• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Surge Protector Japan / Home Desktop

I live in Europe, I have SPD in the General Panel of the house, but even so, I decided to make another panel dedicated to the audio system, now I'm in the assembly stage.
In addition to all this protection, I decided to add a PDU with protection for the audio rack, I know I'm paranoid but it's better to sleep peacefully than to worry about the audio system.

I suspect that in Japan you must find something similar.
And yes, an SPD is a sacrificial piece, it discharges the overload to the ground very quickly in the event of a lightning strike for example, but the SPD will be destroyed, all this to protect your electrical equipment in the house.

View attachment 556867View attachment 556868View attachment 556869
Interesting, but it’s a moot point for my case. While I live in a nice apartment, it’s still a rental. It’s illegal in Japan to do any electrical work at all unless you are a licensed, certified electrician. Even something as basic as changing an outlet. Rental company and building owner corporation isnt going to give anyone the ok to do this - especially not the only white guy in the building. Plus the cost to do all of this and have to undo it when I move out certainly isn’t worth the time or money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DY2
After discussing it a bit with one of the members here and some reflection, the following options are where I’m at:

(Surge Protection/ Power)

Basic: Most of the standard Elecom brand surge protectors have 2p plugs which work flawlessly with normal Japanese 2p wall outlets. They have internal varistors, so they don’t rely on a ground to dump a surge.

Mid: There’s a specific model or two from Sanwa and Elecom which are 3p plugs and 3p inputs with included 3p to 2p adapters. They also offer basic noise reduction, as well. This can be used without the ground attached, but probably wouldn’t fair much better than the “basic” category above.

Top: The highest-end that I would consider is the Tripp Lite Isobar 6 (or 8) Ultra, which has excellent surge protection, but additionally has really great noise elimination. However, as noted above, since I can’t connect the ground wire, this renders all of the advanced features useless. It will handle basic surge suppression and noice reduction, but essentially it becomes an overpriced metal power strip.

* I’ll end up going with basic or mid (they are very similar). If in the future I find myself in a new apartment that allows a 3p wall outlet to be added or 2p with ground - I would step up to the Tripp Lite.

(Noise)

Basic: Cross my fingers that no ground loop or noise occurs between the Mac Mini, Apple Studio Display, powered speakers, and sub plugged into the same aurge protector (and using USB-C to connect speakers to Mac).

Mid: If noise, I have the option of ditching USB-C for a USB-C to Toslink adapter (and Toslink cable).

Top: Not sure there is one, as “mid” should solve it.

* Out of all the other audio systems I've had previously, which always incorporated either a MacBook Pro or iMac, I never had a ground loop. So hopefully I won’t with this iteration, as well. But I’ll have to go one step at a time and see what happens.
 
Last edited:
After discussing it a bit with one of the members here and some reflection, the following options are where I’m at:

(Surge Protection/ Power)

Basic: Most of the standard Elecom brand surge protectors have 2p plugs which work flawlessly with normal Japanese 2p wall outlets. They have internal varistors, so they don’t rely on a ground to dump a surge.

Mid: There’s a specific model or two from Sanwa and Elecom which are 3p plugs and 3p inputs with included 3p to 2p adapters. They also offer basic noise reduction, as well. This can be used without the ground attached, but probably wouldn’t fair much better than the “basic” category above.

Top: The highest-end that I would consider is the Tripp Lite Isobar 6 (or 8) Ultra, which has excellent surge protection, but additionally has really great noise elimination. However, as noted above, since I can’t connect the ground wire, this renders all of the advanced features useless. It will handle basic surge suppression and noice reduction, but essentially it becomes an overpriced metal power strip.

* I’ll end up going with basic or mid (they are very similar). If in the future I find myself in a new apartment that allows a 3p wall outlet to be added or 2p with ground - I would step up to the Tripp Lite.

(Noise)

Basic: Cross my fingers that no ground loop or noise occurs between the Mac Mini, Apple Studio Display, powered speakers, and sub plugged into the same aurge protector (and using USB-C to connect speakers to Mac).

Mid: If noise, I have the option of ditching USB-C for a USB-C to Toslink adapter (and Toslink cable).

Top: Not sure there is one, as “mid” should solve it.

