• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Non-techie question: Is there a best way to downsample with Roon?

CT Man

Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2023
Messages
53
Likes
56
I use Roon primarily with Qobuz, with a relatively small amount from network flac files. Going beyond 48/24 doesn't seem meaningful to me, perhaps even 44/16 is more than enough. I'm currently streaming mostly to my WiiM Pro and Chromecast Audio pucks. I do use PEQ, so I'm not sure if resolution prior to processing matters.

My question is whether there is a best way to set maximum sample rates and bit depths with Roon. I assume if that's done through Settings>Services>Qobuz then Qobuz will perform the format reduction from their server. That seems most efficient from the processing standpoint but I don't know if there's any hit to quality compared to Roon. The options through this setting are more limited than other ways within Roon.

Roon can also set maximum rates for each device through Settings>Audio>(device name). I'm not sure if Roon will only request lower res files from Qobuz, or if Roon will fully process the reduction from high-res formats. Roon converts audio to floating 64 bits prior to any processing, then back to the target sample rate and bit depth for output. Does that make a meaningful difference to audio quality, or is it digital overkill?

Roon can also convert sample rates through MUSE (which controls headroom, sample rates, PEQ, Procedural EQ, Speaker Set-Up, etc). I don't think bit depth can be changed through MUSE.

So my question: Is there a best way within Roon for setting maximum sample rate and bit depth? Are all methods equally "transparent"? Is there a meaningful reason to be concerned about processing efficiency?

See attached image for the different Roon options.
Roon Sample-Bit Options.jpg
 
Just limit Qobuz to 44.1 KHz streaming. Saves bandwidth and electricity from extra processing too. Yes 64bit float is essentially transparent so the processing steps are lossless and indistinguishable from the 44.1 KHz streaming (unless the Hi-rez files deliberately come from a different master than the 44.1 KHz files)
 
Just limit Qobuz to 44.1 KHz streaming. Saves bandwidth and electricity from extra processing too. Yes 64bit float is essentially transparent so the processing steps are lossless and indistinguishable from the 44.1 KHz streaming (unless the Hi-rez files deliberately come from a different master than the 44.1 KHz files)
Thanks. That mostly makes sense to me, but I wonder a bit more about bit depth than sample rate. In your opinion, quantization errors going from 16 to 64 to 16 bits from Roon's processing are indistinguishable from 24-64-24 or 24-64-16?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom