• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Trinnov Altitude 16 Review (AV Processor)

Do some of you use external dacs? Or just use the built-in one?

I don’t use the external DAC since the built in DACs are pretty quiet. The Altitude 16 likely has newer DACs too.
 
Do some of you use external dacs? Or just use the built-in one?
Unless you have a really old Altitude and/or a really unfortunate mix of amplifier gains and loudspeaker efficiencies, I would not expect any audible improvements. That said, there have been reports that external DACs click or pop, sometimes pretty loudly when the Altitude switches sample rates. That also affected the Genelec 2029s I used as rear heights for a while, and using a logic analyzer, I was unable to find any issues with the signal coming from the Altitude, so in my opinion, it's entirely the DAC's fault. I had no such issues with a Octo DAC 8 pro.
 
I'm waiting to see anyone prove with a properly matched double blind test they can hear any difference from their favored DAC of choice to one made in 1989 even.

Trying to hear a difference in the 0.1dB range let alone the more common modern 0.01dB range would be an impressive feat indeed and yet audiophiles gladly shell out $5000, even $12,000 for one and hear magical results. A $1 hit of a gummy from Michigan or Vegas would be a considerably cheaper and you might get a light show to go with it!
 
FWIW - I have updated ADC/DAC boards in my Altitude 32 (at very modest cost per channel), as per Trinnov this should bring another around 6dB of SINAD [or in the ballpark]

Not claiming any magic improvements with ESS vs old Burr Brown boards [that were tested by Amir] - but the fact is, that sound was off and it required renewed calibration to get back to overall SQ that I had before the DAC change.

While I agree with most of the statements here - I work in precision manufacturing od quite complex product - and we have a thing called "tolerance stacking" - while each part is absolutely OK on its own and within spec, they do not work together if not matched properly. Same can be valid also for Trinnov based setups, that are usually much more complex that your everyday Denon HT. We also need to acknowledge, that while Altitude measures competently, it is far from being SOTA DAC, with rising distortion in higher frequencies etc.

So I can absolutely imagine a situation, where changing a DAC board can have audible effects - if you combine it with e.g. some HYPEX Ncore amp with 27dB gain [that has elevated distortion in treble too], have some specificity on your speakers, there I can see how improving DAC board can help.
 
I get the feeling that a adding say a Emm Labs DV2 or Da2 v2 would provide a much better DAC experience but tweaking it's integration and calibration may be a little more tricky then just a plug and play situation.

Using Trinnov from 2.0 channel audio system as well , you have to probably test and do some blind testing also.
 
I just got the acurus muse + aspeqt
The Acurus Act 4 is the best processor I have heard to date however have not heard a Trinnov. I am curious if you heard the Trinnov and can comment on Acurus vs. Trinnov.
 
The Acurus Act 4 is the best processor I have heard to date however have not heard a Trinnov. I am curious if you heard the Trinnov and can comment on Acurus vs. Trinnov.

 
The Acurus Act 4 is the best processor I have heard to date however have not heard a Trinnov. I am curious if you heard the Trinnov and can comment on Acurus vs. Trinnov.

I very much doubt you are hearing the processor as most have very high sinad.

What you mean is the best calibration you "liked" was on a Acurus Act 4.

FYI DIRAC has about 30 or more patents and TRINNOV has about 50. Lyngdorph has a bunch.
Any latecomers will have a hard time having better technology.
 

The Acurus setup is both clever and simple. It’s just PEQ, but they standardize with 4 mics, which allows you to more reliably average four seating positions. It doesn’t do any fancy correction in phase, or soundfield… but frequency response is the biggest bang for the buck.

Trinnov is the gold standard for cinema production and bringing it to your home really does provide stellar results. The better your room, the less important Trinnov is. There is at least one person here who went from the Trinnov to the AV10 for the cost savings since there was no difference. In contrast, there are many people, including myself, who are big fans of Trinnov.
 
