• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Star Wars The Mandalorian and Grogu

Star Wars: Yuck. For the most part I've given up on that franchise. Mind you, I did watch Andor which was remarkably mature & watchable compared to virtually everything else; (I gave it a 7/10 IMDB rating -- would have been 7.5 if that were possible).

As for Mandolorian, I watch two seasons and gave up on it on account of it's being insufferably puerile.
 
Pretty much any serious person working in the industry will recognize Andor as being miles better than pretty much all other Disney Star Wars to date.
Of course they do, they created it. ROTFL
But what normal average person puts any stock in what those tinkerbells in Hollyweird think or do :facepalm: The Mando series was popular enough to support 3 seasons (4 if you include the Boba's) and was seen as being worth investing in a big screen production. OTOH Andor fizzled after 2. :p
 
OTOH Andor fizzled after 2. :p
Well, it wasn't cheap

"Andor is officially the most expensive Star Wars project and one of the costliest television series ever produced, with a total budget exceeding $650 million (some tax filings estimate up to $705.5 million) across its two seasons

Because filming took place in the United Kingdom, Lucasfilm's financial reports were publicly disclosed, giving fans an unusual look at the massive costs of modern streaming. [1]
Why did it cost so much?
  • Elaborate Practical Sets: The production famously prioritized massive, physical sets and functional props over digital volumes (Volume stages), creating highly immersive and realistic environments. [1]
  • Delays & Strikes: The COVID-19 pandemic and the SAG-AFTRA strikes significantly extended production and inflated costs. [1, 2, 3]
  • Massive Runtime: While $650+ million sounds absurd for a TV show, it covers a huge 24-episode runtime across two seasons, which is longer than several multi-film blockbuster trilogies
Many fans and critics on Reddit discuss how the record-setting budget translates into exceptional cost-effectiveness, delivering movie-quality writing and production design for every minute of screen time"

Although I prefer GoT over Andor rather easily, despite the awful last season when it comes to the script.
 
Last edited:
Each to their own opinions. I found Andor the most boring snooze fest ever carry the Star Wars banner. For shame on Disney to ever try and milk money from franchise fans with that crap.
Yeah, funny enough I pretty much take the opposite view, to me Andor was the only Star Wars show that I would recommend people watch whether or not they like Star Wars.

The rest of Star Wars as a whole, I have to shrug and remind myself it's ultimately actually for kids, and for better or worse those kids grew up and wanted to keep watching new Star Wars stuff.
 
Yeah, funny enough I pretty much take the opposite view, to me Andor was the only Star Wars show that I would recommend people watch whether or not they like Star Wars.
Same, most others are popcorn variants, sometimes even downright stupid
 
Well, it wasn't cheap
"Andor is officially the most expensive Star Wars project and one of the costliest television series ever produced, with a total budget exceeding $650 million (some tax filings estimate up to $705.5 million) across its two seasons"
I have to wonder what they spent all that money on?
It wasn't much with offering jaw dropping detail in star ship fighters or ultra futuristic sets in general. Where were the aliens? It was mostly a let down of the Lucas, latest and greatest technology style. That's Star Wars. ;)

  • Delays & Strikes: The COVID-19 pandemic and the SAG-AFTRA strikes significantly extended production and inflated costs. [1, 2, 3]
  • Massive Runtime: While $650+ million sounds absurd for a TV show, it covers a huge 24-episode runtime across two seasons, which is longer than several multi-film blockbuster trilogies
That must have been it, the series was most devoid of Sci-Fi type eye-candy.

