• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Sony BDP-S1700/K Review (Blu-Ray/DVD/CD Transport)

Rate this BR/DVD/CD Transport

  • Terrible (*)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Mediocre (**)

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Good (***)

    Votes: 17 16.2%
  • Excellent (****)

    Votes: 86 81.9%

  • Total voters
    105
Upon reflection: I'd be tempted to go for maximum irony if I switch to one of these as a transport. I'd invest into a converter (there must be one, right‽) and use something like this as a display.

View attachment 535893
EDIT: I actually have a GE Portacolor in the basement. It is semi-functional but would need a full going-through to actually reproduce video. ;)


or maybe even go de luxe...

View attachment 535894
I use a portable monitor as a display for my Sony BDP-S6700, but I like this option better!
 
Would a Sony BDP-S350 perform the same? It is bigger, has a screen, Toslink, coax, and includes internal DAC to RCA.
Most likely NEC EMMA3P MC-10068F1 SoC is used in this model.
It's hard to say how good it is, but judging by reviews of devices from different eras, problems with digital output are rare.
I measured the S300 model based on the Sigma SoC, and the results were very good. I doubt Sony made any changes to it.
 
Any Sony player with similar expected sound quality and CD ripping ? Regards.
 
Any Sony player with similar expected sound quality and CD ripping ? Regards.
There is no difference between the players regarding their digital outputs—or at least only a minimal one, well beyond the audible range.
You can find information via Google about which of these players allow ripping via a hack; there is also an overview listing all the players.
 
Most likely NEC EMMA3P MC-10068F1 SoC is used in this model.
It's hard to say how good it is, but judging by reviews of devices from different eras, problems with digital output are rare.
I measured the S300 model based on the Sigma SoC, and the results were very good. I doubt Sony made any changes to it.
Just did comparison of built in RCA then with a DAC via Toslink. The built in sounded weak. Not that i would use it ever. Glad I kept this one.
 
So neat.

My wife bought one of these over a decade ago. We use it for Blu-ray’s and DVD’s.

A few weeks ago she asked if we had anything to play her CD’s if she grabbed them out of storage. I didn’t think of the Blu-ray player at all. Just told her to go grab them.
 
Liked it so much I bought a second one to use instead of the Panasonic player on my main system. A great deal for the price.
 
I just inherited a CD collection from my Uncle!
Does it play CD's silently? or can you hear them spin?
Don't want to over-spend if I don't need to. Considering buying it today.
 
I just inherited a CD collection from my Uncle!
Does it play CD's silently? or can you hear them spin?
Don't want to over-spend if I don't need to. Considering buying it today.
Lucky you. I play CDs on both of mine and I don’t notice any noise from the player. Of course I play my music loud. Enjoy your new music!
 
I have one and I love that little device. I payed 85€.

I play CD's with it. Someone said it's slow and there is noise while playing. For me it's ok.

I very happy with it.
 
The BDP-S5500 is very similar to the BDP-S1700/K reviewed here. I performed a basic test on the BDP-S5500 using DeltaWave and can confirm it too plays CD audio bit perfectly. It also plays CDs without gaps.

Details in this post.
 
Warranty return if it's new.
If it's used, you'll have to negotiate with the vendor.
 
Back
Top Bottom