JSmith
Master Contributor
On the other side of the coin... free beta testers are real.that I have no need for
JSmith
On the other side of the coin... free beta testers are real.that I have no need for
LOL that is just not something that naturally occurs to me otohOn the other side of the coin... free beta testers are real.
JSmith
I've seen a coupla posts about software that I have no need for so mostly ignore it. A subforum for it might be a good way to go....
I can’t see any downsides at all. Developers who spend their long hours and skills at producing their software that they share freely for members benefits should be welcomed in my opinion. In answer to your question “What do we do with all of them”? My suggestion is absolutely nothing - let as many members as desired post and share free software.It seems a day does not go by that someone doesn't come to us with a new piece of software they have written to solve this and that issue. I imagine with advent of AI, writing software has become far faster and easier.
Question is, what do we do with them all? Many say they are free but we worry that they are free now, and once we help them become successful, they won't be.
At the same time, such software may be useful to you all. And they could have genuine intentions.
So far, we have sort of treated them as Industry Members, giving them the tag and such. But there is pushback especially if the software is "free."
And at any rate, we have so many of these coming our way.
Let me know what you all think.
I think we are only talking about vendor badges for people who are selling stuff.What if someone who's an ASR contributor of some years wants to show off somehting and solicit comments?
For example, if I wanted to share my Kazoo neural analyzer/synthesizer but I had to wear a Vendor badge after that then I won't bother.
How about we put such software projects and vibe codes into a forum set up for that. If you're principle involvement at ASR is as representative of a commercial vendor, which includes new members hoping to advertise their hot new app and eventually profit, then you don't belong in that new forum and you should get the badge and put your offering in Audio Industry Forum.
So I'm not sure about badges. And I'm not sure open source is the distinction I'm concerned about.
So members can differentiate between those with commercial interests and those that do not.
JSmith
This I'm seeing and not only in the audio field.Also there seems to be a class of "junk software " or "spam software" that exist because some dunning kruger candidate burst trough "open doors" or solving non existing problems ? because its to easy to code and you don't need any understanding of the audio science at all ? And can just produce these useless apps ?
yesThis I'm seeing and not only in the audio field.
Part of me applauds the effort and often the cider learns something useful in the process. Something genuinely good may come of it.
Yes - there is something to be said for free software that has existed for many years and is used everyday by huge numbers of people, compared with say a newcomer with zero provenance and 10 downloads. I'd be more likely to trust someone who'd been on ASR for a while though.On a side note, people need to be more cautious about downloading random software from just anyone.
JSmith
I'm talking about more than that.I think we are only talking about vendor badges for people who are selling stuff.
You are spot on with the background of the individual building it mattering big time, and I'd say it matters far more than them being able to code. If the person driving the agent to build the software can't verify what the agent is writing (both the code and the science), then the person building it needs to have serious rigor in their process, and even then it's very difficult. You cannot simply replace a math/science degree with an agent. It's not impossible, but it's far from simple, and the person doing it still needs to be an engineer who is deep into software testing and cares deeply about accuracy.Paid vs free and closed vs open is easy to separate at a couple of sub-forums.
What's not easy to see and understand though is the difference between a simple tool or quirk (a VU meter vis for example) and a piece of software who can mess things big time (messing with levels, or wrong filter stacking, etc)
About the later, how many people you know here at ASR that are formally educated about it? Let alone creating apps too?
Filters (DSP if you like) is just about the most messy area, whatever has the potential to go wrong, it will, big time.
And since DSP (EQ in particular) involves levels and gain, I would really want to know the credentials of the author and the safeguards (for filter-stacking for example) .
(I do like beta-testing, but for less used stuff)