- Sennheiser HD600
- Audio-Technica ATH-R70x
- Audio-Technica ATH-R50x
- HiFiMAN HE400se
- Philips SHP9500
- AKG K371
- AKG K550 mkII
A few of these are recent additions, as I'm currently in the process of consolidating my collection down to just two open-back headphones and the closed-back AKGs, which are a necessary evil for music production.
The
HD600 are a given for all the reasons one would pick them, namely natural timbre and comfort (w/ Capra strap). Something that complements the HD600 and its weaknesses makes the most sense for the second spot - think extended bass and treble and a wider soundstage. The HD600 will probably keep the #1 spot for music listening, while the other pair will be used more for immersive gaming and movies. Though having a "fun" pair around is also great for music when the mood strikes.
A few quick notes on the candidates so far:
The
ATH-R70x would be my #1 do-all pick if I could only have one headphone. It's considerably better in the imaging/soundstage department than the HD600, but the HD600 has it beat for smoothness of treble and natural sound. Comfort is great for me, though I have read lots of comments to the contrary. It's a jack of all trades, and a damn good one at that, but I feel having two specialized headphones makes more sense for me.
The
ATH-R50x are, suprisingly, my current front runner for the #2 spot. They are like the halfway point between the ATH-R70x and something like a DT880. I've also seen them called a "baby Sony MDR-MV1", which I fully agree with. Lots of well-extended bass, an ever so slightly recessed midrange and broadly elevated treble. Not too bad stock, but once EQ'd to the Harman target, these become FUN. I use a slightly altered version of oratory's EQ (the PDF from Reddit), which tightens up the poofy mid bass, gets the mids to a more natural place and reigns in the treble. Comfort is great because they weigh next to nothing and the split headband is designed to avoid hotspots. I wish the pads were a little larger. I put on the pads from my R70x, which have a slightly bigger inner diameter, but I'm still looking for viable alternatives. Good value. I paid 100 € shipped for a like-new pair.
I bought the
HiFiMAN HE400se because of Amir's glowing review. Completely different presentation from the other headphones I own. They feel notably wider than the others, though I don't know if that translates to an actual sense of space for me. Imaging and positioning seem to be slighty off, which I notice most in first-person games. Music plays in an "out of head" kind of way that tends to remove me a little from the emotion of the track. It gets better once you fill in the gaping hole around 2 KHz. Amazingly punchy bass when properly EQ'd, too. But no matter what I do EQ-wise, they feel sort of "diffused" if that makes sense. Far from bad for what I'd use them for but I don't know if I'd ever be able to really get into a piece of music on them. Comfort is poor out of the box because of the weight and bad headband design. I ordered the matching Capra strap the day they arrived. The strap helps a lot, but it's still not an all-day headphone for me.
I've had a few
Philips SHP9500 over the years. They used to be the default recommendation for gaming headphones under 100 € and for good reason. The soundstage and imaging are both good in a natural, non-exaggerated way, which means positional accuracy is on point. Stock, they are bass-shy and the treble is kind of grainy. A bass shelf and some strategic cuts in the treble (5,5 KHz is the main offender on my head) improves the sound exponentially, but the peaky treble means the usual EQ presets found online need fine-grained individual adjustments. I'm still not 100 % satisfied with my EQ curve and I'm sceptical I'll ever get these phones to sound any better than "pretty good". A big plus point for the SHP9500 is the single 3,5 mm input on the left cup, which allows you to use a wide range of aftermarket boom microphones. Back in my sweaty multiplayer days that would have been a real selling point, but now I can take it or leave it. Though they feel kind of cheap, the mechanical design and comfort are actually very good. Big ear pads, low clamping force, nicely stepped headband adjustments. Very solid in that regard.
Right now, my preference is R50x > SHP9500 > R70x > HE400se, but I'm not done yet. I still have an AKG K702 and a HiFiMAN Edition XS on the way (both used). I had the K601 for a while, loved its soundstage and comfort but can't do fixed cables anymore so I thought I'd give the K702 a shot. The Edition XS is HiFiMAN's last chance to really impress me before I write them off under "just not for me". Well, maybe I'll also need to hear the Edition XV as it seems to be a big departure from their house sound but we'll see.
Does anyone have any other ideas? Preferably for not stupid money?