• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Who makes the best drivers in the world?

Truly a "hidden champion" of the international hifi industry.
Yes, I agree

Based on my experience making speakers, I think the best woofer is SEAS. The best tweeter is SEAS or Scan Speak.
It would be interesting to know how you came to this conclusion.
What makes a Seas woofer so much better than one from Accuton, SB Satori, Beyma, 18sound, BMS or Faital? Does SEAS even offer sizes over 10 inches?

How could a 10-inch Woofer be "better" than, for example, an 18-inch driver from a pro audio company?

And what is better about a Seas or Scan Speak tweeter than a Mundorf AMT or Accuton ceramic tweeter in terms of measurement technology?

I have nothing against SEAS, but you should be able to justify such a statement with an absolute claim.
 
While looking at the woofer performance chart, I came across a value called suspension mechanical resistance. I learned that a higher value means a more solid control of the bass, so I became obsessed with whether this value is provided or provided with a lower value. So I said that this woofer was good because SEAS showed a high value, and scanning? This value is not provided.
I think that not providing it because it is expensive is not something that I should judge and it is not something that I should consider when purchasing. I wonder why they do not provide information because it is so good.
You can ask Chat GPT about the meaning or importance of suspension mechanical resistance.
Companies that do not provide data have a basic attitude toward proving the reliability of their products to consumers. It is an experience that you will learn over time. How can I trust and buy from you?
 
Last edited:
If you make a speaker, it's stereo, so 2 are essential. That costs a lot of money, and on top of that, there are expensive parts. Have you tried it and seen if it's good or bad? I don't know. So you have to look at the performance chart and judge. When others say it's good or bad, there aren't many people who've used it, so you don't know. You can't trust it, and your taste may be different from mine. Therefore, you have to look at the performance chart first. They don't provide a performance chart? They're leaving out the performance figures I want? Then how should I judge it? You should immediately exclude it from your consideration for purchase. What do governments these days use when evaluating weapons? The basic performance table is essential, and what I want must be in the performance table. If you don't provide it? Then you are excluded from the purchase target. My money is precious, and the budget set by the government is a lot of money. How can I trust you and buy the weapons you provide? That's right.
 
1000113527.jpg
 
Very, very few people know how these massive master series speakers sound in real life, unfortunately. Countless people have of course watched pictures/You Tube videos from numerous different studios around the world, but when you get one of these at home, nothing tastes better, especially with a Genelec subwoofer and GLM-measured and fine-tuned without that famous studio recording flat sound. So if you want to put a lot of whipped cream on top of the cake and enjoy the layer cake with all the maximum delicacies that the recording industry gives out. You, the reader, will definitely not find better sound quality. That is an absolute certainty.
 
for the money it is a toss up between Peerless and SB Acoustics. You can get extremely competent drivers for just about any application from either of them for less than the cost of lunch in some cities.
 
While looking at the woofer performance chart, I came across a value called suspension mechanical resistance. I learned that a higher value means a more solid control of the bass, so I became obsessed with whether this value is provided or provided with a lower value. So I said that this woofer was good because SEAS showed a high value, and scanning? This value is not provided.
I think that not providing it because it is expensive is not something that I should judge and it is not something that I should consider when purchasing. I wonder why they do not provide information because it is so good.
You can ask Chat GPT about the meaning or importance of suspension mechanical resistance.
Companies that do not provide data have a basic attitude toward proving the reliability of their products to consumers. It is an experience that you will learn over time. How can I trust and buy from you?
Has anyone really produced tighter bass than found in sealed cabinet designs?

Every approach has trade offs.
 
I was researching for a DIY build a while back and I would have easily said Purifi based ..

.. moderately sized, spare-no-expense 2- or 3-way for home listening
I think a few of these could well be used between a room-optimized subwoofer system and a 15"–30" waveguide with decent compression driver in typical home speakers.

ps: I don't consider horns of 40 inches or larger to be "typical home" equipment.
pps: Well, at least I didn't assemble a 6+1 dome myself, nor did I have a ready-made 6+1 at home for 25 years.
 
Last edited:
From my own experience:
HF: Bliesma (absolute top of the food chain), Hiquphon (superb), ScanSpeak, Seas, one or two of the SBAcoustics
Mids: Bliesma, with again, the usual suspects.. ScanSpeak, Seas, SBA, Accutron
LF: Seas, ScanSpeak, Monacor, Purifi (conditionally), Dayton (a couple models specifically) and again, one or two SBA.
--these are my personal faves for building high fidelity speakers.
For Pro, it's a completely different world operating under different parameters, but I've had very good luck with Sica, Faital, and Eminence all performing very well.
 
Don't ignore Celestion. They offer some very fine drivers for low price (have a look at the PA line).
 
TAD for compression drivers, no doubt. But the Altec 288 still makes Best Driver lists after all these years.
 
Celestion
For example:
1790536494039.png

(not very cheap Axi2050 driver)). And cheap small (forgot the model; I think it’s the only one with a threaded interface.) in
1790536730976.png
 
Last edited:
Don't ignore Celestion. They offer some very fine drivers for low price (have a look at the PA line).
Good shoult. Celestion does indeed make some very capable drivers. I've never ended up using them personally, but know of several great projects built with them.
 
1790603158608.png

A few years ago, the 1525 and 1525E were even cheaper at a local sale. Some people used them for some hifi projects.
 
Since we're sort of going down the bang-for-the-buck avenue here, my favorite compression driver is the JBL2426 (which is cheap used) with a Radian aluminum diaphragm.
 
I bought my first 950PBs from Richard Kontrimas at a good price (thanks, Richard, that was truly valuable back then!); a used 2447 would probably have cost more, considering the shipping to Asia.
 
Since ASR thrives on measurements, here are some midrange driver tests by Linkwitz:

 
Back
Top Bottom