• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Topping DX1 II DAC & HP Amp Review

Rate this DAC & HP Amp

  • 1. Poor (headless panther)

    Votes: 13 4.5%
  • 2. Not terrible (postman panther)

    Votes: 13 4.5%
  • 3. Fine (happy panther)

    Votes: 41 14.1%
  • 4. Great (golfing panther)

    Votes: 224 77.0%

  • Total voters
    291
You could add tubes to get desired distortion?

Buf from Schiit is a cheap way to get started down that rabbit hole.

In this forum, technical performance means transparency

"Sound colour" means faulty for electronics like amp or DAC where the goal should be inaudible levels of noise and distortion IOW accurate fidelity, transparency

This sort of verbiage

> fast, tight, punchy bass, not so dry, a little bit lean, detail, spicy, clinical, fun

is like arguing with atheists about saints and angels
 
is like arguing with atheists about saints and angels
Nah, the religious are the tube folks, the chosen people with the golden ears
 
If you use the DX1 II as a preamplifier with RCA outputs, the volume of the clicking sound depends on the input sensitivity of the power amplifier. With sensitive amplifiers, it is quite loud and unpleasant, though it won't blow out the speakers. I have two other DACs, both of which operate completely silently in the same setup.
Do any of those two work without external power supply, like the DX1 II?, because that is one of the main advantages of the DX1 II (and the DX 1, which unfortunately has now become difficult to find, Topping seems to have discontinued it). If choice is open to any dac with external power supply, then there are a high number of dacs that can be chosen instead.
However I need a dac without external power supply but with high output volume (due to hearing impairment. Most small type of dongles are not sufficiently loud for me).
 
Do any of those two work without external power supply, like the DX1 II
This feature is, being USB bus powered, pretty common.

> high output volume (due to hearing impairment.

So you mean the Headphone Amp section?

There are many that do that, you do not need a DAC to be included to get that, many accept analog inputs.

But it depends on what type of phones you are pairing with it.

The three things special with this model besides its flaws, are the internal DSP PEQ, the added DDC function with TOSlink output and the stellar SINAD measurements.

Do you need any of those?
 
Last edited:
Firmware notes for V16.07.23.07 contains:
Fixed: A popping noise when the device automatically woke from OPT input.

I have a WiiM Mini connected to OPT in and still a very loud pop when its woken by the stream (both mode1 and mode2). Very unpleasant.

The sample rate changes on USB produce a tiny pop just like my E50 did, i can live with that. But maybe its only my setup, but Tidal in exclusive mode changes sample rate on this device very slowly, sometimes 6-9 seconds elapse until the audio plays. and Tidal already restarting the stream, based on the logs. The seek bar is off by the amount of time the DAC reacts to the sample rate change. Streaming through the WiiM mini doesn't act like this, so most likely its my PC. Could anybody report on this back?
 
Firmware notes for V16.07.23.07 contains:
Fixed: A popping noise when the device automatically woke from OPT input.

I have a WiiM Mini connected to OPT in and still a very loud pop when its woken by the stream (both mode1 and mode2). Very unpleasant.

The sample rate changes on USB produce a tiny pop just like my E50 did, i can live with that. But maybe its only my setup, but Tidal in exclusive mode changes sample rate on this device very slowly, sometimes 6-9 seconds elapse until the audio plays. and Tidal already restarting the stream, based on the logs. The seek bar is off by the amount of time the DAC reacts to the sample rate change. Streaming through the WiiM mini doesn't act like this, so most likely its my PC. Could anybody report on this back?
Topping support is a complete shame, I sent them two messages reporting the sample rate change glitch but I have never received a response so far.
As a consequence I will never purchase a Topping device until I will receive a response. Period.

Ale
 
A few days ago, Topping Support finally replied to my original email.
Their initial response seemed to address a distortion issue I had never experienced, suggesting that I adjust the sensitivity of the connected amplifier.
After I clarified that my problem was actually the pops and clicks occurring when switching sample rates, they thanked me for bringing the issue to their attention and said they would pass the information on to their technical department for consideration in future revisions.
At this point, I’m not particularly optimistic that the noise issues discussed in this thread will be resolved for existing units, although I certainly hope to be proved wrong. Topping’s response doesn’t really indicate whether a firmware fix might be possible or whether the problem would require a hardware revision.

