• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Fosi v3 Mono - User Impressions | Owner's Thread

I feel massively vindicated here because clearly there was no damn bias involved when I reported this in the first place, yet ASR members decided it was necessary to hound me and blame my report on some mental bias when I made it clear that i
Yes the difference in bass got me interested in making Rew measurements as there was more difference than expected. Otherwise it was just a boring subwoofer leveling mission (which was not needed anyway, the gain in amps is nearly the same).
 
I sure would like to know more about testing those very opamps that cause so much consternation on here.

The only comparison to date as far as I can tell was between two boutique ones that measured very similarly on another site. I'll have to look it up (the site and the opamps reviewed here).

And science has a lot of examples of group think (historically) ... I think.
The really easy way for your own use?
Just put your mic nearfield to get more direct sound (50 cm for a bookself,more for a tower) and get one measurement for each opamp.
Don't touch the mic or anything in the room during the comparison,etc.

If it's audible,the difference will be there to see.

Now the best way would be electrically,but don't bother,others did it before (me included) and the differences are so small that no audibility can be justified.
 
I feel massively vindicated here because clearly there was no damn bias involved when I reported this in the first place, yet ASR members decided it was necessary to hound me and blame my report on some mental bias when I made it clear that it was IMPOSSIBLE to NOT hear it.

-Ed
You'll remember one of my suggestions was to check the polarity on the Fosi. ;)
 
You'll remember one of my suggestions was to check the polarity on the Fosi. ;)
You’ll remember I said that was the first thing I checked. They were wired correctly. Regrettably, I did not attempt running it in the wrong manner just to see.

-Ed
 
The really easy way for your own use?
Just put your mic nearfield to get more direct sound (50 cm for a bookself,more for a tower) and get one measurement for each opamp.
Don't touch the mic or anything in the room during the comparison,etc.

If it's audible,the difference will be there to see.

Now the best way would be electrically,but don't bother,others did it before (me included) and the differences are so small that no audibility can be justified.
I can imagine this would be the case. I mean audibly most of my own (admittedly very minor forays) have suggested exactly this. Nope, none (justifiable audibility). But that is with listening. Can't hear any difference. Move on.

Because I come from the vinyl world where capacitance matters with cables etc. and because I think volume controls can influence the sound of an entire system, I wonder about impedance, and indeed anything else anyone might like to mention with this particular cocktail.

Digital outputs to amplifier inputs - all seems fine and dandy.

I have one example of FET vs Bipolar and it really niggles at me. So I see the monos as a way to test.
If I can muster up the energy in the next few months!

You see on ASR we need measurement afficionados to interact (like you have). And not preach. :)
 
You’ll remember I said that was the first thing I checked. They were wired correctly. Regrettably, I did not attempt running it in the wrong manner just to see.

-Ed
My suggestion specifically was
Back to this - have you checked (for example) that one of the amps isn't inverting the signal where the second does not? Then you'd have a clear reason for an audible difference.
IE to check the amps, not necessarily your wiring. I'm not trying to criticise you here that you didn't, I'm just pointing out I was trying to work with you to find a cause - as well as informing you about how misleading bias can be.
 
My suggestion specifically was

IE to check the amps, not necessarily your wiring. I'm not trying to criticise you here that you didn't, I'm just pointing out I was trying to work with you to find a cause - as well as informing you about how misleading bias can be.
This is extremely difficult to test, and I most definitely do not have the appropriate equipment necessary to test this. One needs a method to test the output from both amps simultaneously to ensure there is an actual delta-T between signals. As it was simply fixing an amp for my dad and then sending it off, the only qualifier was, “it makes sound.” I already put enough into gifting him the amps (with expensive, discrete **-**** rolled into them), and was not about to blow even more budget on expensive testing equipment—not to mention we were both anxious to get the amp back to the post office and in its way back to him ASAP, so taking time to acquire said testing equipment and perform the testing simply adds even more delay—my dad just wants to listen to his new amps already, man!

-Ed
 
I can imagine this would be the case. I mean audibly most of my own (admittedly very minor forays) have suggested exactly this. Nope, none (justifiable audibility). But that is with listening. Can't hear any difference. Move on.

Because I come from the vinyl world where capacitance matters with cables etc. and because I think volume controls can influence the sound of an entire system, I wonder about impedance, and indeed anything else anyone might like to mention with this particular cocktail.

Digital outputs to amplifier inputs - all seems fine and dandy.

I have one example of FET vs Bipolar and it really niggles at me. So I see the monos as a way to test.
If I can muster up the energy in the next few months!

You see on ASR we need measurement afficionados to interact (like you have). And not preach. :)
To tell the whole story here,there are cases that such a change can be audible.
But I wish no one will come to experience it as this case will be something that messes things big time,very possible with a circuit not designed around the different opamp or put wrongly or bended feet touching each other or fake or bad (a good percentage is) ,etc

So a sanity measurement can be of use there too.
 