The rest of Star Wars as a whole, I have to shrug and remind myself it's ultimately actually for kids, and for better or worse those kids grew up and wanted to keep watching new Star Wars stuff.
Don't know if I'd call it focused on kids, yes the kids loved it, but it wasn't just the kids standing in lines to see the original 1977 and later films, I was 27 and a war decorated veteran then. The boomer Sci-Fi lovers like myself loved it also, it changed everything about the looks and technology used to create it. Eye candy and Surround Sound like we had never experienced before. Those my age still talk about the first time they saw the jaw dropping bar seen in movie 1 with aliens that looked more real than anything we had ever viewed before. Probably the most kid oriented of the series were the 4th and 5th releases with that dumb Jar Jar Binks. The character and the films were almost universally panned.
But mainly your above line says it all, your just not a Star Wars fan to begin with so how could real fans expect a relevant review of new material. Yea your right, we want to keep seeing new exciting Star Wars genre stuff. Not something like Andor which would have been most appropriately released on The Hallmark Channel. LOL
 
I have to wonder what they spent all that money on?
It wasn't much with offering jaw dropping detail in star ship fighters or ultra futuristic sets in general. Where were the aliens? It was mostly a let down of the Lucas, latest and greatest technology style. That's Star Wars. ;)
Real sets instead of fake:ish CGI for one thing... I'd rather say that Lucas went way overboard with the CGI, nothing felt real compared to the original trilogy.
But then again, we are again in repeat territory
 
Of course they do, they created it. ROTFL

"the industry" does not mean just Disney or the team that created Andor, it means pretty much everyone in the industry.

The Mando series was popular enough to support 3 seasons (4 if you include the Boba's) and was seen as being worth investing in a big screen production. OTOH Andor fizzled after 2. :p

I read the thread about Andor and it has already been explained quite clearly. They made the decision to begin the series 5 years before ANH. After having produced season 1 during Covid they realized it would be pretty much impossible to do the remainder leading up to Rogue One within a reasonable time frame. It takes a long-ass time to do good content and during that time people get older. It may be a 1-year time stretch between season 1 ep 1 and season 2 ep1 in the SW univers, but longer than that in real life. Season 1 started filming in 2020 and season 2 ended filming in 2024. Then post production on that for a 2025 premiere, a full half a decade after s1 started filming. Actors would look significantly older by season 5 if that's what they chose to do.

However, the two seasons contain pretty much what you needed them to contain. Not sure what you think was missing.

Either way, here's the wiki entry on viewership which could be interesting if you actually think it "fizzled" (outperformed Mando for reference): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andor#Viewership
 
I have to wonder what they spent all that money on?
It wasn't much with offering jaw dropping detail in star ship fighters or ultra futuristic sets in general.
What? Are we talking about the same show now?

Compared to the other volume-generated crap Andor was filled with real things (along with green screen). Take a look at this to see the scope of design and craftsmanship, from the sets to costume:

That must have been it, the series was most devoid of Sci-Fi type eye-candy.

Definitely void of fantasy-stuff. No asteroid worm or "always a bigger fish" or Sarlac pit. But no Sci-Fi eye-candy? I thought there was plenty. From Luthen's Haulship to Emo the droid to Cyril's mom's apartment. The show was never about that and didn't overdo it. But quality>quantity, and I think design and craftsmanship on this show was stellar.
 
Don't know if I'd call it focused on kids, yes the kids loved it, but it wasn't just the kids standing in lines to see the original 1977 and later films, I was 27 and a war decorated veteran then.
Fair when it comes to A New Hope but by the time Return of the Jedi came around, it's hard to say they were really fully aiming at adults, either. Agree on the Episode 1-3 being kid stuff.

But mainly your above line says it all, your just not a Star Wars fan to begin with so how could real fans expect a relevant review of new material. Yea your right, we want to keep seeing new exciting Star Wars genre stuff. Not something like Andor which would have been most appropriately released on The Hallmark Channel. LOL
I used to consider myself a pretty legit star wars fan, and I'm still not NOT a fan. I'm playing through the recent Jedi Fallen Order / Survivor games and they're not bad. I watched Mandalorian pretty eagerly when it first came out, but at some point you have to face the fact that Andor was an abberation and there's no interest on Disney's (or anyone else's part) on taking Star Wars too seriously.

Along the same lines, I didn't hate the Episode 7-9 movies that much because like... what did you expect? A kid-friendly action sci-fi series that was kinda silly from the beginning also being fully consistent, logical, and written to the highest caliber of theater?

But... the hallmark channel? Huh? I feel like you're too eager to dis the show and the people who made it / like it. Just because it's more talking than blasting doesn't make it lame. It's a political drama that happens to take place in Star Wars... where basically every other bit of Star Wars media is a sci-fi action space wizard western type of thing. So I am also not surprised it doesn't resonate with everyone who likes SW.
 