Perhaps we’ll have to wait for the DX1 III. Hopefully not! :-)
 
You were lucky @rodelius !

I have received a message today where it’s clear they pretend to be not aware of the issue, that’s contrasting completely with what you are reporting!

In the message I received after almost two weeks from my message to the support, they even suggest to set the sample rate at a fixed value in Windows!!! I don’t even comment the other suggestions.
Can’t believe.


“Thank you for contacting TOPPING support. We are happy to assist.
To help us further investigate the issue, we recommend trying the following troubleshooting steps:
  1. Set a Fixed Sample Rate: If you are using Windows, try setting a fixed sample rate (such as 24-bit/48 kHz) in the system sound settings and playing music in shared mode to see if the issue persists.
  2. Test the Headphone Output: Please check whether the issue occurs only through the RCA preamp output or also through the headphone output.
  3. Try a Different Music Player: Try using another music player to determine whether the issue is related to a specific playback application.”
 
A few days ago, Topping Support finally replied to my original email.
Their initial response seemed to address a distortion issue I had never experienced, suggesting that I adjust the sensitivity of the connected amplifier.
After I clarified that my problem was actually the pops and clicks occurring when switching sample rates, they thanked me for bringing the issue to their attention and said they would pass the information on to their technical department for consideration in future revisions.
At this point, I’m not particularly optimistic that the noise issues discussed in this thread will be resolved for existing units, although I certainly hope to be proved wrong. Topping’s response doesn’t really indicate whether a firmware fix might be possible or whether the problem would require a hardware revision.

Perhaps we’ll have to wait for the DX1 III. Hopefully not! :-)
I received the exact same answer from Topping a few months ago. Topping doesn't know how to fix the loud popping sound. Perhaps, in time, they will quietly produce a new hardware revision DX1 II that resolves the issue.
 
they even suggest to set the sample rate at a fixed value in Windows!!!
Sorry I don't understand your indignation?

Setting the OS aside, if it indeed prevents the problem (s), in a home recreational use case

and assuming no further DSP transformations are needed,

sticking to a single sample rate upstream will not make any audible difference in SQ.

Perfectly valid workaround.

My question is only "does it indeed solve the problem?" Allowing choice of any output?

 
Sorry I don't understand your indignation?

Setting the OS aside, if it indeed prevents the problem (s), in a home recreational use case

and assuming no further DSP transformations are needed,

sticking to a single sample rate upstream will not make any audible difference in SQ.

Perfectly valid workaround.

My question is only "does it indeed solve the problem?" Allowing choice of any output?

Dear John,
My frustration is quite straightforward: I bought a DAC expecting it to handle a bit-perfect workflow, including sample-rate changes, without audible glitches. That is a basic expectation, not an exotic audiophile requirement.
Even if forcing a fixed sample rate prevents the clicks, it does not address my complaint about the device.

Whether resampling makes an audible difference is beside the point. I should not have to change my playback setup to accommodate a DAC’s malfunction, and receiving that suggestion from the manufacturer instead of a proper response to the reported issue is hardly reassuring.

You may consider the workaround acceptable for your own use. That is entirely your choice. It seems I have a bit more demanding requirements as I am sure most of the participants in Audio Science Review forums

Sincerely,
Ale
 
Yes, as I have stated previously I am here only looking for workarounds, not in any way saying such major faults are excusable.

Horrible customer service and occasionally broken products are the norm, what I expect by default from certain brands / classes of manufacturers.

I don't let this state of affairs stop me, if I did I simply could not afford the hobby.

And yes sticking to 48Hz or under is already dictated by the same value equation up stream, so for me personally if the workaround actually works, then I'm very happy to use the product, a true unicorn for dirt cheap.
 
I really hope there's another update which fixes it. The pop and crackle when it comes out of standby is so annoying.
 
I'd have thought if that were going to happen, it would've by now.
 
This feature is, being USB bus powered, pretty common.

> high output volume (due to hearing impairment.

So you mean the Headphone Amp section?

There are many that do that, you do not need a DAC to be included to get that, many accept analog inputs.