* Out of all the other audio systems I've had previously, which always incorporated either a MacBook Pro or iMac, I never had a ground loop. So hopefully I won’t with this iteration, as well. But I’ll have to go one step at a time and see what happens.
Look like the ZeroSurge series mode surge protectors (and perhaps those from SurgeX too) will work without ground.
 
I am also not against “no surge protectors”, but when the overwhelming majority of people, forums, articles, websites, manufacturers, etc all seem to point to the benefits of having one, it’s kind of hard to roll the dice on going naked.
There is no dice to roll. Vast majority of audio gear and electronics in the world is running without such things. Where is all the electrical damage to them?

The tiny minority who wind up with is because the salesman makes more commission on that, than the TV or stereo you are buying from a store. Or they follow the crowd as you mention. These are tiny compared to total population of electronic devices connected to mains.

That is the reason industry standards such as JIS (Japan) and IEC (EU) exist. To make sure equipment is safe and resilient against such rare situations.

Now, if your case was a simple one, you could get one. But you are saying it is not yet want to still pursue this? Why? Cause everyone else who has no expertise in this area, or aims to sell you something says so? Watch this video on what happens to these MOV based devices (toward the end):


You literally are trusting something that creates a short as a means of protection. With no fusing, it will blow up like shown above.
 
Look like the ZeroSurge series mode surge protectors (and perhaps those from SurgeX too) will work without ground.
I checked the link but then when look at the products, all the power cable plugs are 3p. I can’t find any units that relate to the article talking about 2p outlets.
 
I checked the link but then when look at the products, all the power cable plugs are 3p. I can’t find any units that relate to the article talking about 2p outlets.
My understanding from reading the linked page in my post is that the surge protection will work without the ground connection, so it is "optional". There is really no choice for older houses that do not have grounded outlet. Ground fault circuit interrupters (GFCI) are strongly recommended in those circumstances.

From the page:
1788840591805.png

Instead of replacing the receptacle with one with built-in GFCI, which is not practical in your case, you can use an extension cord that includes an GFCI.
1788840890280.png
 
Last edited:
There is no dice to roll. Vast majority of audio gear and electronics in the world is running without such things. Where is all the electrical damage to them?

The tiny minority who wind up with is because the salesman makes more commission on that, than the TV or stereo you are buying from a store. Or they follow the crowd as you mention. These are tiny compared to total population of electronic devices connected to mains.

That is the reason industry standards such as JIS (Japan) and IEC (EU) exist. To make sure equipment is safe and resilient against such rare situations.

Now, if your case was a simple one, you could get one. But you are saying it is not yet want to still pursue this? Why? Cause everyone else who has no expertise in this area, or aims to sell you something says so? Watch this video on what happens to these MOV based devices (toward the end):


You literally are trusting something that creates a short as a means of protection. With no fusing, it will blow up like shown above.
I’m confused. You are anti-surge protectors but this video you used to prove your point, if you check the comments, it’s basically an advertisement to buy their brand of surge protectors.

Also, I have four power cables in total that need plugs. 2 each into 2 outlets. If I do that, by most accounts, I am setting myself up for a ground loop, no? So are you anti-power tap, too? Just curious.
 
Last edited:
My understanding from reading the linked page in my post is that the surge protection will work without the ground connection, so it is "optional". There is really no choice for older houses that do not have grounded outlet. Ground fault circuit interrupters (GFCI) are strongly recommended in those circumstances.

From the page:
View attachment 557174
Instead of replacing the receptacle with one with built-in GFCI, which is not practical in your case, you can use an extension cord that includes an GFCI.
View attachment 557176
Reading the safety info, I think it’s applying the country of origin’s tech for other countries. Japan has their own way of dealing with electricity than the US, for example. Most people here are using 2p power taps/strips with any green ground wires unconnected. Even the four different electronic stores I visited yesterday, all of their Apple Studio Displays are not connected the ground wires (for example).
 
I’m confused. You are anti-surge protectors but this video you used to prove your point, if you check the comments, it’s basically an advertisement to buy their brand of surge protectors.
There is a small class of "series" surge protectors which don't suffer from MOV issues as seen in that video. The problem with them is that they are more expensive and have losses. If you are willing to accept these things, before buying, read the rest of my post on how unlikely it is that you need anything. But that if you think you do, best to avoid MOV based ones without fusing (which is essentially all point of use ones).
 
Also, I have four power cables in total that need plugs. 2 each into 2 outlets. If I do that, by most accounts, I am setting myself up for a ground loop, no? So are you anti-power tap, too? Just curious.
No. Ground loops typically happen because you are using unbalanced connections and there is mains leakage in each device to varying amount. This will cause a hum regardless of whether you plug everything to the exact source, or not. Indeed, every unbalanced connection likely has a ground loop. It is just that most of the time it is not audible since our hearing threshold is poor in low frequencies.

The solution to this is to use balanced (XLR) audio. In every case that I have had hum, messing with power strips, how mains cords are plugged in, etc. results in zero difference. I know, because I see the spectrum every time I measure gear.

That said, I personally use a stout 20 amp rated power strip and plug everything into it. No surge protection in it.
 
No. Ground loops typically happen because you are using unbalanced connections and there is mains leakage in each device to varying amount. This will cause a hum regardless of whether you plug everything to the exact source, or not. Indeed, every unbalanced connection likely has a ground loop. It is just that most of the time it is not audible since our hearing threshold is poor in low frequencies.

The solution to this is to use balanced (XLR) audio. In every case that I have had hum, messing with power strips, how mains cords are plugged in, etc. results in zero difference. I know, because I see the spectrum every time I measure gear.

That said, I personally use a stout 20 amp rated power strip and plug everything into it. No surge protection in it.
I’ve never had ground loops before, or if I did, as you mentioned, they were not audible to my ears (and I very sensitive hearing). I would not consider myself as paranoid, but there are dozens upon dozens and then even more on top of that who have all complained about having ground loop or other annoying audible noise when using specifically the Apple Studio Display with speakers/monitors.

So I won’t know 100% until I set it up myself. But if I can anticipate it has a decent chance of happening based upon everyone else complaining about it, I want options. I have to work within the components i will have. USB-C is the best use case, but if this causes noise, than Toslink it is. I can’t invent inputs/outputs that don’t exist.

I will reiterate, at every step of starting with these 4 components (Apple Studio Display, Mac Mini, KEF LSX II LT, KEF Kube 8), and simply needing a power tap vs surge protector, one solution turns into 3 new problems.

I can’t rewire my apartment. I can’t swap outlets.

Everything I have read has mentioned that noise is possible with putting computer and audio components into the same power tap. Then it’s also possible if plugging into different wall outlets. Then it’s might happen if using USB. That covers “noise.”

Then there’s Japan’s 2p outlets without ground. It is what it is. If I say screw the surge protector, I'm going to get a power tap because I don’t want to max out every outlet in the room. And then I’m still forced to plug in power cables with green ground wire that won’t be connected.

These are the parameters I have to work within and looking for the best and easiest solution.

For example, if removing surge protection from the menu, I can get an Elecom JIS approved normal power strip to plug everything into. If I wanted to splurge, there is an Oyaide 6 port power tap where the 6 ports and the power cord are all 2p. Either way, I won’t be attaching ground wires. So I’m curious if you find either of those ok? I can send links.
 
Last edited:
A UPS is for power interruptions. Not all models are necessarily immune to being destroyed by a mains surge - kinda back to square one?
 
A UPS is for power interruptions. Not all models are necessarily immune to being destroyed by a mains surge - kinda back to square one?
This has pretty much been like trying to dig a hole to China. Not by any fault of those commenting. But as I mentioned recently above, I have to work within the parameters I'm given.

The issues are grounding and noise, and how they relate here in Japan.

Like it or not, I have wall outlets which are 2 prong and no ground (and same as the US, for example, are located about lower-shin height from the floor). In my entire apartment, there are only 5 wall outlets which are 2 prong and have a ground screw - 1 in my bedroom for the aircon unit, 1 in the living room for that aircon unit, 1 in the kitchen for the refrigerator, 1 in the bathroom for the washing machine, and 1 in the second bedroom for that aircon unit ( I use this room as a home office/music room). Those outlets are all about 6.5-7 feet off the floor. So even if one were free im my office/music room, it’s not exactly practical to plug in a power strip or surge protector at 7 feet, have it dangling against the wall or located on the total opposite side of the room and then what? Connect every component to extension cords thus creating a huge fire hazard? Call in a construction crew to rebuild the room? Ha ha. I mean, there are practical considerations to keep in mind.

So if I am stuck with 2 prong outlets without ground, which is 100% normal for Japan, and it’s going to be a Mount Everest climb to get my rental agency and building owner to ok switching one wall outlet to a type with ground - it is what it is. Although even if possible to change it, I’m not even sure how that helps anyway. I would plug a power tap or surge protector into the outlet, connect the ground wire to so that device is grounded, but everything I plug into it isn’t grounded by default. The power cable plugs with their own green ground wire also need to connect to something and it can’t be that same outlet ground screw because they would be too far away to do so.

Moving on…

With 2 prong ungrounded outlets, I still need either a power tap or surge protector or UPS, or any other device. With two exceptions - basic power strip/surge protector from here Japan OR a very well built power tap from Oyaide who makes all things power related - those are going to be 2 prong power devices, ungrounded. Anything made from outside Japan is going to be 3p, won’t work in my outlets, will require a 3p to 2p plug adapter, and the adapter ground wire will also not be attached, so not grounded (and any of those power devices when not grounded lose most of their protections because they require grounding to work properly).

The Apple Studio Monitor is 2p with ground wire. I’ve seen it displayed in many shops to test out. The ground wire is never connected in any store. The Mac Mini is 2p with no ground wire. I read that the reason is Apple anticipates the Mac Mini to be connection to the Apple Studio Monitor and thus grounded via its ground wire. So those two devices won’t be grounded. I haven’t personally seen the power cable in Japan for the KEF LSX II LT and Kube 8. I assume they will have a ground wire on the plug but perhaps they don’t. Either way, all four units will be ungrounded.

If this was that much of a concern, I would see every Apple store and electronic store in Japan having the monitor grounded, but they aren’t.

If that’s the way it is, then that’s the way it is. I can’t call and complain to anyone or change the way things are done here. The electrical system here is different, as per the video that a commenter posted over on page 2. I’ve lived here close to 20 years. I’ve never had a blackout, brown out, flickering light, nothing. Not even during the huge 3/11 mega quake and tsunami did I lose power. So it isn't a stretch to say that the electrical system in Japan is ultra stable.

As for noise - as I have mentioned, you can Google Apple Display Monitor along with speakers and noise (or ground loop) and you’ll see dozens of people on Apple forums, Reddit, and the like all complaining about having this monitor and fill-in-the-blank speakers, monitors, and powered speakers and annoying audible noise coming from it.

On one hand. I have read and been told multiple times that it’s pretty much a best practice to pick one wall outlet, plug the power device in (power tap, surge protector, UPS, etc) and then plug all components into that one unit (ensuring the 15/1500 rating isn’t surpassed). This can lower chances of noise and ground loops.

Secondly, I have read that since all these components are not grounded. It’s pretty much impossible to have a ground loop because, nothing is grounded. However, there can still be EMI noise (I don’t recall if that’s the correct name for the noise) due to nothing being grounded.

There is no guarantee this noise will occur, but it’s something to be mindful of just in case. And there is a checklist to follow that can help get rid of this. The last being switching from USB-C to Toslink (and even that has its good and bad points).

So at the end of the day, as I have mentioned before, for something as simple as “Hey, I have a computer, monitor, sub and powered speakers, but can’t find a good surge protector”, it has turned into this bottomless black hole where every suggestion causes a new problem or multiple ones. Try this, but that thats a problem. Then get this to fix that. Then maybe scrap that idea and so this, but it works where you live, but not here. It’s like that.

I am not an expert on power and electricity. Happy to admit that. I’ve had audio component systems before which included a MacBook Pro as controller and all were 3p components with 3p power cables going into 3p power tap and the final power cable had the ground pin removed and plugged into my wall. It worked flawlessly - no noises, hisses, static build up, electrocution, etc. I’ve also had an iMac, with powered speakers and a separate DAC and headphone amp all plugged into a basic power strip with 2p surge protection (and also no noises, fires, problems).

For such a simple set-up, it feels like I’m trying to research building my own components from scratch. I feel like I’m no longer asking anything but just explaining why things are the way they are here. Nobody’s fault but reality.

The only thing that’s going to change every component from being ungrounded is an electrician and new outlets, which isn't going to happen. So now I am on a level playing field with most Japanese here.

The only thing left is noise. I won’t know until I start adding pieces to the puzzle to see if there is noise and if so, what did I last connect that gave noise and how to solve it. And to be clear, by “noise”, I'm not referring to setting up testing equipment and doing a scientific analysis of noise emissions that the human ear isn't physically capable of hearing. I’m talking about noise that you hear, it’s not normal and you know something is wrong.

