• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Sigberg Audio Manta (12" wideband cardioid active speakers) development thread

Exactly... in my room, ARC would flatten this curve to 100Hz, then follow the natural slope below that.

Flattening this curve to 100hz would sound worse.

Since I sit on axis (for the most part), why would I want a sloped curve down to 20kHz?

Because you want what the speaker naturally does in-room, otherwise you'll get weird results, as mentioned by Snickers further up.
 
Are you saying that following this curve's natural response profile yields worse results? I said flatten earlier because it looked flat to me, but maybe my eyes are deceiving me.
 
Are you saying that following this curve's natural response profile yields worse results? I said flatten earlier because it looked flat to me, but maybe my eyes are deceiving me.

Okay, maybe I misunderstood you. You said "ARC would flatten this curve", I assumed you were talking about the curve I posted in the post that you quoted, but perhaps not? :) And did you mean below 100hz? Either way, the point is that Dirac shouldn't change the slope (however it looks), just remove peaks, and potentially lift the bass(subs) if needed/wanted.
 
Are you saying that following this curve's natural response profile yields worse results? I said flatten earlier because it looked flat to me, but maybe my eyes are deceiving me.

There are lots of facets to response curves. The one Sigberg posted above is probably not a measurement with unlimited duration. I guess there's some frequency dependant gating going on, meaning he has cut the duration for each frequency band to something he found useful. That means there may be more energy in the room that is not included in the measurements. If this was included, it would most likely skew the result towards more lift in the low mid an bass.

I am not sure what info is available on how ARC does their measurements. There are countless ways of doing this, so unless we have that information we can not determine what they are actually doing.

A correction system has to make some choices. What should be corrected and what should be left untouched? How much do we correct for in each case? The curve may just as well simply show what ARC has chosen to correct for.

The topic of room correction is a big one and it is not what this thread is about. However, there are some possibilities built in to the Sigberg speakers, so a part of it will be on topic.

Firstly, any in room measurement will have some kind of mixed phase response. Once we start correcting for that, we introduce new errors in the time domain. That is regardless of whether FIR or IIR is used, but the errors can be a bit different. The trick is to just correct enough to dampen the bad stuff a bit. We can look at it in four segments:

1: Direct sound is mostly just the anechoic response of the speaker. Most of what we see here is minimum phase that can be safely corrected for. This is what we measure when the time window is kept so short we are not affected by reflections at all.

2: Reflections comes in when we extended the time window a bit. This is not something we should try to equalize as it is almost exclusively excess phase (so really bad time domain errors will be introduced) and it is not globally valid. That last bit means of we move the head a bit the correction no longer fits the sound it is trying to correct.

3: If we extended the time window further, we include decay and room modes. We should be careful when trying to correct for this. A significant peak that can be found in different locations can be turned down a bit, but not 100%. That would completely kill transients.

4: Below a certain threshold, commonly referred to as the Schröder frequency, you can more safely correct for modes. This is typically below 200-400Hz, depending on the room size. Corrections in this range does not degrade transients as much, and the time domain errors will be much smaller since the speakers and room behave more like a unit here, and we do not identify the speakers response separately from the room's response (like we do at higher frequencies).
 
I asked, just for kicks:)!

1788914860889.png


Imagine what the bass will be with the new Sentinel subs!
 
Last edited:
Okay, maybe I misunderstood you. You said "ARC would flatten this curve", I assumed you were talking about the curve I posted in the post that you quoted, but perhaps not? :) And did you mean below 100hz? Either way, the point is that Dirac shouldn't change the slope (however it looks), just remove peaks, and potentially lift the bass(subs) if needed/wanted.

The 'flattened' part started at 100Hz and up. Since my eyes may be playing tricks on me, I meant that ARC follows the speaker's natural frequency response. Your posted curve is similar to the ones I have in my room, except I don't have a frequency response as high as the SBS.

ARC follows its target curve, which should closely match your speaker's response.
 
Maybe you are looking at the corrections? And the corrections are limited to below 100Hz? So the flat curve above 100Hz means the system does not touch anything...
 
Maybe you are looking at the corrections? And the corrections are limited to below 100Hz? So the flat curve above 100Hz means the system does not touch anything...
Yes, the corrections. ARC uses a target curve based on your speaker's full frequency response. It then tries to match your speaker to the target curve as much as possible.
 
The 'flattened' part started at 100Hz and up. Since my eyes may be playing tricks on me, I meant that ARC follows the speaker's natural frequency response. Your posted curve is similar to the ones I have in my room, except I don't have a frequency response as high as the SBS.

ARC follows its target curve, which should closely match your speaker's response.

Still not sure I'm following you, but for the speaker response I posted (posted again below to avoid misunderstandings), I would suggest that Dirac should do absolutely nothing from 100hz and up. Is that the same you are saying? Maaaybe dampen the 200hz peak a bit if it's present in several positions.



(for readers not following every post, this is the SBS (not the Manta) and without subs, which is why the bass is missing)
1788933034378.png
 
Yes, the corrections. ARC uses a target curve based on your speaker's full frequency response. It then tries to match your speaker to the target curve as much as possible.

Ok, that means if the curve was not flat, it would apply some alterations to the slight natural fall towards high frequencies that is probably already built into the speakers.
 
Last edited:
And suddenly there were four. It seems the subwofers are multiplying on their own up North. :D

4x10D-2.jpg

4x10D-1.jpg

4X10D3.jpg
 
Did you remember to remind him that he has room for two more on top of each speaker?

No, but I will do so ASAP! I'm sure his wife has either given up or left at this point anyway, so nothing to lose by adding four more! :D
 
Lmao!

@SigbergAudio Have you thought about doing a cool MCM integration with a lovely crafted chair and nearfield sub this guy can sit on?! ;)

Perhaps I could design a small house, that IS a sub, so that people can live in their subwoofers? :p
 
Wouldn't it be better than place the subwoofers at different positions to mitigate dips?
 
Wouldn't it be better than place the subwoofers at different positions to mitigate dips?

It will often yield a more even response yes. But sometimes there are other concerns as well, like what is practical in a non-dedicated listening space.
 
Back
Top Bottom