• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required as is 20 years of participation in forums (not all true). There are daily reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

How Bad are those MTM Center Speakers in Practice in Reality? Revel C25 Content Inside

Do we objectively make too much of horizontal MTM designs in real-world applications?

  • Yep

    Votes: 9 36.0%
  • Nope

    Votes: 16 64.0%

  • Total voters
    25

gbrnole

Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2022
Messages
29
Likes
25
A plot showing, say 25 degrees, is greater than +/- 18 degrees.
(I.e. You do not need to double the values as it is relative to being “off of the centerline”.)
yeah the total width in all listening positions across my seating area is 36 degrees (actually a hair under that) so 18 degrees from center to each of the left most and right most seating positions. for most of the MTM centers you are hard pressed to find anything that doesn't begin to have serious off axis issues beyond 10 degrees from center - 20 degrees total.

vertically the center speaker is 7.6 degrees below my ear level but i do tilt the front speaker and use a laser pointer to angle up towards ear level to negate that. i have about ten inches of height space to work with for the center speaker but that is reduced when the speaker is angled.

ideally i'd love to be able to use a revel c208 but i just don't have the space for that. a c25 or a c205 would fit comfortably but i would prefer a little larger woofer in the 6 to 6.5" range. i have pondered just grabbing a kef q350, laying it on its side and calling it a day. the only real downside to that is to get the most out of a q350 you need equalization in the higher frequency region so it leaves me a bit apprehensive. ARC genesis will smooth that region but it will also color the sound of the speaker in doing it.
 

Holmz

Major Contributor
Joined
Oct 3, 2021
Messages
1,089
Likes
645
Location
Australia
yeah the total width in all listening positions across my seating area is 36 degrees (actually a hair under that) so 18 degrees from center to each of the left most and right most seating positions. for most of the MTM centers you are hard pressed to find anything that doesn't begin to have serious off axis issues beyond 10 degrees from center - 20 degrees total.
I ended up getting a used center channel
(+/- 40 degrees)

The center has one job, which is a wide radiation pattern.
The rest can be fixed with a DSP.

vertically the center speaker is 7.6 degrees below my ear level but i do tilt the front speaker and use a laser pointer to angle up towards ear level to negate that. i have about ten inches of height space to work with for the center speaker but that is reduced when the speaker is angled.

ideally i'd love to be able to use a revel c208 but i just don't have the space for that. a c25 or a c205 would fit comfortably but i would prefer a little larger woofer in the 6 to 6.5" range. i have pondered just grabbing a kef q350, laying it on its side and calling it a day. the only real downside to that is to get the most out of a q350 you need equalization in the higher frequency region so it leaves me a bit apprehensive. ARC genesis will smooth that region but it will also color the sound of the speaker in doing it.

Another nuance is that if the MTM is different from the L/R sides, then its sound may be out of phase with them in certain bands as the drivers can be out of phase.
Best to stick with the same brand IMO.
 
Last edited:

FrantzM

Major Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Mar 12, 2016
Messages
3,172
Likes
5,035
Thanks, and for the record I’m still married. :)

Here is the back wall with panels having a 9cm air gap.

The room layout is not that good, but it is the only one that works.

View attachment 180284
Could you tell us more about the Acoustic treatments ? Front and rear...They look uber-cool :) >
Heck! Your entire room is beautiful :D . Congrats!
 

Trell

Major Contributor
Joined
May 13, 2021
Messages
1,402
Likes
1,453
Could you tell us more about the Acoustic treatments ? Front and rear...They look uber-cool :) >
Heck! Your entire room is beautiful :D . Congrats!

Thanks!

The panels are made by GIK Acoustics, EU subsidiary. The flat panels are 10cm (4”) thick, and all of them have scatter plates in order to not absorb so much HF. The flat panels on the back wall have an air gap of 9 cm. About 50% of the front and back wall is covered with panels.

The links below will redirect depending on your location.




 
Last edited:

Colonel7

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2020
Messages
491
Likes
647
Location
Maryland, USA
What if I always get the center seat, and none of my family members care about any of this stuff?

What if my 9 year-old bounces around all over the place, and my wife falls asleep after 30 minutes of whatever we are watching?
Nice thread and thanks for the measurements in application. Based on this though, isn't the rationale that they don't know any better, or that they haven't heard a 3-way or coaxial, or that you won't give up the dad seat? Or it is in fact not a big deal? Maybe as an experiment for a few weeks you sit in one of the end couch positions, or during each movie at a specific time you play musical chairs and switch seats without pausing.

Very timely! Just finished the prototype cabinet today and time to start on the crossover. And if you look carefully please note the wall is a special new paint color called ASR brown. :cool:
20220202_141419.jpg
 

luft262

Senior Member
Forum Donor
Joined
Mar 25, 2021
Messages
357
Likes
170
Location
Phoenix
Here are my 2 cents...

I think the main pros of a center channel over just using the mains would be better off axis sound quality and the ability to increase the volume of voices. Using a bookshelf might mess up the TV's position and it will look strange to anyone who doesn't frequent this site (lol!) and even some of those. Getting a center channel that doesn't match your mains might work OK, but might not. Timbre may or may not be a thing. I've had a system with a non-matching center, a system with a matching center, and my current system has no center. I can't really say how sound quality was affected, because I wan't comparing them back to back and it was years ago. I can say that having a center channel allows you to boost the volume of voices in movies and shows and my wife especially really likes that. When I watch movies alone I can crank it, but she usually likes dynamic volume on and the center channel turned up +3dB, or at least she did with our old system, since the center was available.

I guess if you have people who care about the sound sitting off center and/or if you have someone who wants the center turned up for voices then you'll benefit from a center channel. But unless you regularly have off axis listeners who actually care about audio the type of center channel won't matter much so I'm going to vote with "we're overthinking it!" I'll probably throw my hat in with getting the matching center channel to the mains for aesthetics if nothing else.
 

Descartes

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Joined
Dec 27, 2020
Messages
861
Likes
406
Too bad Erin didn’t include the C25 in his center channel shoot-out!

Amir’s position “Without EQ and for center usage, I can't recommend the Revel C25….”
 
Top Bottom