of them did)
Ignoring these?
And the end result:
To the contrary, all of my philosophy is based upon the science that has been presented to me (I'm not claiming to be any trailblazer with new information that people should believe
over the science, as many here are).
Maybe you missed it, but I have stated several times that I am in agreement with Toole that there is nothing wrong with broad, smooth, tone controls users may adjust to their preference and/or make up for program material that is lacking in some way. That is something completely different than what you are advocating--EQing to steady state measurements that include late arriving reflections. They aren't the same thing.
ignoring the relation of PIR (calculated from LW, ER and SP)
Ignoring the relation of PIR to ....? You didn't finish the thought.
and your simplifcation of the direct sound response represented by on-axis pseudo-ancechoic measurement.
You mean the exact same way Olive and Toole both did in the pictures above? Forgive me for agreeing with them. Like I said, I'm not the one to pick apart their research, contradict them or call them wrong until I have enough science of my own to back it up and feel qualified to do so.
Btw, once you put your speaker in the room and let it play anything you should be aware that on-axis, LW, ER and SP are not there - there is only PIR,
Again, this comes from the basic misunderstanding of what was explained above. The direct sound and indirect sound (even late arriving)
ARE all there. Your microphone may not distinguish without specific gating techniques,
but your brain will.
which correlates with steady state response, and your brain, interperting the sound collected by your ears in your own way.
If you believe your ears interpret the sound
in you own way, different from what the science shows for normal human beings...OK. Upon what do you base this conclusion?
View attachment 53245
Maybe it would be polite to say I'll say I miss you, but that's simply not true.
I'm not sure what to do with that. I can't remember the 8th grade very well.