• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Why you should feel sorry for HiFi reviewers

Plcamp

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Joined
Jul 6, 2020
Messages
860
Likes
1,318
Location
Ottawa
One business opportunity would be to hire someone who pretends to be a both a doctor and (by chance) an audiophile to lend expert credence to your surprisingly successful experiments with ear wax management.

Think about it.

There would be zero difference whatever whacko ear oil you sell actually does, it most certainly would make a noticeable difference to all who paid to obtain it ; it certainly would have novelty ; it has a plausible story spanning both audiophileometry and medical foolery ; it might actually help them in some circumstances and even measurements would confirm a difference.

With a much higher margin than even power conditioners if you play it right.

(Just ask Dr Ho.)
 

fpitas

Master Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Jul 7, 2022
Messages
9,885
Likes
14,211
Location
Northern Virginia, USA
One business opportunity would be to hire someone who pretends to be a both a doctor and (by chance) an audiophile to lend expert credence to your surprisingly successful experiments with ear wax management.

Think about it.

There would be zero difference whatever whacko ear oil you sell actually does, it most certainly would make a noticeable difference to all who paid to obtain it ; it certainly would have novelty ; it has a plausible story spanning both audiophileometry and medical foolery ; it might actually help them in some circumstances and even measurements would confirm a difference.

With a much higher margin than even power conditioners if you play it right.

(Just ask Dr Ho.)
One problem is that it actually might help. The best, most expensive snake oil is completely useless nonsense.
 

Plcamp

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Joined
Jul 6, 2020
Messages
860
Likes
1,318
Location
Ottawa
One problem is that it actually might help. The best, most expensive snake oil is completely useless nonsense.
The devil is most effective when some things said are true. It might be true that snakes have excellent hearing. Partly because their ears are never waxy. And they have oil.

Coincidence?

Be happy it can’t legally be spiked with nicotine.
 

fpitas

Master Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Jul 7, 2022
Messages
9,885
Likes
14,211
Location
Northern Virginia, USA
The devil is most effective when some things said are true. It might be true that snakes have excellent hearing. Partly because their ears are never waxy. And they have oil.

Coincidence?

Be happy it can’t legally be spiked with nicotine.
I look forward to the day we can leave the poor snakes unmolested.
 

JSmith

Master Contributor
Joined
Feb 8, 2021
Messages
5,221
Likes
13,459
Location
Algol Perseus
Funny-Nonsense-Meme-Goats-Are-Like-Mushrooms-If-You-Shoot-A-Duck-I-Am-Scared-Of-Toasters-Picture.jpg



JSmith
 

Robin L

Master Contributor
Joined
Sep 2, 2019
Messages
5,288
Likes
7,718
Location
1 mile east of Sleater Kinney Rd
Hello, well that was the sound of Roger's Wah Wah Rabbits,
You heard them eating endive there,
That's very cheap at this time of the year
But now here in Willesden Green, yes, brr, it's a bit chilly
But no matter, because here comes a gentleman
And we're going to talk to him about shirts

Excuse me, sir

Would you mind talking to us about shirts?
 

JSmith

Master Contributor
Joined
Feb 8, 2021
Messages
5,221
Likes
13,459
Location
Algol Perseus
Excuse me, sir

Would you mind talking to us about shirts?
Do what? About shirts, shirts? Yes.

Cause I've got plenty at home, good grief.

... and here comes a lady with an enchanting little kangaroo and I'm going to ask her something about shirts.

No, I'm not because she's given me a rather a vulgar sign...


JSmith
 

Capitol C

Active Member
Joined
May 21, 2021
Messages
164
Likes
191
Location
Washington, DC
Imagine this. You are a high-end HiFi reviewer, you have a high end HiFi setup and a dedicated listening room all set up to try out any new HiFi product that arrives in your mailbox or is sent to you by a magazine or website. Then, joy upon joy, a new product arrives! :) Being the modest and fair person you are, you fit the new device to your equipment, kick off a piece of appropriate test audio and settle into your listening chair to experience the new device.

Then it happens! Beginning slowly, as the new gear “burns in”, there’s a perceptible improvement in the oft-listened audio source you have playing. Yes! The noise floor has dropped away! The quiet phases are quieter…. blacker, so black. Then as the track continues, veils are lifted, vestigial parts of the music, barely audible before, are now present! The music sounds tighter, more balanced, individual instruments are riveted to the soundstage! But wait, there’s more! Muddiness is gone, the music sounds more in tune and rhythmic, so much so that it becomes danceable! Then the big rush, the walls of the room melt away and you are transported into the venue, into the performance, you’re sitting in front of the soloist and he’s playing just for you! It’s rapturous, it’s life changing and all from one exchanged/added component!

You start hammering out your review in barely adequate words. Dictionaries and thesauruses are pored over, looking for new and hitherto unknown superlatives, hell! You invent your OWN superlatives! Your review runs for three ecstatic pages, gushing your transformative experience to the hungry audience. As you finish with the last sentence, you’re spent, drained of creative fire but you have achieved the almost impossible in describing your experience.

WOW!

But what goes up, must come down. The vendor wants the component back. So you reluctantly remove it from your system, pack it up and send it back. You plod despondently back to your listening room with a heavy heart and put on a familiar piece to help you relax. This of course has the opposite effect. Sitting in your listening chair, new component removed, HORROR! What has happened??!!?? Noise! The noise floor is back up? The blacks are now mid-grey! AAAAK! What’s that?! I can’t hear the click of the octave key on the third Clarinet! It all sounds loose and unbalanced, the instruments are wandering around the stage… the second Bassoon has left to get a sandwich! It’s muddy and veiled……..oh tragedy…… . What’s happened to the tune and the rhythm, it’s all gone, not danceable at all!!

You slump in your chair, life has ceased to be worth living. Your mouth hangs open and your eyes droop. You try to prise yourself out of your chair but your muscles have become weak and atrophied. You manage to croak out a plea for a stiff drink to your partner which is duly supplied. Before they leave the room, you instruct your drink provider to switch the power off on the HiFi, maybe never to be re-energised…. All is dark and gloomy, your hobby has dealt you a cruel blow. Is there any point in going on?

View attachment 225321
Image created using the MidJourney AI engine.
This is fine writing! Thanks!!
 
Top Bottom