• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required as is 20 years of participation in forums (not all true). Come here to have fun, be ready to be teased and not take online life too seriously. We now measure and review equipment for free! Click here for details.

Shanling UA2 Aborted Review (DAC & Amp)

Frankie-Shanling

New Member
Manufacturer
Joined
Aug 12, 2020
Messages
4
Likes
31
If you had sent me the product, that is exactly what would happen. I would have shown you the measurements and asked you for feedback prior to publication. This is a courtesy I provide to manufacturers who volunteer to have their products tested. To the extent you did not do that and left it to me and membership to fund acquisition of the product, then I publish what I find as a service to that member and the membership at large.

Had you sent me a product and then told me an app had caused the levels to go down, I would have scolded you for a) not being clear in documentation this could happen and b) not providing for a hardware reset. Plenty of products have persistent settings like active professional speakers and AV Receivers. In all cases, they allow you to do a factory reset which I always do prior to testing.

For your product, I thought there would be such a thing but all I found was the USB button. I played with that but it didn't obviously solve this problem. You need to update the firmware to allow that button to be used as a reset, e.g. by holding it down 10 seconds or something like that.

Ideally there would also be an indication on the device that the volume is not at default level, say with an LED, but I understand that increases power consumption.

Your are a small company and could disappear tomorrow. This hardware can't become obsolete if your app disappears with it with the next update of Android OS. There must be a hardware reset.

Remember, almost no other dongle works this way. So there can't be an expectation that the user figures all this out especially given lack of documentation. I appreciate the benefit it provides but you need to be very strong in documenting and providing work-arounds. Throwing this at my feet as if you have done the perfect thing is not proper. I tested your dongle just like all other dongles. It is not my job to think of possibilities that simply don't exist with countless competing products.

I actually went searching for this online. Read a bunch of posts, etc. but nothing came up. With this thread available, people running into this at least can find out what is going on. It also helped me figure out what was going on when member kindly post the possibility of the Android app changing this. Had I not post this, that information would not have come to light -- again because of incomplete documentation and indication on the device.

Note that the article clearly says it is "aborted" and finishes with it is an "FYI." And that is what it was. My attempt to test your device and not being able to get it to work like dozens of other dongles have.

I suggest going back and improving the documentation. While you are at it, please put a copy on your website.

I would just hope that one message to company representative (And you know we are taking part on this forum) would save everybody else time over threads like this. We get technical questions daily from reviewers around the World, even if they are not cooperating directly with us.

It would be sad if we just disappeared tomorrow after 33 years in business.

Product page of UA2 talks about companion app, mentions adjusting volume, gain and filters. We don't do dedicated notes for second hand market buyers of our devices, but might put there some note for UA2.

Seems they (90s products) were and are still largely in obscurity. They weren't released on the international market.

Anyway, fame was only achieved it seems after they began their portable player series.

Shanling had quite a nice presence on international market in 2000s, you can still find a lot of users running our Tube CD players and amps from that period. These devices are now limited to Chinese market mostly, but we are slowly going back to the world of home Hi-Fi with the M30.

@amirm Hi! I can help you fix this, Usb Audio Player app helped me solve what you found here, connect UA2 to the phone, then open UAP, click volume button, small window will pop up, there is ,,hardware volume" button, click it, then you will see 3 sliders, put them all up and then on high gain there will be 1.9V output on SE and 3.85V output on Balanced. Before that i also measured 0.1V max output Voltage. I would like so much to see your measurements of it

As far as I know, this is issue specific to UAPP, to the way it takes control over the hardware volume control on UA2. If you are using other software, you shouldn't face this.
 
OP
amirm

amirm

Founder/Admin
Staff Member
CFO (Chief Fun Officer)
Joined
Feb 13, 2016
Messages
34,942
Likes
129,731
Location
Seattle Area
(And you know we are taking part on this forum)
I don't. I am sure I saw your alias at some point to give you the manufacturer title but it is not something I memorize. We have about 100 members of the industry here. I only remember a few of them.
 

jasonhanjk

Active Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2019
Messages
123
Likes
102
I would just hope that one message to company representative (And you know we are taking part on this forum) would save everybody else time over threads like this. We get technical questions daily from reviewers around the World, even if they are not cooperating directly with us.

It would be sad if we just disappeared tomorrow after 33 years in business.

Product page of UA2 talks about companion app, mentions adjusting volume, gain and filters. We don't do dedicated notes for second hand market buyers of our devices, but might put there some note for UA2.

看来您不明白他的意思。
难道贵公司会一直更新 app 直到 33 年后吗?
就如当时 Win 98 的产品贵公司还在支持?

就从现在起,安卓一直会更新。
贵公司的 app 也必须更新,只要不更新就无法使用。
你明白吗?

现在把产品做好就无需担心到 app 得一直更新的问题。
而且不是每个用户会特地去下载 app.
 

Asylum Seeker

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2020
Messages
414
Likes
285
Location
Guatemala
It's not broken. The forum member who sent the UA2 to Amir used the accompanying App to limit the DAC's output.
This limit is stored on the unit itself and stays active no matter what USB host you use, so that's what Amir was left with.
The Dr. has a thing for broken gear.
 

Saidera

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2020
Messages
307
Likes
199
Location
Adelaide, South Australia, Australia
Next minute we'll be conversing in native Chinese in this forum.
 

aranido

New Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2020
Messages
3
Likes
3
I ordered mine a few days ago. I hope you have a chance to review it later on. I was curious on how it would compare against the THX Onyx.
 
Top Bottom