Even a Trinnov won't use your Front Wides on fixed object Atmos films in Atmos decoding mode. Only Neural X and Scatmos (and obviously DTS:X films on DTD:X Pro units including the Trinnov) will put them to full proper use for in-phase material between the mains and sides. I think Storm's StormXT mode may use them as well (certainly uses CH, SH and TS (VOG) in Atmos decoding mode).
 
Let's move the discussion here

If you understand how the Atmos and DTS:X renderers worked, you'd realize there's no real functional difference between rendering (Dolby) and matrix extracting the channels discretely (Neural X or Scatmos). You get the same benefits (off-axis seating resolution is greatly improved with more discrete speaker locations as there are no "new locations" outside the 7.1.4 skeleton, only speakers between those locations, allowing them to be extracted relatively discretely via matrix steering logic like PLII or DTS' own Neural X. There might be audible differences, but they are small.



That's the first time I've ever heard anyone claim they can extract more channels (outside of Neural X) on a Trinnov. Do tell more of how this is done. Of course, at 10x the cost (not counting amplification which using PLIIx AVRs includes), you've got to expect some conveniences from Trinnov.

The one feature I am super jealous of in a Trinnov is the ability to digitize its 7.1 inputs. Theoretically, it should be able to run Neural X on the output of my Lexicon MC-1, giving a top end (ceiling) to its Logic 7 output for music. That I would be curious to hear.

Trinnov is the only [AFAIK] processor capable of rendering 24.1.10 Atmos content + 128 objects.

Re Matrix - it is in Expert Menu and you can basically route whatever you wish to wherever you wish, sum up channels, multiply them, delay, gain etc. No real reason to do it, as you have couple of other options - e.g. 3D remapping or arraying of speakers and of course Auro3D

Re Logic 7 - this is not an issue to re-create in Trinnov, e.g. for 2Ch music and with 9.x.7 setup it takes Logic7 couple of notches higher, But you also get very similar results with adjusted Auromatic upmixer, you just need to have proper speaker layout. Trinnov anyway recommends heights, not Atmos tops. I have heights above ear layer speakers angled at MLP and speakers are capable to go down to 60Hz without compression. I run heights bit hotter to enhance immersion and you need to carefully adjsut bass management in order not to get too pronounced bass, once you get into stronger Auromatic setting.

For 5.1 and Logic7 - I just don’t bother and use adjsuted Auromatic, with Wides and Surrounds used as one array to utilize all aear channels and I use Height Mids as VoG with 3dB attenuation. I have slighlty different target curves for surrounds where I try to get bit more meat to the sound from 150-2000Hz vs L-C-R that I keep with house curve.

I do not touch DTS HD MA - it get automatically upmixed to 7.1 and that is enough

Naural X - don;y use st all, unlistenable, same for for Dolby surround
 
Trinnov is the only [AFAIK] processor capable of rendering 24.1.10 Atmos content + 128 objects.

Irrelevant. Fixed objects and bed channels do not render to speakers like Front Wides despite correlated information present between the front mains and side surrounds in most movies and surround recordings. $20k-48k and Atmos still doesn't use those extra speakers properly.

This purely Dolby's fault. Scatmos gets around the problem as does Neural X from base 2.0/5.1/7.1 soundtracks. DTS:X Pro doesn't exhibit the problem either. It's directly related to Dolby's implementation of object rendering (particularly with fixed objects which unfortunately are used a LOT in movie soundtracks) versus bed channels.

Re Matrix - it is in Expert Menu and you can basically route whatever you wish to wherever you wish, sum up channels, multiply them, delay, gain etc

Routing and summing do not necessarily mean Matrix decoding or logic steering. A mixer sums, but it doesn't give discrete output for a summed center.

No real reason to do it, as you have couple of other options - e.g. 3D remapping or arraying of speakers and of course Auro3D

None of those help the above described Atmos issue with fixed and bed objects not using speakers like Wides WHATSOEVER.

Re Logic 7 - this is not an issue to re-create in Trinnov, e.g. for 2Ch music and with 9.x.7 setup it takes Logic7 couple of notches higher, But you also get very similar results with adjusted Auromatic upmixer, you just need to have proper speaker layout

Um, no. Auromatic isn't in the same galaxy as Logic 7. Auromatic is nothing more than a cheap reverb copy system. On the plus side, it doesn't screw with the front sound stage, but it does little more than a cheap DSP reverb effect. It's not even close to what Logic 7 does.

