Yamaha’s TX-950 should be high on your list. It was Yamaha’s last high-end tuner and for some reason gets no respect, even though it specs better than the vaunted Onkyo T-9090 II.
In the tuner review I referenced above, Modafferi and Rich both had good things to say about the TX-950. I bought one based on their review (to match the Yamaha integrated amplifier Rich reviewed). Although I never used it much, after a few years one of the capacitors leaked black gunk all over the circuit board. Who knows if it was just my lucky day, or if there were some component problems with that model? I never investigated or attempted to fix it, because FM wasn't really something I was interested in.
Don't most FM stations stream over the Internet? That would be something I'd be looking in to, if it was important to me.
Of all the old analog sources from my hi-fi years, I'd rate FM right up there with open reel as being totally useless. On the other hand, at least an FM tuner won't cost you an arm and a leg to use and keep going, like open reel. Personally, I always thought the '70s era Pioneer tuners (9100, 9500, etc) looked very nice in an equipment cabinet. But there were a lot of nice looking FM tuners from that era.