I used to consider myself a pretty legit star wars fan, and I'm still not NOT a fan.
What? Which way is it? You seem so confused. LOL

But... the hallmark channel? Huh? I feel like you're too eager to dis the show and the people who made it / like it. It's a political drama that happens to take place in Star Wars... where basically every other bit of Star Wars media is a sci-fi action space wizard western type of thing.
Now your 100% on point. If I want political drama I'll watch the fake news on CNN. LOL
 
Don't waste your time, the Bat is a pussy next to Mando Din Djarin ;)

They are the same.

Batman's superpower: he's rich and he has gadgets. No actual superpower - can't fly, can't turn invisible, can't do anything a normal person can't do.

Mando's superpower: he has Beskar and he has gadgets. Can't use the force.

Well, maybe the only difference is that sometimes, Batman has nipples. We haven't seen Mando's nipples yet, but I wouldn't put it past those clowns in Disney ...
 
Me and daughter enjoyed it. Dad daughter movie date.
 
They are the same.
Not close.
Mando says, "I can bring you in warm, or I can bring you in cold." Mostly they come in cold.
Batman I can never remember killed anyone. :p
 
Last edited:
I finally watched it yesterday.

I gotta say, it's pretty much as expected. It feels like a few episodes of a TV show stuck together to make a movie. But it still plays like a TV show which I think is a bad thing.

I think there's a place for shows that are mainly episodic with little progress over time. I think that's fine. But if it's basically just a bunch of side-quests and no real progress then it's of less value I'd argue, though that's debatable. More importantly though, it really felt weird that this movie felt like a few such episodes strung together and slightly massaged. The other SW movies I've seen have been a part of a larger whole, like the three trilogies obviously were and R1 was leading straight into ANH. The only other one, Solo, was more of an origin story meaning there's a point to it within that larger universe and the story (should) matter.

Mando & Grogu on the other hand just felt unnecessary. Like, why is this made into a movie? It seems literally all of it is not just unmemorable but ultimately inconsequential to the SW universe. It's like they sat down, decided to make a Mando movie, and then just came up with an idea and went "Yeah, that's good enough to fill 130 minutes".

I thought the performances were average at best. I also thought Weaver's mouth looked weird (!). It's as if she phoned in dialog replacement in the studio and they just digitally tweaked the mouth to make it match her re-recording, rather than have her re-record with good lip-sync. And either way the dialog in general was poorly performed. I'm allergic to poor emphasis in dialog and that's something that happens a lot with ADR. Actors come in many months after filming and they're not in the same headspace and might not even give a shit anymore. So the ADR sounds like they read off of a page with the bare minimum emotion, and then emphasis in sentences often ends up being off (along with wrong intensity and projection and emotion).

Dialog as written was also really average at best. It was a bit clunky at times, on the nose and a bit repetitive. It really all comes off as a more contemporary writing where the audience is assumed to not be paying attention and forgetting what they were told ten minutes ago, not to mention that things need to be spelled out real clearly, like I said, on the nose, because 8-year-olds have to get it too.

Visual effects were average. Music was average. Editing was average. Sound effects didn't bother me.

Actually, I think the idea of making a Hutt into a main character and then have it be fighting and be really physical ran against what I felt was believable. Obviously there's the counter that "Oh, but this is fantasy and.." but the Hutts to me seemed to be established as big, slow slugs, not jacked fighters. That plus a bunch of other stuff just made so much of the movie feel so CGI (as opposed to TFA for example).

Anyway, ultimately a borderline instantly forgettable experience.
 
Oh, and incidentally since money was mentioned about some SW piece of media somewhere; it seems like the current status is 345 mil at the box office with a 165 mil budget. Using the standard average costs that'll put it at about a 300 million USD loss heading to streaming.
 
Question;

Was anyone at all bothered by these shots:

1786907514442.png


For some reason the made those critters all look like either miniatures or like they had used tilt-shift in post. They never look like normal but short. Something really weird about that in my brain.
 
Back
Top Bottom