• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Star Wars The Mandalorian and Grogu

I think I will make up my own mind. Definitely going to see it this weekend.
 
I think I will make up my own mind. Definitely going to see it this weekend.
Yep, that was one man's opinion. When he announced he never bothered to watch Season 3 of the TV series I could have easily guessed what he'd say about the movie.
 
People repeat after me: "I care about this movie and I will not read a single review or watch any trailers before I see the movie myself."

Seriously. If you care about a movie then don't bias yourself with giveaways in trailers and getting emotionally "set up" from reviews. From the sequels to Joker to Nolan's movies or whatever I've always done this and it's always way better than getting hyped and then disappointed.

Works wonders.

"trust me bro"
 
People repeat after me: "I care about this movie and I will not read a single review or watch any trailers before I see the movie myself."
Sounds good. Since Jon Favreau directed and co-wrote the movie, same guy that did the TV series of Mando and Boba Fett, along with Dave Filoni and Noah Kloor, the viewing of which I enjoyed very much, I have high hopes for the movie, I can't see them taking the genre very far off course.
YMMV
 
Im going to swear in the church, but I think Mandalorian series is way better than the new star wars movies since 1999? It's star wars done right.
I was very apprehensive about seeing this one since I had loved all 4 of the Mando - Boba seasons on TV and I was scared Disney would freak it up for the big screen.
Well I went with 3 others tonight and we all loved it, a fun roller coaster ride the entire time.
And the same was heard from the few we chatted with on the way out.
At the theater we went, the surround mix was great, very immersive and not too loud thankfully.
My one complain was with video brightness, I don't know if the directors choice was for a very dark overall effect, or the theaters projector was growing a bit dim? But black detail was badly hurting throughout the movie. IMHO ? I had wanted to see it on the IMAX screen but for various reason missed it. :( I'll know for sure when it comes around on video, this is one I'll for sure buy in 4k BluRay.
Hope there may be more to come.
This Is The Way. ;)
 
Which series do I need to be up to date on to watch this movie?
I don't believe you have to be up to date at all.
None of the others I was with had seen any of the TV series yet still enjoyed the movie.
Maybe at least having seen Season 1 would introduce you to the hole deal of who a Mandalorian is (badass bounty hunter) and where Grogu came from, but not really a requirement.
 
The experience is precisely like a middling Mandolorian episode arc, stretched to two or three times its TV length and projected on a giant screen.

As the saying goes, if you like that sort of thing, the movie is the sort of thing you'll like.

So no, you don't need to be up to date. You just need to know some general culture slop basics about Star Wars: Grogu is a baby Yoda, Mando the mercenary is his protector, and Hutts are giant talking slugs.

The only surprising thing in it to me was how bad Sigourney Weaver's acting can be.
 
When I partially watched S1 mr Mando basically survived on pure luck :D
 
I've actually seen at least 1.5 seasons of Mando and the other one. Ahsoka as well. Just don't remember much.
The only surprising thing in it to me was how bad Sigourney Weaver's acting can be.
Judging from the few seconds she's in the trailer it looks terrible.

I have no idea why filmmakers insist on bringing back old actors and put them in roles where more energy is needed.
 
When I partially watched S1 mr Mando basically survived on pure luck :D
Nah it's not about luck, it's either about pure plot armor or just bad writing. Or maybe both at the same time.

I've actually seen at least 1.5 seasons of Mando and the other one. Ahsoka as well. Just don't remember much.

Judging from the few seconds she's in the trailer it looks terrible.

I have no idea why filmmakers insist on bringing back old actors and put them in roles where more energy is needed.
It's about money. Sigourney Weaver needs some quick and easy cash and Disney need a big name to show off to milk more money from their dying franchise ;)

But yeah you don't need to have seen anything to see this. This is just a few Mandalorian episodes packed as a movie but with nothing of consequence happens, just some random pew pew action to keep fans moderately happy.
 
I watched a video on YT that explained why Mando and Grogu bombed, and it's not about fan apathy. Fans are not apathetic about Star Wars, they are angry at Disney. This is not apathy, this is a boycott. Gaslighting us for years, blaming fans for their failures, accusing us of racism and misogyny, killing off legacy characters or humiliating them, refusing to listen, and producing more of the same slop. It's not as if I don't care, I DO care. I want them to fail, and fail so badly that the franchise dies. I don't want Disney to make another cent from Star Wars, I want them to suffer catastrophic losses. Let them learn what "the power of manyyyyyyyyy" really means.
 
There's plenty wrong with both the corporation and many, many fans...
Lots of disgusting behavior
 
It's about money. Sigourney Weaver needs some quick and easy cash and Disney need a big name to show off to milk more money from their dying franchise ;)

I don't really blame the actors for taking the jobs, especially women. It's a tough as hell business and aging sucks in general and it's worse if your work relies on how you look. I doubt she got paid a lot but apparently she wanted or needed to do it. Fair enough. I just think Disney has done pretty poor casting in Star Wars, with the exception of Andor which had a bunch of theatre actors that were absolutely brilliant.

