Nabussan
Member
What is a cost-efficient way to run a 7-channel system (2 x 2-way + 3 subwoofers) with a DSP-DAC-AMP solution?
As per https://support.biamp.com/Design_Tools/Amplifier_Power_Calculator, at a distance of 3.8 m, with 95db sensitivity 8R speakers, 18 dB headroom (for high-quality recordings with not too much dynamic compression), I achieve 87db average continuous volume if I use 150W amps for my mains -- more than sufficient.
The setup I want to replace: 2 minidsp 2x4 plus IRS2092-based 150W/250/300W amp modules with Connexelectronics SMPSs, fed by an AVR preamp stereo output.
I'd like to have less noisy amps, and signal processing in the digital domain with no prior AD conversion.
At the moment, I seem to prefer the Hypex FusionAmp scenario. The modules have SPDIF optical input, can be daisy-chained via SPDIF coax, and allow crossover design and equalizing like the miniDSP platform.
2 x FA252
1 x FA252 in BTL mode
1 x FA502
Including IR receiver and remote, it's around 1850 € (including VAT) here in Europe.
I compared this to a miniDSP-based solution w/o DIY (except for copying my existing filters)
WI-DG
miniDSP 10x10 Hd
1 x Crown XLS 1001 in BTL mode
3 x XLS 1502
That would cost me about 2150 €.
Advantage: plenty of power. Disadvantage: 5 optically obtrusive boxes that I can't mount at the back of my speakers, unlike the FusionAmps or other DIY modules.
To my surprise, at a comparable power rating, with 4 FA502 modules, I get better specs than with the crown amps (and avoiding their additional AD/DA conversion), at the same price. And optimum WAF (DSP, DAC, and amps disappear completely, except for the IR receiver).
As per https://support.biamp.com/Design_Tools/Amplifier_Power_Calculator, at a distance of 3.8 m, with 95db sensitivity 8R speakers, 18 dB headroom (for high-quality recordings with not too much dynamic compression), I achieve 87db average continuous volume if I use 150W amps for my mains -- more than sufficient.
The setup I want to replace: 2 minidsp 2x4 plus IRS2092-based 150W/250/300W amp modules with Connexelectronics SMPSs, fed by an AVR preamp stereo output.
I'd like to have less noisy amps, and signal processing in the digital domain with no prior AD conversion.
At the moment, I seem to prefer the Hypex FusionAmp scenario. The modules have SPDIF optical input, can be daisy-chained via SPDIF coax, and allow crossover design and equalizing like the miniDSP platform.
2 x FA252
1 x FA252 in BTL mode
1 x FA502
Including IR receiver and remote, it's around 1850 € (including VAT) here in Europe.
I compared this to a miniDSP-based solution w/o DIY (except for copying my existing filters)
WI-DG
miniDSP 10x10 Hd
1 x Crown XLS 1001 in BTL mode
3 x XLS 1502
That would cost me about 2150 €.
Advantage: plenty of power. Disadvantage: 5 optically obtrusive boxes that I can't mount at the back of my speakers, unlike the FusionAmps or other DIY modules.
To my surprise, at a comparable power rating, with 4 FA502 modules, I get better specs than with the crown amps (and avoiding their additional AD/DA conversion), at the same price. And optimum WAF (DSP, DAC, and amps disappear completely, except for the IR receiver).
- Can anyone tell about their experience with the FusionAmp DSP functions (Hypex filter design software)?
- What alternative cheaper scenarios do you advise to consider that might trump the FusionAmp solution? For example, the miniDSP 10x10 Hd plus DIY amp modules with comparable specs as the Hypex NCxxxMP modules.
- Are there cheaper DSP solutions to replace the miniDSP 10x10 Hd? The Wondom modules, for example, have analog input if I understand it correctly.
- How could I provide for the option to later upgrade to a DRC solution (DIRAC or Acourate, for example) if I wanted to play around with such things?
Last edited: