• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

SMSL SU-1 Stereo DAC Review

Rate this DAC:

  • 1. Poor (headless panther)

    Votes: 16 2.7%
  • 2. Not terrible (postman panther)

    Votes: 15 2.6%
  • 3. Fine (happy panther)

    Votes: 69 11.8%
  • 4. Great (golfing panther)

    Votes: 487 83.0%

  • Total voters
    587
I should also mention that I tested the DAC using both the optical and USB inputs, and the sound quality was exactly the same in both cases. I couldn't hear any difference at all.
 
What convinced me to buy this DAC was all the positive reviews and the praise I had heard about it. I don't have much personal experience with DACs. A lot of people said that the input and output circuitry of each DAC is different and that it has a significant impact on the final sound quality. However, I honestly couldn't hear any difference between my motherboard's onboard audio and the SMSL SU-1.
"the input and output circuitry of each DAC is different and that it has a significant impact". In theory maybe yes, however, it must be really bad in the first place. Most brands have a good design. The funpart is that some exclusive and expensive DAC's sometimes measure inferior, lol.
 
What convinced me to buy this DAC was all the positive reviews and the praise I had heard about it. I don't have much personal experience with DACs. A lot of people said that the input and output circuitry of each DAC is different and that it has a significant impact on the final sound quality. However, I honestly couldn't hear any difference between my motherboard's onboard audio and the SMSL SU-1.
Be grateful you didn’t spend an arm and a leg to learn this lesson. Many have spent wasted significant sums on ‘boutique’ DACs.

You may find a different use for the SMSL… A DAC I didn’t need to buy now sits between my TV and some speakers…
 
I don't want to sound rude or offend anyone, but I'm genuinely curious. Are the people who say that this DAC—or other DACs—made a huge improvement in sound quality, soundstage, imaging, and other aspects simply convincing themselves that they hear a difference? Or do they actually hear those improvements and I just don't? Or is it mostly a matter of marketing and hype?
 
The simple reply is that all competent DACS sound the same - they have a simple task - convert a digital signal into an analog audio signal. It’s testable and this site had dozens of reviews showing that any difference between good DACS is inaudible.

There’s a lot of posts here explaining why listeners think they can hear a difference - often it’s that they compare different DACs at different volumes - and so hear a difference that they wrongly attribute to the DAC.

The other main reason is they know which DAC they are listening to and expect to hear differences - and their brain obliges!

In proper tests - volume level matched using a voltage meter, and double blind so neither the listener nor the one facilitating the test knows which DAC is playing - listeners can no longer detect the difference between DACs, unless one is faulty or really badly made.
 
I don't want to sound rude or offend anyone, but I'm genuinely curious. Are the people who say that this DAC—or other DACs—made a huge improvement in sound quality, soundstage, imaging, and other aspects simply convincing themselves that they hear a difference? Or do they actually hear those improvements and I just don't? Or is it mostly a matter of marketing and hype?
A DAC has only one job : to translate the digital signal into an analog signal. That's it, nothing more. To that end, it is absolutely critical that it is totally TRANSPARENT in the signal translation. Nothing is added, nothing is deleted. Contrary to what many of those fools say on YT (sorry jonny darko), you should never hear a DAC doing it's job well, simply because its sole job is NOT to be heard.
 
I don't want to sound rude or offend anyone, but I'm genuinely curious. Are the people who say that this DAC—or other DACs—made a huge improvement in sound quality, soundstage, imaging, and other aspects simply convincing themselves that they hear a difference? Or do they actually hear those improvements and I just don't? Or is it mostly a matter of marketing and hype?
Dacs and the supporting analog circuitry have been better than human hearing specs for a couple of decades. If the circuitry has been competently designed, you will hear no audible differences in a properly controlled test. The people who say otherwise are either fooling themselves or are saying it for monetary gain.
 
Last edited:
I don't want to sound rude or offend anyone, but I'm genuinely curious. Are the people who say that this DAC—or other DACs—made a huge improvement in sound quality, soundstage, imaging, and other aspects simply convincing themselves that they hear a difference? Or do they actually hear those improvements and I just don't? Or is it mostly a matter of marketing and hype?
There was a time a few decades ago where changing a DAC could make a potentially audible difference, but it should not this century. However, there are still potential circumstances where a computer motherboard has a bad implementation (usually to do with noise), in which case an external DAC, especially optically connected) may measure better and perhaps sound better.
 
I have an EVGA Nu Audio Pro card with lower SINAD and like you, I cannot tell any difference in sound quality (lossless to McIntosh MA352 to B&W 702 Signatures). I'll probably end up selling the SU-1.
 
