TBone
Major Contributor
- Joined
- Mar 16, 2016
- Messages
- 1,191
- Likes
- 348
Applying compression during mixing is the wrong solution, it damages the source material. It would be better to provide compression controls in the playback device.
However, in modern times, most wouldn't want to manually adjust such settings. A possible solution could therefore be something akin to the compression controls or dynamic eq already seen in AVRs.
Thinking out loud here... Further down the line I wonder if we might see something similar to Dolby vision. I.e. HDR Audio, where metadata accompanies the audio stream with flags to specify the amplitude scale that the DAC should use. (This could allow more optimal use of the available number of digital bits).
...Compression control could easily be implemented simply by adjusting the transfer function between the metadata amplitude flags ...
kinda reminds me of replay-gain somewhat, perhaps a workable solution, however ...
... problem remains ... overall compression = dynamic capability of source material provided; strictly judged on todays sound/remasters (esp w/old.orig.analog) ... the compression remains ...
hence ... why the war was "lost".