• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

The Courteous Vinyl Playback Discussion

What is progressive about Rush??
I'll let Max explain it:

Rush​

The Canadian progressive rock band comprised of Geddy Lee, Alex Lifeson, and Neil Peart are regarded as an influential prog rock band.

Published on
June 24, 2020
By: Max Bell

Rush photo by Fin Costello and Redferns

Photo: Fin Costello/Redferns

The history of the mighty Rush could and has filled many a book. Since their inception in 1968 – and of course, they remain a vital force five decades later – the Canadian power plus trio have thrilled listeners and audiences with their heady blend of prog, intelligent heavy metal and hard rock balladry, defying time and tide.

They were inducted into the Rock and Hall of Fame in 2013 as a band while the individual members – Geddy Lee, Alex Lifeson and Neil Peart hold numerous individual gongs. Longevity and critical acclaim aside, Rush have had sales approaching 40 million along with numerous gold, platinum and multi-platinum discs. Their bluesy metal overtures have evolved across the years as they embraced serious progression and thrilling synthesiser sounds.

In keeping with their auxiliary work above and beyond the call of duty these good guys are actively involved in philanthropic causes, ranging from UNICEF liaisons to human rights activism. They have played countless benefits in their homeland, where they are simply musical gods and that acclaim spreads across the globe.

Following fledgeling performances in their native Willowdale, a neighbourhood of Toronto, Ontario, the origins of Rush took shape when Lee joined forces with original drummer John Rutsey and then frontman Jeff Jones. It wasn’t long before Lee replaced Jones and Lifeson jumped on board. Originally influenced by exposure to the heavy end of the British blues boom, specifically, the sounds of Led Zeppelin, Deep Purple et al, Rush carved out a loyal local following but struggled to break out until 1974 when their self-titled debut was swiftly followed by Rutsey’s departure and the arrival of Peart.

The group now concentrated on their instrumental skills, spending hours in rehearsals. It was solid groundwork. The debut Rush was coloured by elements of Cream and boasts a fine crisp production, harbinger of the outfit’s insistence on technical excellence. Much loved by fans for its more idiosyncratic bluesy styling, the album contains early classics like the self-explanatory ‘Finding My Way’, the blue-collar anthem ‘Working Man’ and ‘In The Mood’.

Having set the groundwork, the template was subtly shifted for Fly By Night, with Peart’s arrival as super drummer and lyricist. Elements of fantasy entered Rush’s realm on ‘By-Tor & The Snow Dog’ (a suite in eight parts) and ‘Rivendell’ while the influence of Peart’s favourite philosopher Ayn Rand became apparent. Engineer Terry Brown, a key figure during this time, ensured clarity of sound that made Rush many an audiophile’s go-to rock band.

Caress of Steel (1975) picked up the baton as the trio entered epic territory on ‘The Necromancer’ and ‘The Fountain of Lamneth’, both revered items in their repertoire but it was the monumental 2112 album that made people sit up and take note. For Rush, this was their precursor to true break out mainstream acceptance. Mixing side two’s concise cuts with the title piece sweep of side one, Lee, Lifeson and Peart sought out new sounds to match their increasing ambition. Guest player Hugh Syme was the ideal component since he added ARP Odyssey and mellotron. The die was cast. The reviews were hugely favourable. The tours were starting to become major events. Later recognition arrived via various polls (Rush are constant winners in various categories) and Rolling Stone has called 2112 one of the most important prog albums of all time.

The ensuing 2112 tour gifted the world the double live All the World’s a Stage and these players were certainly on top of their game. They’d made a quantum leap in two years and while live albums are notoriously slow sellers this one was not as it hit the US Top 40. The remastered version is a must-have since it reinstates all the vinyl cuts and duplicates the glorious triple gatefold sleeve.