Neural X works well with 5.1 and 7.1 sources, but so well with stereo. So the idea would be to use the Trinnov 7.1 inputs with an analog Logic 7.1 output and run Neural X on it to separate out an overhead layer from the 7.1 base. That is something I'd love to play with.

Trinnov anyway recommends heights, not Atmos tops.

Trinnov supports all 10 overheads simultaneously and more is better for precision imaging across multiple seating rows or a long room. Six is usually sufficient for most medium to semi-large rooms.

I use reverse polarity Scatmos for my overheads. Instead of steering discrete output to the center output, reversing the polarity sends it to two or more surround outputs instead (you then right the polarity on the speakers). This gives me Tops from Heights for 8 overheads (and quad mono VOG in Auro-3D). You could do 10 overheads with a 6.1 PLIIx AVR and my room would normally be small enough to get by with only six overhead speakers, but my room has a steel beam box where Top Middle would be mounted so Heights+Tops gets around the problem very well.

I have heights above ear layer speakers angled at MLP and speakers are capable to go down to 60Hz without compression. I run heights bit hotter to enhance immersion and you need to carefully adjsut bass management in order not to get too pronounced bass, once you get into stronger Auromatic setting.

Naural X - don;y use st all, unlistenable, same for for Dolby surround

You're the only person I've EVER heard from thousands that has claimed Neural X is unlistenable. I can only surmise that there's either something wrong with your Trinnov or the way you hear.

IMO, arrays, summing etc is no substitute for discrete steering to more speakers. Neural X can make a 5.1 version of an Atmos soundtrack (e.g. The Meg) sound almost exactly like the Atmos version. Dolby's own Pro Logic II steering can make a pretty discrete center between two analog inputs (no leakage with fully correlated in-phase inputs).

This is the same basic thing the panning renderer in Atmos does when adding additional speakers between say the Front and Rear Heights (Top Middle Left & Right). It renders based on the object position rather than the amount of correlated panned content, but panning is panning.
 
Irrelevant. Fixed objects and bed channels do not render to speakers like Front Wides despite correlated information present between the front mains and side surrounds in most movies and surround recordings. $20k-48k and Atmos still doesn't use those extra speakers properly.

This purely Dolby's fault. Scatmos gets around the problem as does Neural X from base 2.0/5.1/7.1 soundtracks. DTS:X Pro doesn't exhibit the problem either. It's directly related to Dolby's implementation of object rendering (particularly with fixed objects which unfortunately are used a LOT in movie soundtracks) versus bed channels.



Routing and summing do not necessarily mean Matrix decoding or logic steering. A mixer sums, but it doesn't give discrete output for a summed center.



None of those help the above described Atmos issue with fixed and bed objects not using speakers like Wides WHATSOEVER.



Um, no. Auromatic isn't in the same galaxy as Logic 7. Auromatic is nothing more than a cheap reverb copy system. On the plus side, it doesn't screw with the front sound stage, but it does little more than a cheap DSP reverb effect. It's not even close to what Logic 7 does.

Neural X works well with 5.1 and 7.1 sources, but so well with stereo. So the idea would be to use the Trinnov 7.1 inputs with an analog Logic 7.1 output and run Neural X on it to separate out an overhead layer from the 7.1 base. That is something I'd love to play with.



Trinnov supports all 10 overheads simultaneously and more is better for precision imaging across multiple seating rows or a long room. Six is usually sufficient for most medium to semi-large rooms.

I use reverse polarity Scatmos for my overheads. Instead of steering discrete output to the center output, reversing the polarity sends it to two or more surround outputs instead (you then right the polarity on the speakers). This gives me Tops from Heights for 8 overheads (and quad mono VOG in Auro-3D). You could do 10 overheads with a 6.1 PLIIx AVR and my room would normally be small enough to get by with only six overhead speakers, but my room has a steel beam box where Top Middle would be mounted so Heights+Tops gets around the problem very well.