I noticed that this DAC sounds better with driver version 5.68. Drivers 5.70 and newer sound somewhat harsh and sharp at high frequencies. I saw complaints about this in this thread. Maybe it's worth trying the older 5.68 driver. Downloaded old driver using web archive: link
 
I noticed that this DAC sounds better with driver version 5.68. Drivers 5.70 and newer sound somewhat harsh and sharp at high frequencies. I saw complaints about this in this thread. Maybe it's worth trying the older 5.68 driver. Downloaded old driver using web archive: link
The problem isn't that this DAC sounds bad. It's just that I can't hear any difference between it and my PC's onboard audio.
 
I noticed that this DAC sounds better with driver version 5.68. Drivers 5.70 and newer sound somewhat harsh and sharp at high frequencies. I saw complaints about this in this thread. Maybe it's worth trying the older 5.68 driver. Downloaded old driver using web archive: link
The XMOS driver does not influence the sound quality. All it does is provide the right software interface and configuration options like buffer size. It has no - as in zero - influence on the contents of the audio data packets being send.
 
The XMOS driver does not influence the sound quality. All it does is provide the right software interface and configuration options like buffer size. It has no - as in zero - influence on the contents of the audio data packets being send.
Yes, it shouldn't influence. But I noticed this when switching between versions. Maybe there's a difference in how the AK4493 is configured by XMOS, I don't know. I'm just sharing my experience, maybe it'll help someone.
 
Yes, it shouldn't influence. But I noticed this when switching between versions. Maybe there's a difference in how the AK4493 is configured by XMOS, I don't know. I'm just sharing my experience, maybe it'll help someone.
But how did you test? Clearly, it will take a minute or two to install new drivers, right? But echoic memory is only a couple of seconds. Also, unless you own multiple SU-1 or have a friend switch drivers without you knowing which one is running, the test can't be blind. But sighted tests are always biased.

As long as you didn't do well controlled blind tests and considering that the driver does not incluce DSP or EQ functions and therefore cannot change the sound the way you describe, the only logical answer is that your impression is incorrect and there is no audible difference.

There's probably a dozen posts a day like this. I get that you really believe that you heard that. But unless you test in a controlled way, listening impressions are just extremely unreliable.
 
But how did you test? Clearly, it will take a minute or two to install new drivers, right? But echoic memory is only a couple of seconds. Also, unless you own multiple SU-1 or have a friend switch drivers without you knowing which one is running, the test can't be blind. But sighted tests are always biased.

As long as you didn't do well controlled blind tests and considering that the driver does not incluce DSP or EQ functions and therefore cannot change the sound the way you describe, the only logical answer is that your impression is incorrect and there is no audible difference.

There's probably a dozen posts a day like this. I get that you really believe that you heard that. But unless you test in a controlled way, listening impressions are just extremely unreliable.
Yep, just reinstalling driver. Initially i installed latest 6.0 driver after purchasing su-1. But always found it sound slightly harsh on treble. That's strange cause all reviewers describe sound as smooth, slightly soften, "velvet" sound, etc.
Out of curiosity installed driver 5.12 and noticed this changes. Then i wanted to determine last "good" driver. Installed 5.70 and it sounds the same as 6.0. Then 5.68 and it sounds as good as 5.12.
Found thread on reddit describing similar issue. So it's not just me. Same driver versions, althrough different device (SMSL SU-8) with different XMOS and DAC chips. I think it's likely due to how driver 5.70+ interacts with the Windows audio subsystem, rather than the DAC itself.
 
Yep, just reinstalling driver. Initially i installed latest 6.0 driver after purchasing su-1. But always found it sound slightly harsh on treble. That's strange cause all reviewers describe sound as smooth, slightly soften, "velvet" sound, etc.
It's a DAC: If it "sounds" like something, it's broken. The reviews are all subjective and they all make the same trivial mistakes when testing and end up reporting biased results.

Out of curiosity installed driver 5.12 and noticed this changes. Then i wanted to determine last "good" driver. Installed 5.70 and it sounds the same as 6.0. Then 5.68 and it sounds as good as 5.12.
Again: I do believe you that that is your honest impression. But as stated above, results from testing like that do not give you reliable results.

Found thread on reddit describing similar issue. So it's not just me. Same driver versions, althrough different device (SMSL SU-8) with different XMOS and DAC chips. I think it's likely due to how driver 5.70+ interacts with the Windows audio subsystem, rather than the DAC itself.
That's a prime example of why sighted testing is useless. On Reddit, the user reports
Better bass, more details, better soundstage.
which is totally different to your impression. It's almost the opposite. Do you see the problem? Invalid testing, invalid and essentially random results.
 
Back
Top Bottom