A Farewell to Kings is much loved by British fans of course, partly because the trio had played the UK and recorded this disc at Rockfield Studios in South Wales. Geddy Lee now took over lyrical duties and there is a change of mood afoot in some softer, ballad-like pieces like ‘Madrigal’ and ‘Closer to the Heart’. Another chart smash, A Farewell to Kings saw Rush breach the British Top 30. Meanwhile, the increasing use of synths, Mini Moogs, classical twelve-strings and exotic percussion ensured Rush were a full-on experience.

Hemispheres saw them spending more time in Europe. They returned to Rockfield and mixed at the legendary Trident Studios. Peart took control of the writing again and infused the tracks with science-fiction motifs and surreal fantasy. Even so, they could look at themselves from outside, hence the playfully subtitled ‘La Villa Strangiato (An Exercise in Self-Indulgence)’. Nevertheless, sprawling, mood switching statements are what Rush’s fans demand and they get those with both barrels blazing on the brilliant ‘Cygnus X-1’ whose very name sends shivers down the spines of admirers and has inspired an entire culture of its own. When a band can reach that level of fanaticism they must be doing more than one thing right.

Permanent Waves (released New Year’s Day, 1980) soared to the top five in America and eventually sold platinum. Relocating to Quebec, they experimented again, infusing their brew with quirky time signatures, lashings of fantasy and an even more upfront role for Lifeson’s guitar. A nod towards reggae on ‘The Spirit of Radio’ indicated there was no desire to stand still and the disc received their best reviews to date and chart places top match.

Moving Pictures was and is Rush’s biggest seller, eventually achieving the quadruple-platinum effect. Adapting their sound to suit FM radio’s poppier side they hit with singles ‘Tom Sawyer’ and ‘Limelight’ and maintained their credibility on ‘Red Barchetta’ and ‘YYZ’. Melodically adroit throughout and yet packed with fervour, this album gives the lie to the naysayers and doubters. It’s a stone-cold classic.

Exit…Stage Left – another live beauty from 1981 now saw Rush capitalising on the video age and embracing the mixed 12-inch single. Recorded in Montreal and Glasgow, hotbeds both, this meaty double set is a gloriously conceived summation of their act at the time and rejuvenated the troops for their ninth studio disc, Signals where all-out assaults on rapidly ravenous technology informed their approach. Thanks to the diligence and a work ethic that would have sunk a lesser act Rush were now able to straddle the albums and singles market thus keeping them on heavy rotation thanks to stand out cuts like ‘New World Man’, ‘Subdivisions’ and ‘The Analog Kid’. Again the remaster is highly recommended.

1984’s Grace Under Pressure ushers in a sea change as long-time production associate Terry Brown was amicably replaced by Peter Henderson (Supertramp, Frank Zappa, King Crimson). Very much a concept album (previously they’d juggled various concepts within a whole) Peart’s concerns here are how society acts under pressure from technology, emotion and darker forces of evil. Eschewing programmed sounds Rush adopted an almost organic approach, stripping the instrumentation back and pushing the vocals to the front of the mix. They maintained that stance on Power Windows (recorded in England) and showed they were also fully conversant with the aftermath of the punk scene and even the emergence of the ZTT movement since they used Trevor Horn’s Sarm Studios in part and employed in-house strings arranger Anne Dudley from The Art of Noise. Hold Your Fire and A Show of Hands found Rush holding their own in the latter 1980s even though the musical terrain had shifted considerably. The latter live album is a perfect accompaniment to earlier on the board’s sets, containing magnificent versions of ‘Manhattan Project’, ‘Distant Warning’ and ‘Red Sector A’ – crowd pleasers to the nth degree.

For those with the desire to venture even further, we point you towards the comprehensive compilations – Chronicles, Retrospective I and Retrospective II (covering the years 1974-1980 and 1981-1987), The Spirit of Radio – Greatest Hits 1974-1987 and Gold which teams the Retrospective discs in a handy package. Very much an ongoing concern today, Rush is a prolific and potent force in the development and improvement of contemporary prog. Lee, Lifeson and Peart, we salute you.

Words: Max Bell

Format:
Union Jack flag
UK English
1970sAlex LifesonFly By NightFreewillGeddy LeeGroupLindy YoungNeil PeartProgressive RockRockRushTom SawyerYYZ
 
l let Max explain it:

Rush​

"Beloved by millions and scorned by critics." An interesting one line bio by Jason Ankeny on allmusic.com
 
"Beloved by millions and scorned by critics." An interesting one line bio by Jason Ankeny on allmusic.com
Depending on when the critical reviews were written, the same could be said of most of the prog greats, including Yes, Genesis (with Gabriel), and especially Emerson, Lake, and Palmer. I can remember all sorts of scorn for those groups in the late 70’s when punk took over in the hearts of Rolling Stone writers.

Rick “always seems to like what others scorn” Denney
 
  • Like
Reactions: EJ3
Depending on when the critical reviews were written, the same could be said of most of the prog greats, including Yes, Genesis (with Gabriel), and especially Emerson, Lake, and Palmer. I can remember all sorts of scorn for those groups in the late 70’s when punk took over in the hearts of Rolling Stone writers.

Rick “always seems to like what others scorn” Denney

I have, to my great sheepishness, become an enthusiastic fan of ABBA in the last few years. Buying the whole discography. Reading all the biographies. All that fan stuff.
They were pretty much excoriated by critics (and parts of the public) during their heyday as mechanical and soulless pop. (especially in their own country of Sweden !)

Today they are generally exalted by critics, and millions find their music deeply emotional and affecting. Amazing what time can do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EJ3
Did you buy original vinyl of new vinyl or digital versions? I have some CD compilations and the poor sound quality is hard to get past on many of the songs.

Actually, just double checking… I have only Five of their albums on vinyl:
Arrival
Voulez vous
Super trooper
The visitors
Voyage
(the rest I’ve listened to on streaming)

Voulez vous is my favourite album and I have both the original vinyl and the newer repress and both sound fantastic, really amazing on my system.

Even better is this Visitors vinyl release that I bought: holy moly does it sound amazing! Clean, clear, detailed, rich, spacious… you name it:


The Visitors = ザ・ビジターズ by ABBA (1981).

Shared by Discographic App

https://www.discogs.com/release/2469071-ABBA-アバ-The-Visitors-ザビジターズ
1769473409744.png


I bought the recent Abbey Road vinyl remaster of Super Trooper as well. It sounds really good for the most part from the mid range up, similar to the visitors. However, I find it extremely bass heavy to the point of an unbalanced sound.

The Voyage album (did you like it? I like some of it, being more amazed by the effort than the result)…. Actually is among the worst sounding I find both on vinyl and streaming (Tidal). There’s a sort of vague fuzziness to the sound like a bad mastering, makes it sound a bit opaque. That was a real disappointment.
 
A sidenote to "The Visitors" cover. I saw a ABBA documentary a few years ago, where there was an interview with the photographer who took the cover picture. He almost couldn't talk about that session, because it had been such a bad experience in a very saddening atmosphere.
 
A writer for the New York Times answers the question 'Should I Get Into Vinyl Records' ?

(gift) link


The article references (link below) a New Yorker cartoon on collecting vinyl I was unfamiliar with.... :)

 
A writer for the New York Times answers the question 'Should I Get Into Vinyl Records' ?

(gift) link


The article references (link below) a New Yorker cartoon on collecting vinyl I was unfamiliar with.... :)


Today, that cartoon also apply for CD players... there's much more convenience and money savings with streaming services.
 
Today, that cartoon also apply for CD players... there's much more convenience and money savings with streaming services.
I think this is true of most, but it depends on your tastes. I tried Spotify and Tidal and too much music is missing. My tastes are just a bit too eclectic. When I did find something it typically was a modern remaster I didn't care for with no way to access the original master. The cost of CDs is well worth it in my particular situation. Used CDs are still quite inexpensive and haven't had the resurgence vinyl has.