I have heights above ear layer speakers angled at MLP and speakers are capable to go down to 60Hz without compression. I run heights bit hotter to enhance immersion and you need to carefully adjsut bass management in order not to get too pronounced bass, once you get into stronger Auromatic setting.



You're the only person I've EVER heard from thousands that has claimed Neural X is unlistenable. I can only surmise that there's either something wrong with your Trinnov or the way you hear.

IMO, arrays, summing etc is no substitute for discrete steering to more speakers. Neural X can make a 5.1 version of an Atmos soundtrack (e.g. The Meg) sound almost exactly like the Atmos version. Dolby's own Pro Logic II steering can make a pretty discrete center between two analog inputs (no leakage with fully correlated in-phase inputs).

This is the same basic thing the panning renderer in Atmos does when adding additional speakers between say the Front and Rear Heights (Top Middle Left & Right). It renders based on the object position rather than the amount of correlated panned content, but panning is panning.

Now it all makes sense, Mr. MagnusX. I have to say, I truly admire your persistence—thousands of posts about NeuralX, Scatmos, and Logic7, even though the world seems to have moved on years ago. Sometimes, you just have to let go. That train has left the station.

In my experience—having witnessed both excellent and not-so-great home theaters—there are far more important factors than just the number of overhead speakers or how the top channels are panned. If your L-C-R speakers are properly aligned and tonally matched, your bass section is state-of-the-art and well-integrated, and your bed layer speakers are correctly placed and aligned with the L-C-R, then you're already 95% of the way there. Add some decent overheads, and you're done.

That’s my philosophy, and it’s why I prefer Trinnov over a bricolage of boxes with multiple AD/DA conversions that introduce random delays, noise, distortion, and digital artifacts.

Throw in a massive screen and a good projector, and you’re fully immersed. No one will ever notice whether there are 4 or 24 overhead speakers. And no one will ever convince me to watch a terrible movie just because “it has great overhead effects”—just like no one can make me sit through boring audiophile jazz.
 

Attachments

  • 1748234110128.png
    1748234110128.png
    476.1 KB · Views: 104
Last edited:
Fully agree. Not because I am french ;).
I have discussed with a few pros building private cinema rooms (yes, it's a pretty good business here in Luxembourg, especially since pandemics). They were clear on one point: Trinnov is the one and only room correction system that is actually working.
Well not because I'm an American, lol, but I have limited experience with room correction algorithms, so far only having tried two of them. Emotiva's room correction as implemented on the MR1L is garbage, not worth the effort of using it. The room correction on my Wiim Ultra streamer is a bit better, though it does not make dramatic improvements. Its fairly subtle. And perhaps that in itself is an indication of a proper implementation. It cannot fix everything but it fixes what it can. The final outcome is mighty good. That said, I would love to try a Trinnov if not for the channels offered for the room correction alone. Alas it is well out of the price range of being affordable.
 
So this thing will be the limiting factor by far when paired with Ncore, Purifi or Benchmark amplifiers in both distortion AND noise?

That's horrible. :eek:

Joking aside, I assume it's possible to use this thing as a pure digital processor and just send digital out to a proper high-quality multichannel dac, like the Okto Dac8?
I am not being a smartass when I ask you why in the world would you want to use a proper multichannel dac if you have already dropped 18k on a Trinnov. One would assume that at that price its internal DAC is SOTA. Please explain
 
Agreed - but as you said, 1/10 of the price is one thing but at what price point should such reliability and service be expected? With Yamaha now charging $3,000 for their just released flagship RX-A8A, we don't expect this premium piece to receive any better support than their $500 receiver. So this begs the question: at what price point should consumers expect concierge service from the manufacturer?
Very interesting question. Its my opinion, and probably an unpopular one, that no matter what price point, the equipment should do what the marketing department claims. No exceptions. The company has an obligation to stand behind the product and properly compensate customers who receive products that don't live up to the hype. The sad thing is there is so much pure junk being sold today I hardly know where to start. To top it off, the companies are not standing behind what they sell. WHich brings us to this point: Quality and Reliability should be a reasonable expectation as well as a good customer service experience if you receive a troublesome piece of equipment. So at what price point can you actually expect to get that in today's marketplace? And what manufacturer will give you that at a price point that is less than the cost of nice car? I already have written off Emotiva as being a company I want to interact with again. My last experience with them was as unpleasant as it gets. Are there any companies other than Trinnov that actually make the cut?
 
