• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

toe-in: aim for the ears, or the nose, or...?

krabapple

Master Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Apr 15, 2016
Messages
5,551
Likes
7,364
Owning a laser level and distance meter is so triggering to one's OCD.
Once you can literally 'see' the tweeter axis, you start wondering.

AIUI a standard view for toe-ing in speakers is, aim at the ears. This means the two axial 'rays' intersect (i.e. make a vertex) a little behind your head. This, one would think, maximizes treble direct sound (the AI demon seems to agree w/me on that) and 'pinpoint imaging'.
Still, crude schematic views of speaker set-up very typically show the vertex at the nose or the center of the head (i.e., a little bit more toe-in than the first case). One benefit I can imagine from that is, it directs slightly less energy to the first sidewall reflections.

What say youse guys? Would it tend to even matter?

(Please don't lead with 'it depends on the speaker'. Imagine plain front-firing bookshelfs speakers on stands, or floorstanders, nothing exotic, that benefit from toe-in.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: ob1
What say youse guys? Would it tend to even matter?
Not in the slightest.

We're talking about, like, 1-5º differences here.

Peruse some of the directivity measurements here and on erinsaudiocorner.com and you'll see that changes nothing.
 
Last edited:
Owning a laser level and distance meter is so triggering to one's OCD.
Once you can literally 'see' the tweeter axis, you start wondering.

AIUI a standard view for toe-ing in speakers is, aim at the ears. This means the two axial 'rays' intersect (i.e. make a vertex) a little behind your head. This, one would think, maximizes treble direct sound (the AI demon seems to agree w/me on that) and 'pinpoint imaging'.
Still, crude schematic views of speaker set-up very typically show the vertex at the nose or the center of the head (i.e., a little bit more toe-in than the first case). One benefit I can imagine from that is, it directs slightly less energy to the first sidewall reflections.

What say youse guys? Would it tend to even matter?

(Please don't lead with 'it depends on the speaker'. Imagine plain front-firing bookshelfs speakers on stands, or floorstanders, nothing exotic, that benefit from toe-in.)
If you point them to vertex in front of you, as your head moves towards say, the right, the left speaker will point at your left ear, and vice-versa. Tends to keep the channels sounding the same level as you move slightly. Having said that, I aim mine at my ears.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ob1
I use neither. I cross them in front of me, ≈40° toe-in.It gives me the right mix of phantom image and width without it being too small and centered phantom image (45° does that...).
 
Good thing I don't have a laser level then :) Depends on speaker and room as to how I might aim them, but mostly ears.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ob1
Owning a laser level and distance meter is so triggering to one's OCD.
Once you can literally 'see' the tweeter axis, you start wondering.

AIUI a standard view for toe-ing in speakers is, aim at the ears. This means the two axial 'rays' intersect (i.e. make a vertex) a little behind your head. This, one would think, maximizes treble direct sound (the AI demon seems to agree w/me on that) and 'pinpoint imaging'.
Still, crude schematic views of speaker set-up very typically show the vertex at the nose or the center of the head (i.e., a little bit more toe-in than the first case). One benefit I can imagine from that is, it directs slightly less energy to the first sidewall reflections.

What say youse guys? Would it tend to even matter?

(Please don't lead with 'it depends on the speaker'. Imagine plain front-firing bookshelfs speakers on stands, or floorstanders, nothing exotic, that benefit from toe-in.)
My dude... it would seem you're worrying too much. OCD is a bitch. :D

These tiny angle differences, how much do they really do? You can make an educated guess and a good estimation by looking at your speakers' dispersion pattern. Within, say, +-5° horizontally, how much changes there?

Answer that to yourself. Then you'll get my point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ob1
Please don't lead with 'it depends on the speaker'.
Well, it depends on the speaker :P, but excluding unusual designs with extremely narrow horizontal directivity, the angular difference is small enough that it doesn't matter at normal listening distances. It's perhaps worth noting that many speakers measure somewhat better slightly off axis, so pointing the axis directly at either cephalic protrusion may not be optimal. Speakers with narrow-ish, relatively constant directivity tend to work best crossed in front of the listener (toed in 40-50°).
 
There are general rules to follow (as you've seen) but you need to really adjust based on your room. For my Revels the manual recommends shooting for the focal point to be directly behind the head. This didn't work in practice for me as my room was throwing off the stereo image and was focusing it to the right, with a large gap left-center. I had to tighten the toe-in to focus more in front of my head and that corrected it. Go for whatever sounds best to you and don't sweat the rest of the details as you've already achieved what you needed to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ob1
1789513076461.png


Joe knows.
 
I have liked every post, for you've made my day!

OCD here. When I am in the mood for some serious listening, I take my trusty laser distance measurer, place it right next to my right ear and shoot : 1,82 m is a perfect seating distance. Then I do the same with left ear and most of the time, it is also at 1,82 m for corresponding left speaker. How proud am I, I had seated in the SWEET spot! Yes!

Then, I calm, relax and enjoy the music.

However, I am also ADHD and I cannot stand still for more than a few seconds. Shoot, measure, repeat.

Of note, guess what is the distance between each speaker? 1,82 m ;)

Then one day I realized : shit, I had measured listening distance with grille on!!! KEF Q7, grille has about 4 cm depht. So I arranged my seating position to 1,78 m. Move a little. Repeat, etc.

Then I realized the speaker is a little recessed, its acoustic center not flush with the speaker front panel.

Then, I thought, wait a minute, it may be a coaxial, but is the acoustic center of every speaker exactly at the same spot???

Then... I move and measure and I am happy and I listen to music and. and . and.
Can't stay still.

Sometimes, I make huge efforts not to measure. My enjoyment is a bit compromised until I oblige himself, then I finally measure. I may have to move a bit laterally.
I guess this is called active listening.

Sorry, forgot to mention the speakers are not toed-in, they point straight, I am exactly at 45 deg, +- 3 deg.
 
I take my trusty laser distance measurer, place it right next to my right ear and shoot : 1,82 m is a perfect seating distance. Then I do the same with left ear and most of the time, it is also at 1,82 m for corresponding left speaker...

Of note, guess what is the distance between each speaker? 1,82 m...

Sorry, forgot to mention the speakers are not toed-in, they point straight, I am exactly at 45 deg, +- 3 deg.

Pardon my OCDness, but wouldn't the equilateral triangle you describe, with speakers pointing straight ahead, put you at 30 degrees off-axis rather than 45 degrees off-axis? Or, have I missed something, or misunderstood you?
 
@Duke, you have unmasked me! You are indeed right, it is mathematically impossible. All of said criterias cannot be exact.
The speakers are not aimed at 45 deg, but indeed 30 deg.
Too many homebrewed beers, I suspect.
The rest holds true, until someone uncovers another of my beginner mistake(s).
I stand corrected.
Your OCDness, as far as maths are concerned, is far greater than mine :)

Damn, those ASR members, they are so clever! Now you know why I refrain from posting too often... Still, you are a true gentleman!
 
Last edited:
Your OCDness, as far as maths are concerned, is far greater than mine :)

Ha! It takes one to know one, my friend!

Too many homebrewed beers...

When it comes to homebrewed beers, is there really such a thing as "too many"??
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ob1
The first thing you need is this:

1789526028590.png


Insert your head into the apparatus and get your assistant to tighten the screws. Then use your laser pointer to aim the speakers at your ears. Enjoy the rest of your listening session.
 
Back
Top Bottom