• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Topping E50 Review (Balanced DAC)

raif71

Major Contributor
Joined
Sep 7, 2019
Messages
2,345
Likes
2,564
Hi @amirm I was wondering if you have a higher quality image of the rankings list?
It's unfortunately become too low res to make out the names of the devices tested.
I mean this one:

https://www.audiosciencereview.com/...lanced-dac.26219/#lg=attachment150587&slide=0


I believe, this is better in resolution , I got it off an ASR page but don't have the link anymore. Hope it is useful

When zoomed in the software gimp, I can see the name of the DAC as shown below:

1631103427827.png
 

Attachments

  • Best desktop USB Balanced XLR DAC Review.png
    Best desktop USB Balanced XLR DAC Review.png
    571.6 KB · Views: 251

Grooved

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Joined
Feb 26, 2021
Messages
682
Likes
441

Yorkshire Mouth

Major Contributor
Joined
Apr 22, 2020
Messages
1,356
Likes
1,298
Location
God's County - Yorkshire
I hate myself for this, but I'm being drawn into the 'hobby'.

Just got my EX5, and am looking at alternatives for round the house.

I've just opened 2 tabs, this one and the D10 Balanced. Now the measurements are so similar *, it's not even remotely justifiable for me to warrant spending the E50 over the D10 balanced on those, but the E50 does have better features.

However, I'll need an amp, and if I plug the D10 into an L50, I get all the outputs I could want from that on passthrough.

Unless I've missed something, which is why I'm asking this here. Any reason to get the E50 over the D10 balanced?

*
SINAD:

D10B 118.3
E50 120.9
Would I hear a difference?

Signal to noise ratio:
D10B 121.5
E50 122.5
Would I hear a difference?

Linearity:
Both perfect

Jitter:
Both perfect

IMD:
Near identical

Filters:
The best measuring one (THD_N Ratio vs Frequency @ 48khz) on the E50 is the same as the only one on the D10B, and both measure pretty much identically.

Multitone:
Near identical

Comments?
 
Last edited:

Fawzay

Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2019
Messages
21
Likes
4
Location
Red Dot
I hate myself for this, but I'm being drawn into the 'hobby'.

Just got my EX5, and am looking at alternatives for round the house.

I've just opened 2 tabs, this one and the D10 Balanced. Now the measurements are so similar *, it's not even remotely justifiable for me to warrant spending the E50 over the D10 balanced on those, but the E50 does have better features.

However, I'll need an amp, and if I plug the D10 into an L50, I get all the outputs I could want from that on passthrough.

Unless I've missed something, which is why I'm asking this here. Any reason to get the E50 over the D10 balanced?

*
SINAD:

D10B 118.3
E50 12.09
Would I hear a difference?

Signal to noise ratio:
D10B 121.5
E50 122.5
Would I hear a difference?

Linearity:
Both perfect

Jitter:
Both perfect

IMD:
Near identical

Filters:
The best measuring one (THD_N Ratio vs Frequency @ 48khz) on the E50 is the same as the only one on the D10B, and both measure pretty much identically.

Multitone:
Near identical

Comments?
Yeah... Thinking of this setup as well d10b to L50 to Adam F5
 

Ata

Senior Member
Forum Donor
Joined
May 6, 2021
Messages
388
Likes
334
Location
Adelaide, Australia
Wow? Only $269 and we have hit 120db SINAD? Where is there to go from here? Haven't we hit "Peak-DAC" now?

I though peak DAC was a few years ago, since then it is a race to the bottom price-wise, with SMSL and Topping in the lead.
 

raif71

Major Contributor
Joined
Sep 7, 2019
Messages
2,345
Likes
2,564
I hate myself for this, but I'm being drawn into the 'hobby'.

Just got my EX5, and am looking at alternatives for round the house.

I've just opened 2 tabs, this one and the D10 Balanced. Now the measurements are so similar *, it's not even remotely justifiable for me to warrant spending the E50 over the D10 balanced on those, but the E50 does have better features.

However, I'll need an amp, and if I plug the D10 into an L50, I get all the outputs I could want from that on passthrough.

Unless I've missed something, which is why I'm asking this here. Any reason to get the E50 over the D10 balanced?

*
SINAD:

D10B 118.3
E50 12.09
Would I hear a difference?

Signal to noise ratio:
D10B 121.5
E50 122.5
Would I hear a difference?

Linearity:
Both perfect

Jitter:
Both perfect

IMD:
Near identical

Filters:
The best measuring one (THD_N Ratio vs Frequency @ 48khz) on the E50 is the same as the only one on the D10B, and both measure pretty much identically.