Well not because I'm an American, lol, but I have limited experience with room correction algorithms, so far only having tried two of them. Emotiva's room correction as implemented on the MR1L is garbage, not worth the effort of using it. The room correction on my Wiim Ultra streamer is a bit better, though it does not make dramatic improvements. Its fairly subtle. And perhaps that in itself is an indication of a proper implementation. It cannot fix everything but it fixes what it can. The final outcome is mighty good. That said, I would love to try a Trinnov if not for the channels offered for the room correction alone. Alas it is well out of the price range of being affordable.

For stereo Trinnov Nova is a good alternative - pro equipment, but all the bells and whistles of Trimmov optimizer. sans Waveforming. Not that crazy expensive either.

 
Irrelevant. Fixed objects and bed channels do not render to speakers like Front Wides despite correlated information present between the front mains and side surrounds in most movies and surround recordings. $20k-48k and Atmos still doesn't use those extra speakers properly.

This purely Dolby's fault. Scatmos gets around the problem as does Neural X from base 2.0/5.1/7.1 soundtracks. DTS:X Pro doesn't exhibit the problem either. It's directly related to Dolby's implementation of object rendering (particularly with fixed objects which unfortunately are used a LOT in movie soundtracks) versus bed channels.



Routing and summing do not necessarily mean Matrix decoding or logic steering. A mixer sums, but it doesn't give discrete output for a summed center.



None of those help the above described Atmos issue with fixed and bed objects not using speakers like Wides WHATSOEVER.



Um, no. Auromatic isn't in the same galaxy as Logic 7. Auromatic is nothing more than a cheap reverb copy system. On the plus side, it doesn't screw with the front sound stage, but it does little more than a cheap DSP reverb effect. It's not even close to what Logic 7 does.

Neural X works well with 5.1 and 7.1 sources, but so well with stereo. So the idea would be to use the Trinnov 7.1 inputs with an analog Logic 7.1 output and run Neural X on it to separate out an overhead layer from the 7.1 base. That is something I'd love to play with.



Trinnov supports all 10 overheads simultaneously and more is better for precision imaging across multiple seating rows or a long room. Six is usually sufficient for most medium to semi-large rooms.

I use reverse polarity Scatmos for my overheads. Instead of steering discrete output to the center output, reversing the polarity sends it to two or more surround outputs instead (you then right the polarity on the speakers). This gives me Tops from Heights for 8 overheads (and quad mono VOG in Auro-3D). You could do 10 overheads with a 6.1 PLIIx AVR and my room would normally be small enough to get by with only six overhead speakers, but my room has a steel beam box where Top Middle would be mounted so Heights+Tops gets around the problem very well.

I have heights above ear layer speakers angled at MLP and speakers are capable to go down to 60Hz without compression. I run heights bit hotter to enhance immersion and you need to carefully adjsut bass management in order not to get too pronounced bass, once you get into stronger Auromatic setting.



You're the only person I've EVER heard from thousands that has claimed Neural X is unlistenable. I can only surmise that there's either something wrong with your Trinnov or the way you hear.

IMO, arrays, summing etc is no substitute for discrete steering to more speakers. Neural X can make a 5.1 version of an Atmos soundtrack (e.g. The Meg) sound almost exactly like the Atmos version. Dolby's own Pro Logic II steering can make a pretty discrete center between two analog inputs (no leakage with fully correlated in-phase inputs).

This is the same basic thing the panning renderer in Atmos does when adding additional speakers between say the Front and Rear Heights (Top Middle Left & Right). It renders based on the object position rather than the amount of correlated panned content, but panning is panning.

I'm curious about Scatmos. Is it a program that can be used in Trinov?
 
Back
Top Bottom