• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Topping MA4 Monitor Speaker Review

Rate this speaker:

  • 1. Poor (headless panther)

    Votes: 33 16.2%
  • 2. Not terrible (postman panther)

    Votes: 111 54.4%
  • 3. Fine (happy panther)

    Votes: 51 25.0%
  • 4. Great (golfing panther)

    Votes: 9 4.4%

  • Total voters
    204
Thank you for the review @amirm,

Could the internal powerAmp be partially responsible for some of these distortion products?

Just for information
It uses a bi-amplification (50W RMS for the 4-inch paper-cone woofer + 25W RMS for the 1-inch soft dome tweeter) with a purely analog signal path.

Also found these attached pictures
 

Attachments

  • Capture+_2026-11-04-07-27-25.png
    Capture+_2026-11-04-07-27-25.png
    1 MB · Views: 89
  • Capture+_2026-11-04-07-29-39.png
    Capture+_2026-11-04-07-29-39.png
    2.3 MB · Views: 83
Last edited:
A bad tongue could say a typical Topping product, optimised for some score like Harman or SINAD but failing as a total in real use. ;)

Also at 190$ it is too close to the JBL 305/6 (soon MKIII generation will be on the market) or KALI LP6 V2 which in total are a less of a compromise.
 
Do you know if this point has been corrected ?
I saw that after I did my measurements but before listening tests. I tried to feel air escaping from the back with my hand but did not detect any. Not a conclusive thing but I did try. :)
 
That smoothly narrowing directivity looks like what Harry at Audio First goes for with his designs, also using moulded waveguides to achieve it
 
I saw that after I did my measurements but before listening tests. I tried to feel air escaping from the back with my hand but did not detect any. Not a conclusive thing but I did try. :)

Thanks, this could potentially be attributed to a manufacturing defect in the model tested by @Nuyes .
 
Oh yeah, seems like we have yet again another Topping product with QC issues.
:rolleyes:

edit: might be just in a few samples, time will tell

By the way why is it "smart" to add internal volume by adding depth to the enclosure? I'd think just the opposite - if one would like to use these as NF monitors that kind of shape is not smart.. I mean, that's their intended use?
 
Thanks Amir. A Topping that's not recommended, who'd have thought it?
Topping are known for their compact desktop electronics, aren't they?
These strike me as desktop speakers - an alternative to using headphones.
The bass alignment seems to be a fixable mistake, but otherwise I was quite pleasantly surprised.
 
Oh yeah, seems like we have yet again another Topping product with QC issues.
:rolleyes:

edit: might be just in a few samples, time will tell

By the way why is it "smart" to add internal volume by adding depth to the enclosure? I'd think just the opposite - if one would like to use these as NF monitors that kind of shape is not smart.. I mean, that's their intended use?
I think it's more like "clever" instead of "smart". Compromises need to be made to get deep bass extension using small drivers at this price point.

To your point, I also agree with you that the large enclosure means this is a tough sell for desktop use. They're as deep as a Revel M106! I think these are intended to actually sit on a bookshelf. I could picture a scenario where I'd use these but the size is prohibitive for me at this point in my life.
 
Thanks Amir. A Topping that's not recommended, who'd have thought it?
Topping are known for their compact desktop electronics, aren't they?
These strike me as desktop speakers - an alternative to using headphones.
The bass alignment seems to be a fixable mistake, but otherwise I was quite pleasantly surprised.

I think they're way too deep for being desktop monitors: 28,8 cm, 11,3". The shape is like a miniature shipping container and reminds me of Elac BS305 and BS312.2. Don't get me wrong - I do like the look.

If you have desk against a wall positioning these can be problematic and finding suitable desktop stands can be difficult as well. So they're far from compact in their class (4" driver powered desktop monitors) if you compare against other similar products, not to mention the stupendous distortion. As someone pointed out earlier, these hardly seem like serious speakers. And yes, I read the review and that high pass fixes the issue - assuming one has software capable of it - but then again Topping advertises deep bass.

For comparison of depth:

Topping MA4: 28,8cm (11,3")
Kali Audio LP-UNF: 18,6cm (7,3")
Adam Audio D3V:15cm (5,9")
Adam Audio A4V: 22cm (8,7")

Topping MA4 is 92% deeper than Adam D3V, for example.

edit: couple of typos
 
What happens if you block the port with foam? I know generally this is a bad idea, not really converting a ported speaker into a sealed one but some inbetween abomination, but it's worth a shot.

Also an interesting tidbit, a comment from who I assume to be the ASR Topping representative/engineer under a YT video for 3D printed speakers with high performance waveguides:

The MA4 is apparently the result of his experiments with making waveguides. And he also said this: "...but here's the challenge: make 4inch to reach below 50Hz and no port noise".
 
I thought this was a really decent speaker from the spinorama. @amirm , do you have a rough measurement of dB at 1m that you can listen at before the bass distortions become an issue? They seem like really decent speakers for use as PC desktop speakers either side of your monitor.
 
Impressive first effort. Shame about the distortion
 
As an alternative, I’m looking forward to the review of the 3-way Teufel Studio 5X. Teufel developed this model using the Klippel NFS; in my opinion, it should be quite promising.

 
Seem like a poor choice to try to fill a room, but for desktop speakers to use with a PC at low volumes, a fantastic option. I'd be curious to see / hear how these guys perform with a sub taking over below 80Hz - seems like that would address the only significant problem (issues with resonance aside) with these speakers at moderate volumes.
 
A bad tongue could say a typical Topping product, optimised for some score like Harman or SINAD but failing as a total in real use. ;)
I mean I'll come out and say it, Topping stuff usually is like that.
 
This looks like an decent for people who live in small apartments where listening distances are close and volumes must be kept low. I could see this doing much better in urban China than other markets. If these are kept below 80 dB, the sound quality to cost ratio must be great. I have a pair of Revel F206 myself and as an apartment dweller I never push the volume past 75 dB @ 1 meter. These have a pref score of 6.0 while the JBL 306p and Kali LP-6 each are 5.2, so within their ability range these should sound meaningfully better. However, for bigger rooms or higher volumes, it is hard to ignore that the JBL 308p mkII is currently on close out for cheaper than these.
 
I am sure they had their reasons but a small monitor that has more depth (288 mm) than height (255 mm) seems a very odd design choice.
 
Maybe this is another entry in the computer desktop market with a listening distance of half a meter and an added sub?
 
Back
Top Bottom