This is B.Y.O.B. with default Declipper and Natural Dynamics, -7.7 dB gain, -13.7 dB RMS and "DR12":
Almost no peaks go above -3 dBFS, so it is as much "DR12" as some 80s master with one freak peak and everything else at -5 dBFS is "DR15". To me the result here is more DR9 than DR12.
DR9 can already sound excellent, given a good mix and EQ. I dislike the mentality to scoff at anything below DR12, when the truth is that most pop, rock and metal does not need any more than DR8 to DR10 to sound good. The Beatles remasters all come in between DR9 and DR11, most of the albums are DR10. I would not dare complain about their dynamic range.
When it comes to declipping, I would rather go for less, as there is very little value in leaving in those few very high peaks, but potentially they come with noticeable channel imbalance or other off-sounding quirks.
Almost no peaks go above -3 dBFS, so it is as much "DR12" as some 80s master with one freak peak and everything else at -5 dBFS is "DR15". To me the result here is more DR9 than DR12.
DR9 can already sound excellent, given a good mix and EQ. I dislike the mentality to scoff at anything below DR12, when the truth is that most pop, rock and metal does not need any more than DR8 to DR10 to sound good. The Beatles remasters all come in between DR9 and DR11, most of the albums are DR10. I would not dare complain about their dynamic range.
When it comes to declipping, I would rather go for less, as there is very little value in leaving in those few very high peaks, but potentially they come with noticeable channel imbalance or other off-sounding quirks.