To repeat myself, I appreciate every single one of you who have read, commented, recommended, and shared here. I don’t consider anything I’ve read as bad advice or useless. Some of it might not apply to me due to different country/power system/plug type/etc, but still it was food for thought.

Unless I am snow-blind now (my mind is already burnt out) I’m pretty sure my options on power devices are either a basic ungrounded power strip without surge protection (all 2p), a much better built ungrounded Oyaide power tap (all 2p) without surge protection, or lastly, a basic surge protector (all 2p). Anything else will be 3p (useless without ground).

And then potential audible noise, which I don’t have yet because I have nothing here to connect. The entire reason for this topic/post was to preemptively source a surge protector before my system arrives.

Sorry for the book.
 
Last edited:
IMHO - forget about power surges and enjoy the music. For the other worry, get decent kit if you have not already, and let us know if noise or hum is a real issue or not.
 
IMHO - forget about power surges and enjoy the music. For the other worry, get decent kit if you have not already, and let us know if noise or hum is a real issue or not.
I would just ask you this - setting aside audio. Plain and simple. If you were going to Apple tomorrow and spending $5000 on a new monitor and desktop computer - would you plug it into the wall or a surge protector? I don’t think there’s a wrong answer. I think most people who aren’t audiophiles would get a surge protector. So would I based on it being a computer. And yes, I could be totally wrong for it.

As for if there’s noise or hum, I totally agree with you. Thanks!
 
I'd plug it into the wall socket - no surge concerns. I've always done this with my computer kit, since the '80s, PCs and monitors going right back to CRTs.

I do however switch off the mains socket for my LG OLED TV in electrical storms, but this is more to do with the fact LG skimps on quality and good design where you can't see it, if it saves them pennies - PSUs are often 'frail' in TVs... I bet an Apple monitor is better.

I only recall one thing I have had in the last 69 years that appeared to fail after a storm, and that was a Water Piq (a tooth cleaner thing). I was sent a new one in 4 days under warranty. No need to return the faulty one. There was no clear proof of the root cause (no pun intended), but as I usually do, I took the broken unit apart, and sure enough the PSU was dead (fixable though).
 
One warning: If you have solar panels with microinverters, a whole-house surge protector is strongly recommended, and is mandatory in some areas.
 
I'd plug it into the wall socket - no surge concerns. I've always done this with my computer kit, since the '80s, PCs and monitors going right back to CRTs.

I do however switch off the mains socket for my LG OLED TV in electrical storms, but this is more to do with the fact LG skimps on quality and good design where you can't see it, if it saves them pennies - PSUs are often 'frail' in TVs... I bet an Apple monitor is better.

I only recall one thing I have had in the last 69 years that appeared to fail after a storm, and that was a Water Piq (a tooth cleaner thing). I was sent a new one in 4 days under warranty. No need to return the faulty one. There was no clear proof of the root cause (no pun intended), but as I usually do, I took the broken unit apart, and sure enough the PSU was dead (fixable though).
Interesting. Again, different, not wrong. I suppose my rationale is that I’ve never had only a monitor and computer on my desk or only a laptop. There were always speakers that needed an outlet. HDDs for backups with needed an outlet. Etc. So I needed a power strip to accommodate so then why not just get one with a surge protector. Wasn’t going to hurt my set-up.

Of course if I randomly asked someone else, you as an example, opposite. Just plug it into the wall and done with it.

I guess my description above (long one) about how stable the Japanese electric system is would lean way more toward your methodology than mine, haha. And also as mentioned, the component system I last had was definitely way more expensive than this new set-up (which is basically my computer set up to work from home and listen to music while doing so), and I had no worries I my using an ORB power tap with zero surge protection.

I’m there with you though - I’ve never lost any product due to power issues. Ever. And I do unplug when a storm comes. Yahoo Japan Weather over here can actually map out exactly what the weather will be, so you can literally walk your way around rain, etc. I’m starting to sound like a guy who doesn’t need a surge protector, haha.
 
I checked the link but then when look at the products, all the power cable plugs are 3p. I can’t find any units that relate to the article talking about 2p outlets.
Here's an example from my own audio system, everything Marantz is powered by 2 wires.
Search the internet and see how many Marant devices have had problems in the last 10 years for example...

Marantz Power Surge.jpg
 
Back
Top Bottom