I finally watched it yesterday.
I gotta say, it's pretty much as expected. It feels like a few episodes of a TV show stuck together to make a movie. But it still plays like a TV show which I think is a bad thing.
I think there's a place for shows that are mainly episodic with little progress over time. I think that's fine. But if it's basically just a bunch of side-quests and no real progress then it's of less value I'd argue, though that's debatable. More importantly though, it really felt weird that this movie felt like a few such episodes strung together and slightly massaged. The other SW movies I've seen have been a part of a larger whole, like the three trilogies obviously were and R1 was leading straight into ANH. The only other one, Solo, was more of an origin story meaning there's a point to it within that larger universe and the story (should) matter.
Mando & Grogu on the other hand just felt unnecessary. Like, why is this made into a movie? It seems literally all of it is not just unmemorable but ultimately inconsequential to the SW universe. It's like they sat down, decided to make a Mando movie, and then just came up with an idea and went "Yeah, that's good enough to fill 130 minutes".
I thought the performances were average at best. I also thought Weaver's mouth looked weird (!). It's as if she phoned in dialog replacement in the studio and they just digitally tweaked the mouth to make it match her re-recording, rather than have her re-record with good lip-sync. And either way the dialog in general was poorly performed. I'm allergic to poor emphasis in dialog and that's something that happens a lot with ADR. Actors come in many months after filming and they're not in the same headspace and might not even give a shit anymore. So the ADR sounds like they read off of a page with the bare minimum emotion, and then emphasis in sentences often ends up being off (along with wrong intensity and projection and emotion).
Dialog as written was also really average at best. It was a bit clunky at times, on the nose and a bit repetitive. It really all comes off as a more contemporary writing where the audience is assumed to not be paying attention and forgetting what they were told ten minutes ago, not to mention that things need to be spelled out real clearly, like I said, on the nose, because 8-year-olds have to get it too.
Visual effects were average. Music was average. Editing was average. Sound effects didn't bother me.
Actually, I think the idea of making a Hutt into a main character and then have it be fighting and be really physical ran against what I felt was believable. Obviously there's the counter that "Oh, but this is fantasy and.." but the Hutts to me seemed to be established as big, slow slugs, not jacked fighters. That plus a bunch of other stuff just made so much of the movie feel so CGI (as opposed to TFA for example).
Anyway, ultimately a borderline instantly forgettable experience.