Multitone:
Near identical

Comments?
Well the D10b is always in DAC mode and volume will have to be controlled on the active speakers as the L50 will not be able to control the volume. With E50, you can have preamp mode and control the volume to the active speakers (L50 will have to be turned off). If you don't mind controlling the volume of the active speakers, then D10b should suffice. I'm thinking of this setup (D10b with L50) too but I will only use the headphone portion and not the passthrough feature of the L50.
 

Yorkshire Mouth

Major Contributor
Joined
Apr 22, 2020
Messages
1,356
Likes
1,298
Location
God's County - Yorkshire
Well the D10b is always in DAC mode and volume will have to be controlled on the active speakers as the L50 will not be able to control the volume. With E50, you can have preamp mode and control the volume to the active speakers (L50 will have to be turned off). If you don't mind controlling the volume of the active speakers, then D10b should suffice. I'm thinking of this setup (D10b with L50) too but I will only use the headphone portion and not the passthrough feature of the L50.

No active speakers. Aux in to an integrated amp.
 

MrDamianOZ

New Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2021
Messages
4
Likes
4
With results like these, what is the point of buying anything more expensive, like the D90? Can it offer anything else in terms of sound?
 

Grooved

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Joined
Feb 26, 2021
Messages
682
Likes
441
I hate myself for this, but I'm being drawn into the 'hobby'.

Just got my EX5, and am looking at alternatives for round the house.

I've just opened 2 tabs, this one and the D10 Balanced. Now the measurements are so similar *, it's not even remotely justifiable for me to warrant spending the E50 over the D10 balanced on those, but the E50 does have better features.

However, I'll need an amp, and if I plug the D10 into an L50, I get all the outputs I could want from that on passthrough.

Unless I've missed something, which is why I'm asking this here. Any reason to get the E50 over the D10 balanced?

*
SINAD:

D10B 118.3
E50 120.9
Would I hear a difference?

Signal to noise ratio:
D10B 121.5
E50 122.5
Would I hear a difference?

Linearity:
Both perfect

Jitter:
Both perfect

IMD:
Near identical

Filters:
The best measuring one (THD_N Ratio vs Frequency @ 48khz) on the E50 is the same as the only one on the D10B, and both measure pretty much identically.

Multitone:
Near identical

Comments?

D10b + L50 looks like a good alternative, but in this case, why not just get another EX5 ?
It cost the same price than D10b+L50, unless you really need the Optical/Coax outputs of the D10b...

Another alternative is the Tone2 Pro which performs and has the same functions as a balanced DAC than the EX5 (balanced/unbalanced, volume control on all outputs, MQA decoder+renderer if you need it), cost less, is mobile, but doesn't have a real display, no bluetooth yet (module will be available later), optical input, and has great headphones power as a mobile device, but less power than the EX5.
This is certainly what I would pick in this case : combo of EX5 and Tone2 Pro, as I see more the D10b in case you only need a DAC to link to an amp or HP amp you already have, and L50 if you need an HP amp but already have the other part. Maybe I don't like stacking devices :)
 
Last edited:

litguy

Member
Joined
Nov 16, 2018
Messages
9
Likes
2
D10s and D50s have unbalanced outputs (2V). If you now compare D90se XLR output (4V) you are going to get more max volume which might explain the difference you hear.
you comment on your imagination, volume level is only one thing, not all
 

FireLion

Active Member
Joined
May 25, 2018
Messages
243
Likes
98
Wish the price was in line with the amp, seems a bit much when compared to say a grace sdac balanced or even the D10B. Cheap option would be E30+L50.

I mean if it's just an E30 with some balanced outs then the price should be +$50 in my most humble opinion.
 

jevenator

Member
Joined
May 29, 2020
Messages
31
Likes
14
Can I use the E50 in pre-amp mode for my active speakers using the Balanced TRS connectors while at the same time having my Schiit Heresy plugged into the SE ports to power my headphones and just easily switch in between them whenever I want to listen to my speakers or headphones?
 

mmichii

Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2021
Messages
8
Likes
4
I have the d10b but for some reason it sounds really harsh at times. Noticeably (not in a headfi superbest infinitesimally small imagined difference) to the point i don't need a direct a/b to pick it out instantly. I noticed it the moment i plugged it in and started to listen to it. I switched it up using different cables (just in case), different amps, headphones. It made my hd600's which sound muddy to me at times bright as hell. I noticed one other reviewer somewhere (maybe headfi) mention how bright and harsh the thing is. I thought he meant in an audiophile can't really tell kind of way. wow was i wrong on that count. In any case i saw the e50 on apos and i thought i would give it a shot. i like the build quality fo the d10b and the fact the driver from topping says topping in settings. Which was a nice attention to detail. I hope and am pretty sure this will fit the bill. I've been watching with fascination as the package makes it way through the various checkpoints all the way to me in san diego from shenzhen. the e50 has the two features i really wanted which was volume control option and the unbalanced outputs for my stax srm252s. it arrives monday.
 
Top Bottom