20 year old flagship speaker vs today's best $2500 or under?

[paulgyro]

Hi everyone I'm currently in the market for a new pair of speakers to replace my Forte IIIs, budget is $2500.

I keep debating with myself and thought I'd let you guys join in too.

Get a 20 year old high-end flagship or the best $2500 or under pair you can get bookshelf or tower.

Examples of old high-end flagship type I'm debating about.

Note: Assume I can get parts for repair if need be.

Revel Ultima Gem with stands for about $2k
-I've not heard these but have heard the Ultima Studio (same line), amazing. Studios measure good on Sound Stage Network https://www.soundstagenetwork.com/measurements/revel_ultima_studio/
-Stereophile's Products of 1998 Joint Loudspeakers of 1998 https://www.stereophile.com/content/stereophiles-products-1998-joint-loudspeakers-1998
-Stereophile's measurements looks good but for a dip at about 4k. https://www.stereophile.com/content...r-ultima-sub-15-subwoofer-measurements-page-3


KEF Reference 201/2 with stands for about $2k
- 201/2 measure great on Sound Stage Network https://www.soundstagenetwork.com/measurements/speakers/kef_201-2/
-Stereophile's measurements and review look great https://www.stereophile.com/content/kef-reference-2012-loudspeaker-measurements
-Stereophile's recommended A (Restricted Extreme LF)-list until about 2013

Current example speakers up to the $2.5k price point.

Arendal 1723 Monitor S or 1723 Monitor for $2 to $2.4k
Focal Aria 906 for about $2k
JBL HDI 1600 for about $1.9k
Revel Concerta2 F36 for about $1.75k
Legacy Studio HDs for about $2k
Ascend Sierra Tower or Sierra-2EX $2.5k or $1.5k
KEF R3
KEF LS50 Meta (most likely way too small)
Other Revel book shelf
Other Focal Chora lines.
Others?

Let me know your thoughts!

I'm going crazy thinking about this....

Other info you might want, my room is 320 sq ft, 3000 cubic feet, 8-9 ft listening distance. 80-85 db average listening levels.

Current amp is VTV Stereo Amplifier based on Hypex NCore NC252MP (VTV Stereo Amplifier based on Hypex NCore NC252MP | VTV Amplifier)

I already own 4 subs, all aligned with miniDSP HD 2x4 and MSO. Amazing bass.

Paul

 

[dshreter]

With four managed subs, there’s no reason to get a flagship full range speaker. Something modern and more accurate like R3 or M106 should be better.

 

[Sal1950]

The only thing I want to add is to beware of speakers 20 years old.
Woofer surrounds, crossover caps, and other things may have deteriorated.
I stay newer than 10 if you want a decade or two of trouble free use.

 

[restorer-john]

The only thing I want to add is to beware of speakers 20 years old.
Woofer surrounds, crossover caps, and other things may have deteriorated.
I stay newer than 10 if you want a decade or two of trouble free use.

I agree. Speakers do unfortunately deteriorate rapidly after 10-15 years or so and you are often stuck with beautiful cabinets, almost a full set of functional drivers and no spare parts. Ask me how I know that- or better still, have in look in my storeroom.

 

[BoredErica]

I agree. Speakers do unfortunately deteriorate rapidly after 10-15 years or so and you are often stuck with beautiful cabinets, almost a full set of functional drivers and no spare parts. Ask me how I know that- or better still, have in look in my storeroom.

Wish there was an easy way to lengthen the life of a speaker. Oh well, 10-15 years is a decent amount of time...

 

[DonH56]

You can't get drivers for the original Ultima line AFAIK. I agree with the rest; get a decent modern('ish) speaker new or made within the past five years or so, a sub or two, and enjoy. A pair of year-old Revel F206's sold for about $2k on another forum recently.

 

[paulgyro]

Gotcha thanks all! If there aren't parts available it certainly doesn't make sense to invest $2k in a time bomb. I now have some Arendal 1723 Monitors on order. I've also reached out to Revel and Kef to see if they are have parts available just incase.

How do you think the over all performance of the Revel / Kef I mentioned above compared to the $2k speakers we are discussing?

 

[Chrispy]

Personally I wouldn't rank the original Klipsch speakers as high as you do....

 

[MaxBuck]

I'd be thinking seriously about the BMR Philharmonic Monitors.

 

[paulgyro]

Personally I wouldn't rank the original Klipsch speakers as high as you do....

Not sure what you are getting at here, my only mention of Klipsch was what I'm replacing. Can you clarify?

 

[paulgyro]

I'd be thinking seriously about the BMR Philharmonic Monitors.

I've never heard of these, I'll look into them.

 

[paulgyro]

Say out of curiosity I contacted Revel to see if they have tweeter and woofer available still and they do. Does knowing their are part's available change your thinking at all?

 

[SKBubba]

Curious why you're replacing Forte 3?

 

[Sal1950]

Does knowing their are part's available change your thinking at all?

It would for me

 

[mhardy6647]

Wish there was an easy way to lengthen the life of a speaker. Oh well, 10-15 years is a decent amount of time...

There are few here that are that new.

 

[paulgyro]

Curious why you're replacing Forte 3?

I'd like a more accurate speaker with better imaging. I love the live sound of the Fortes though. It's all about trade offs right?

 

[rdenney]

In my experience, speakers don't die quite as easily as some are suggesting. But when I buy older stuff, it's at a price point that keeps them from being a bad deal even if they die in five years. Example: I bought a pair of Revel Concerta F12's, which were probably 15 years old. They work great, but I got them for $700, so if I only get five years from them, they'll still be a good deal.

But I'm already struggling to get parts--an attempt to buy a replacement set of carpet feet has gone nowhere. They identified some stock in the UK, but even with me willing to pay three times their price for shipping, I can't get anyone at Revel to lift a finger to make it happen. That's why I don't sell my old Advents, which seem to be indefinitely repairable.

Rick "for whom buying old stuff is part of the hobby" Denney

 

[dlaloum]

I would look at electrostatics for a high end example from 20+ years ago ...

The 20 year old Quad 989 is well nigh identical to the current 2912, and the 988 is almost identical to the older ESL63 from the mid 80's, or the newer 2905 (current).

Martin Logan still makes the CLS... I first heard that speaker in the mid 80's

As long as they have not been ARC'd (in which case they need a replacement diaphragm) - their performance does not change over time.

Both the ML and the Quads are still available, parts are available and they can be easily repaired (well... as easily as any ESL can be!)

You could even have a listen for the much more delicate Quad ESL57 - Quads original electrostatic from the 60's - it is severely bass limited - but it's midrange is quite magical! - these are delicate, easily damaged - but still repairable to this day.

 

[jonfitch]

Older speakers tended to have less bass so will sound quite lean relative to modern designs, I guess besides Dynaudio speakers which have always had chonky bass. But blended with subs I doubt you will be able to tell the difference assuming you aren't sitting nearfield.

 

[H-713]

Older speakers tended to have less bass so will sound quite lean relative to modern designs, I guess besides Dynaudio speakers which have always had chonky bass. But blended with subs I doubt you will be able to tell the difference assuming you aren't sitting nearfield.

That is heavily dependent upon the speaker and I would not necessarily make that generalization.