• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!
I asked ChatGPT 3.5 (the free version) to recommend me songs with good bass, and this was the answer:



Hip-Hop/Rap:

Electronic/Dance:

Rock:
View attachment 332156
View attachment 332157
View attachment 332158
View attachment 332159

Pop:
View attachment 332160
View attachment 332161
View attachment 332162

Reggae/Dub:
View attachment 332163
View attachment 332164
View attachment 332165

R&B/Soul:
View attachment 332166
View attachment 332167
View attachment 332168

Metal:
View attachment 332169
View attachment 332170
View attachment 332171

Dubstep:
View attachment 332172
View attachment 332173
View attachment 332174

overall, not bad.
out of 27 recommended songs, 4 songs were mediocre, but the rest okay.
No classical thought,it still has lots to learn :)
 
BTW, I made a simple script that pipes the YouTube audio directly to SoX for the spectrogram. FFmpeg is used for decoding Opus.

Bash:
#!/bin/bash

if [ -z "$1" ]; then
    echo Missing YouTube URL
    exit 1
fi

readarray -t vars <<< "$(yt-dlp --print filename,ext,title,duration "$1")"

filename=${vars[0]}
ext=${vars[1]}
title=${vars[2]}
duration=${vars[3]}

file=$(basename "$filename" ."$ext")

yt-dlp --extract-audio --output - "$1" | \
    ffmpeg -hide_banner -i - -f sox - | \
    sox -V -t sox - --null remix - rate 200 spectrogram -z 60 -t "$file" -d "$duration" -o "$file".png
 
Jeez, if there ever was a track that spoke to me as a person....

I think that just went lower than my headphones could play (1:34 mark)
EDIT: actually not sure whats going on at 1:34, Unless its in the track I can’t play it properly on several headphones / players / speakers. Im using the amazon music version.
 
Last edited:
Jeez, if there ever was a track that spoke to me as a person....

I Love Big Speakers [TX5BHcag3bw].png
 
I think that just went lower than my headphones could play (1:34 mark)
EDIT: actually not sure whats going on at 1:34, Unless its in the track I can’t play it properly on several headphones / players / speakers. Im using the amazon music version.
I think that's just a 1/16 loop, definitely a part of the track. What do you mean play it properly? As in reach those lowest notes?

edit: i got what you meant now lol.
 
Last edited:
I have a couple of bass intensive recordings
first a Swedish traditonal song with very low bass
and a electronic piece that i really like
 
For those Windows users who just want use ffmpeg.exe to pipe any audio format into sox.exe

ffmpeg -hide_banner -i <input file in double quotes> -f sox - | sox.exe -t sox - -n remix - rate 200 spectrogram -z 60 -d <manually enter duration of audio file>
 
Pink Floyd: Pulse DVD (24bit 48kHz rip).
First 4 minutes of Track 6 Sorrow.

When my parents attended the very last night of this tour in Earls Court late October 1994 they said that the seats were vibrating pretty terrifically from the low organ notes.
Lets not forget that the seating did collapse in a small section on an earlier evening at this venue!

spectrogram.png
 
Last edited:
Michael Jackson (& Slash): Give In To Me, from Dangerous album.
spectrogram.png


I should add that the smashing window pane at the beginning of track 1 "Jam" sometimes sounds like crystal glass dropping on a stone kitchen floor on some setups!
 
Back
Top Bottom