• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

A tube buffer that gives tube sound.

After owning and building and rebuilding tube and SS amps I am a skeptic that tube sound even exists in properly functioning and well designed tube equipment. In a level matched blind test I set up I could not hear a difference between a Dynaco ST 70 and a Neurochrome Mod 86. If a tube buffer or tube pre-amp is actually audible I would contend it is "broken" either by design or actually an electrical fault.

While I could not hear a difference, power amps, due to their higher output impedance will have a different frequency response than a SS amp which is speaker dependent. See below some measurements I took when doing a level matched blind test with the Neurochrome and Dynaco. You can see there is a FR difference between the two, which while not audible to me could possible be to some people. This graph also shows the Neurochrome with a 0.9 Ohm resistor in series with the speaker. In that case the FR is almost identical to the Dynaco.

My advice to the OP is be very skeptical about "tube sound" despite what you read on the internet. While a pain I would verify that any difference you think you hear can be verified in a blind level matched test. The power and confidence you will gain by hearing for yourself what differences you can or can not hear (all the "night and day" difference your read on the internet are for the most part a joke) are huge and will keep you on track for making real upgrades to your system rather than expensive detours. In any case have fun.

Add Resistance.jpg
 
I'm currently enjoy a Hagerman Baritone Tube Buffer and while browsing amazon I found this:

HiFi PRT09A Tube Buffer Preamplifier Stereo Vacuum (Silver, with EH-6922 Tube)​



Does this look like a quality piece of tube gear?
 
I'm currently enjoy a Hagerman Baritone Tube Buffer and while browsing amazon I found this:

HiFi PRT09A Tube Buffer Preamplifier Stereo Vacuum (Silver, with EH-6922 Tube)​



Does this look like a quality piece of tube gear?
The pictures show a reasonable build quality. The schematic of the Musical Fidelity X-10 D seems OK to me. The plate voltage is not high, so I don't know whether the tubes work in their best working point. Of course I have no idea how this buffer sounds. For the medium price a try may be OK.
 
There's a tweak by @pkane you can tune in any distorsion desired, not?
 
Back
Top Bottom