This is extremely difficult to test, and I most definitely do not have the appropriate equipment necessary to test this. One needs a method to test the output from both amps simultaneously to ensure there is an actual delta-T between signals. As it was simply fixing an amp for my dad and then sending it off, the only qualifier was, “it makes sound.” I already put enough into gifting him the amps (with expensive, discrete **-**** rolled into them), and was not about to blow even more budget on expensive testing equipment—not to mention we were both anxious to get the amp back to the post office and in its way back to him ASAP, so taking time to acquire said testing equipment and perform the testing simply adds even more delay—my dad just wants to listen to his new amps already, man!

-Ed

No issue - as I said my intent is not to criticise the not checking. But to counter the...
yet ASR members decided it was necessary to hound me and blame my report on some mental bias
Perhaps some members were doing this - I didn't read them all - and if they were, perhaps in that context my posts came across the same way. However my intent was to point out that your impression could be because of bias - in spite of how clear the difference you heard was, while ALSO suggesting other possible causes for you to investigate if you cared to.
 
To tell the whole story here,there are cases that such a change can be audible.
But I wish no one will come to experience it as this case will be something that messes things big time,very possible with a circuit not designed around the different opamp or put wrongly or bended feet touching each other or fake or bad (a good percentage is) ,etc

So a sanity measurement can be of use there too.
Yes I had one of these big time mess ups where (they were correctly inserted) there was excessive bass. My subwoofers had to be cut right back so I just got rid of them immediately and went back.

But this example is a diversion. I have only tested a small number of op amps. The ones above I can't remember. OPA1656, another I will have to remind myself of, Muses02 and 01. And the industry standard types like the default ones here.

The FETs vs Bipolars experience were Muses01s v Muses02s. The latter are recommended for these v3 monos.

I had listening bias perhaps (but I am not sure what my bias should have been).

So I hope to blind test at some point. Nail this one for myself using monos.

I preferred the FETs (I mean significantly and enjoyably) used after a volume control in the circuit - But I am told that this is an irrelevance (the passive volume control).

Roll on blind testing with the monos at some point. :)
 
(but I am not sure what my bias should have been).
Again - bias may have nothing to do with your conscious expectations or prejudices. They are built into the "wiring" of your brain, based on everything you have learned and experienced since the day you were born.
 
Again - bias may have nothing to do with your conscious expectations or prejudices. They are built into the "wiring" of your brain, based on everything you have learned and experienced since the day you were born.
:D :D :D

Big hug @antcollinet - must be congenital hearing...

But this would not be conscious expectation or prejudice.

My tests with the monos might have conscious expectation or prejudice, because these are based on previous.

My previous had no previous.

Hugs all round. Tomorrow is a new day. Night night - it is the time for wise owls ...

to catch mice and such.

:)
 
:D :D :D

Big hug @antcollinet - must be congenital hearing...

But this would not be conscious expectation or prejudice.

My tests with the monos might have conscious expectation or prejudice, because these are based on previous.

My previous had no previous.

Hugs all round. Tomorrow is a new day. Night night - it is the time for wise owls :)
I have no idea what you are saying but hugs are appreciated. There are never too many hugs in the world. :D
 
I have no idea what you are saying but hugs are appreciated. There are never too many hugs in the world. :D
Aha! :D I spoke perfect sense (I think) but you are welcome to my world (not having an idea what someone is saying)

Bonne nuit.:D
 
Fosi in orange. Can someone else verify this result? If the HK230 is correct, the Fosi is reversed.
1721488118301.png



So if I have got this right, all the v3 monos should have these reversed?
I suppose to test if our unit is also, then we just need to hook up another amp to play through the other speaker.
Post edit: I can see all this being debated now on the v3 mono review forum ... will just leave this here.
 
Last edited:
I just played the following stereo system test tracks through Tidal:


The second track is a phase test, and my system tested fine for in-phase and out-of-phase. I also confirmed left and right connections were correct. I am using all balanced connections too. I could try RCA connections to determine if something is off with single ended connections.

My wife was listening to the system and she was very impressed with the V3 Monos. She said the sound was very three dimensional and the KEF LS50s disappeared. Hope others can sort out the phase issue they are experiencing.
 
I just played the following stereo system test tracks through Tidal:


The second track is a phase test, and my system tested fine for in-phase and out-of-phase. I also confirmed left and right connections were correct. I am using all balanced connections too. I could try RCA connections to determine if something is off with single ended connections.

My wife was listening to the system and she was very impressed with the V3 Monos. She said the sound was very three dimensional and the KEF LS50s disappeared. Hope others can sort out the phase issue they are experiencing.
I think indeed it would be useful to confirm with the RCA ...that would be a strange one! I'm also using balanced.
 
I think indeed it would be useful to confirm with the RCA ...that would be a strange one! I'm also using balanced.
Is your system out-of-phase? Using the cited test tracks, my system is in phase without a doubt.

When I have time, I can try the RCA connections and check phase again.
 
Is your system out-of-phase? Using the cited test tracks, my system is in phase without a doubt.

When I have time, I can try the RCA connections and check phase again.
I'm not signed up for Tidal but I do have a test 'CD' stored on my hard drive when I get back to my system. I am sure that it will have a phase test.
It will be good to identify if there is even more to what @Miser_Audioman and @EddNog found and heard.
 
Back
Top Bottom