Your point about Topping is entirely valid. However, it remains surprising and somewhat frustrating, that aside from the DX9, whose price places it out of reach for many, the brand has yet to offer a well-engineered, integrated solution in the midrange segment that could directly compete with the DO400. This absence leaves a strategic gap, pending perhaps a more precisely targeted DX5 II.
Which is also very clever, because compared to a DO400, the effort in the DX9 is immense.
The DX9 is a very independent design and development.
- Completely separate and complex power supplies for the digital and analog sections, meaning three different and separate voltages.
- 4-channel AKM DAC chip.
- AK4118 transceiver chip.
- Analog and relay-based volume control.
- Completely separate headphone amplifier for SE and Balanced modes with 6 instead of 4 power amplifiers, with completely separate circuits for SE and Balanced modes. While this circumvents certain limitations in these areas, it requires significantly more space and more components.
- Large housing, which allows for a relatively separate design of the different sections.
Considering the significantly higher costs for the DX9—for example, components, a large circuit board, expensive assembly, packaging and shipping, development costs, etc.—which are spread over a much smaller number of units than with a DO400, I can't call the DX9 expensive.
Topping has at least 20 very good combinations of DACs and HPAs in its range, all of which feature a highly transparent HPA and are all priced in the DO400 range or below.
For me, the limitation of two separate devices only exists in the minds of users, as there is definitely no sonic limitation, and the spatial volume is in most cases no larger than that of the DO400.
But the advantages are clear.
- Two separate power supplies for the DAC and HPA.
- Two separate enclosures for the DAC and HPA.
- Easy replacement of a single device.
- Affordable price.
- Better measurement values.
The combination of, for example, the SU-1/C100/E30 II/Lite and the L30 II or the D50 III and the L70 is currently hard to beat by any other combination device, especially not for less than €1,000.
But Topping is supposed to release the DX5 II in the next few weeks. The board looks like it has a lot of effort in terms of both the power supply and the circuitry for signal conditioning and HPA. Added to that is an HPA power output that could exceed the performance of the DO400 at both 32 and 300 ohms. EQ on all inputs is also a big plus. The measurements published so far also point to an excellent device. If these measurements are confirmed in a test, it could become one of the best-selling devices on the market.