But it depends on what type of phones you are pairing with it.

The three things special with this model besides its flaws, are the internal DSP PEQ, the added DDC function with TOSlink output and the stellar SINAD measurements.

Do you need any of those?
I am aware usb bus powered is pretty common, however the headphone amp section might not be loud enough for me on all such devices (for example, I own an Audioengine D1 and the headphone out is not loud enough, I need to use an extra headphone amp to use that).
I own a DX1 (first version), due to my hearing impairement I use it in high gain, almost at highest volume, connected via USB to a PC. It works well (that's why I'm interested in the DX1 II). That is my main set up when I am not at home, often on the go. At home I have Topping E70 + L70.
So I do need a dac + headphone amp (for the a/m use), it must be loud, low distortion even in high gain, and possibly usb powered.
The headphones I use are usually ear buds from Sennheiser (MX470) or IE 200.
The stellar SINAD is nice to have, TOSlink out is not needed, the DSP PEQ would be nice as it might help recover some of my impairement (I have the frequency response of my ears plotted by Oticon - I use their hearing aids normally).
 
I have just received yet another response from Topping support regarding the DX1 II sample-rate switching glitch.

At this point, I’m honestly not sure whether this is a joke, a sign of technical incompetence, or simply another automated, copy-and-paste response.

What is certain is that they keep failing to address the actual issue. We are talking about an audible glitch occurring during sample-rate transitions, NOT a distortion problem. These are two entirely different things.

And yet, they are now suggesting that “slight distortion is normal”. Seriously?

It’s astonishing how a reputable manufacturer can undermine its own reputation through such poor technical support.
The hardware issue itself is disappointing enough. But the apparent inability — or unwillingness — to understand and properly address a clearly described technical problem is even more frustrating.

Topping, this is not the level of support your customers should expect.
In the meanwhile I have returned my unit to Amazon. End of the story.

Here is their latest response:

———

Dear Alessandro,

Thank you for reporting this issue. Slight distortion is normal. If the distortion is significant, you can try the following:

1. Turn both the source and device volumes to maximum, and adjust the volume using the downstream device. If connected to a computer, ensure the computer's system volume, playback software, and driver volumes are all at maximum.

2. If your speakers have sensitivity adjustments, try lowering the sensitivity.

3. Try connecting the RCA output to other devices. If the distortion is still significant after checking and ruling out the above methods, you can send it back for us to inspect.

If possible, please record a video for us showing the RCA output switching sample rates, so we can use it for reference.

We take your feedback very seriously and will assist you in troubleshooting the issue as soon as possible.


Best regards,
 
Y'all really do have IMO unrealistic expectations.

Quality tech support is not commonly available direct to consumers from firms in this industry that compete on price from outside the West

especially when those engineering the products likely are many layers removed from public facing positions and English competency is rare.

If you really "demand" goid customer service on tracking down technical glitches, then boycott those firms and in most cases, be prepared to spend a lot more money.

There are some Western exceptions ofc, and maybe even some Asian ones, members please post recommendations.

In my case I just realize being an early adopter is risky, and sometimes I just have to accept a loss.
 
Y'all really do have IMO unrealistic expectations.

Quality tech support is not commonly available direct to consumers from firms in this industry that compete on price from outside the West

especially when those engineering the products likely are many layers removed from public facing positions and English competency is rare.

If you really "demand" goid customer service on tracking down technical glitches, then boycott those firms and in most cases, be prepared to spend a lot more money.

There are some Western exceptions ofc, and maybe even some Asian ones, members please post recommendations.

In my case I just realize being an early adopter is risky, and sometimes I just have to accept a loss.
Ok, that’s your YOO (your own opinion, reverse of IMO ;-) ) but I again totally disagree.

I had similar conversation in January with SMSL and their support was at a completely different level. Very professional.

As for product quality, I have different Chinese-made products that are just excellent regardless of the price, competing with best “west” brands. That’s was true even with Topping. I use a D10s daily and it is a fantastic device.
One more reason to be disappointed by what it seems a new course of the Chinese brand.

Ale
 
It's not mere support if we get unfinished products into our homes, the early buyers are beta-testers and Topping in case of DX1 II needs user input
 
Back
Top Bottom