Incidentally, one reason I hated the beginning of the second season of Boba or Mando (can't recall which) was the piss-poor ADR acting. I'd expect more of the same here. Maybe I'll still see it though.
 
I watched a video on YT that explained why Mando and Grogu bombed, and it's not about fan apathy. Fans are not apathetic about Star Wars, they are angry at Disney.

There's a ton of rage-bait videos on YT though.

A "long" time ago I stumbled upon Redlettermedia's "Plinkett" review of The Phantom Menace, and it shocked me how much I agreed with the criticism and how much more enjoyable it was to watch that review rather than the actual movie. I thought it was a hilarious review at the time. And then I watched their other reviews.

Fast forward to the release of The Last Jedi and I stumbled upon Mauler's 15-minute "unbridled rage" of it. Again, really funny, and spot-on.

But then something interesting happened. In one of Mauler's videos he said "I got a lot of great feedback on my review of TLJ so I think I'm going to make more 'rage-videos'". And that really struck me. It struck me because he's basically saying that people like the rage part so he'll make more of that.

You can take any movie that isn't really really good and pick it apart and 'rage' over how horrible it is, even if it isn't horrible. And you'll get views no matter what. "Rage sells clicks and views". I don't even think it's that hard to do.

All of the above is just to say that I think a lot of YT 'criticism' is just 'rage-videos' to get views rather than coherent, logical and factually well-founded criticism, and I think that applies to Disney. Mind you, I dislike most of Disney's SW content, and I absolutely loathe the sequels. Most of it is just bland though. Andor to me is the exception, because it is really well done.

This is not apathy, this is a boycott. Gaslighting us for years, blaming fans for their failures, accusing us of racism and misogyny, killing off legacy characters or humiliating them, refusing to listen, and producing more of the same slop. It's not as if I don't care, I DO care. I want them to fail, and fail so badly that the franchise dies. I don't want Disney to make another cent from Star Wars, I want them to suffer catastrophic losses. Let them learn what "the power of manyyyyyyyyy" really means.

Unfortunately the industry as a whole is facing great changes ahead, and Disney failing would be terrible for everyone working in it. I get why people hate on Disney for how they handled SW (I do), but wanting everyone to fail rather than change and succeed is probably not the best "want" out there.
 
Sure there are lots of pure content on Youtube where some seem to only do whatever they've always done just because that's what's expected of the. The Critical Drinker for example that (rightfully) piss on Disney Star Wars also did so on Andor, it felt like he almost unconsciously thought it was bad because that's what his job more or less tells him to do. He did eventually wake up seeing Andors worth, but after that one video he never mentioned it again because it didn't fit the narrative of how bad Disney Star Wars generally is. I do often agree with him though, but to me this was quite an interesting observation how someone blindly keeps in a track because that's how he earns his money.

But there are lots of great analysis out there, this one for example puts into words what I've felt about the Mandalorian from the start, that it really is more or less all random side quests and that nothing really happens. Sure there are lots of pew pew action that can be entertaining I guess, but how much has Din Djarin and that small merchandise toy really developed as characters throughout the series? Yeah not much all really.
 
there are lots of great analysis out there, this one for example puts into words what I've felt about the Mandalorian from the start, that it really is more or less all random side quests and that nothing really happens.

That's probably fair criticism.

I think a core problem with SW is that originally we got a concise story about this kid that went on an outer and inner journey and in the process helped redeem his father. They both were "saved" so to speak. All wrapped in fantasy/sci-fi. The prequels made sense to give some backstory to Anakin and Lucas again gave it some depth and weight (with poor execution). But then where do you go from there? He told the Anakin and Luke story so what else should we expect.

I read the first Thrawn trilogy when it came out and I thought it was great. I think at one point though it's easy (for Lucasfilm) to just continue for the sake of continuing. Perhaps our expectations were too high (or "different") for the "side" characters stories is what I think I'm getting at. I suspect that's the case.

Anyway, I don't really disagree with you or all the YouTuber critics out there, just wanted to throw out there that a lot of negativity surrounding Disney is there for reasons that don't really have anything to do with Disney not producing good enough content.
 
Judging from the few seconds she's in the trailer it looks terrible.
That's just about the same amount of time she's in the movie. Don't know why her part is even a point of discussion.
That said I didn't find her acting that bad, mostly just superfluous to the needs of the movie.

Sure there are lots of pure content on Youtube where some seem to only do whatever they've always done just because that's what's expected of the. The Critical Drinker for example that (rightfully) piss on Disney Star Wars also did so on Andor, it felt like he almost unconsciously thought it was bad because that's what his job more or less tells him to do.
Each to their own opinions. I found Andor the most boring snooze fest ever carry the Star Wars banner. For shame on Disney to ever try and milk money from franchise fans with that crap.
 
For shame on Disney to ever try and milk money from franchise fans with that crap.
Pretty much any serious person working in the industry will recognize Andor as being miles better than pretty much all other Disney Star Wars to date. On pretty much every level. It's not even close. You don't have to like it, but it's just much better.
 
Back
Top Bottom