I hope physical media continues to survive as a streaming only world seems terrible to me. I like seeing records in stores even if they aren't my preferred format for listening.
 
Whether it’s cheaper to stream or buy CDs depends on if you’re paying for a streaming service and the number of CDs you buy in a year.
 
Streaming is key to helping me decide the music I would like to own on vinyl.
 
Did you buy original vinyl of new vinyl or digital versions? I have some CD compilations and the poor sound quality is hard to get past on many of the songs.
A late tale. I was informed that a central UK mastering facility did the earlier digital masterings (not sure if it was just the Abba Gold masterings or whole albums). The claim was that these songs needed work to 'sound best' for digital sources, but the record company said no and what you hear is what they were given to work with. I have somewhere, Abba Gold on CD and remember the sonics weren't very good at all.
 
I think this is true of most, but it depends on your tastes. I tried Spotify and Tidal and too much music is missing. My tastes are just a bit too eclectic. When I did find something it typically was a modern remaster I didn't care for with no way to access the original master. The cost of CDs is well worth it in my particular situation. Used CDs are still quite inexpensive and haven't had the resurgence vinyl has.

I hope physical media continues to survive as a streaming only world seems terrible to me. I like seeing records in stores even if they aren't my preferred format for listening.

I agree 100% with you ... but ... for the masses, the cartoon is true anyway. I use vinyl and CDs, because i love physical media, but i know i'm not part of the majority.
 
A writer for the New York Times answers the question 'Should I Get Into Vinyl Records' ?
Thank you for sharing, nice balanced article on the subject, I particularly like the last line:
“Whatever the format: Just keep listening.”

I still enjoy playing records and I am glad I kept most of my record collection. I also play CD’s and stored digital files. I do not stream much. I usually do not listen to music as background, I prefer silence.
To me listening to music is a dedicated activity, so actively seeking a medium, either physical or digital file on a nas is part of the process.
I use streaming to listen to something I do not have, but I always download it first.
The whole process of playing record has been part of my life since early 70’s and still bring me joy today, no reason to stop.
 
Last edited:
A late tale. I was informed that a central UK mastering facility did the earlier digital masterings (not sure if it was just the Abba Gold masterings or whole albums). The claim was that these songs needed work to 'sound best' for digital sources, but the record company said no and what you hear is what they were given to work with. I have somewhere, Abba Gold on CD and remember the sonics weren't very good at all.
I heard a similar tale about a company making heavyweight vinyl releases sometimes having to work from the CD.
 
Thank you for sharing, nice balanced article n the subject, I particularly like the last line:
“Whatever the format: Just keep listening.”

I still enjoy playing records and I am glad I kept most of my record collection. I also play CD’s and stored digital files. I do not stream much. I usually do not listen to music as background, I prefer silence.
To me listening to music is a dedicated activity, so actively seeking a medium, either physical or digital file on a nas is part of the process.
I use streaming to listen to something I do not have, but I always download it first.
The whole process of playing record has been part of my life since early 70’s and still bring me joy today, no reason to stop.

I enjoyed the article too. It was a good response.

I’ve just got back to listening to music on my system after a long absence (tinnitus flareup).
Just as before I’m finding myself enjoying vinyl more than my digital source. There’s an excitement when I pick out and hold a specific record in my hand from my collection, pulling it out and putting it on the turntable, that I just don’t get from flicking through tracks on my iPhone.
Plus, I love the sound.
 
It's all about collecting for me. I love the way every LP in my collection sounds different compared to the next. I also fully realize it is not the path to perfect sonic experience.
 
Today, that cartoon also apply for CD players... there's much more convenience and money savings with streaming services.
That's only possible if you live where you can receive a stream. I prefer living where you cannot.
And listening to what is available on streaming at friends homes, the goodness of which selection of something is hit & miss and you have no choice for the better cut. Each to their own, I guess.
 
Back
Top Bottom