• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Separate tweeter cabinet

Thieluar

Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2026
Messages
30
Likes
11
Several questions on more or less the same subject.

I have the yamaha two-way budget bookshelf NX-100, paired with the Ampapa D1 and a cheap small sub . The setup works quite well, I think thanks to high pass filter in the D1. The bass register in the NX is tight/controlled/rich and more then ok, the midrange and treble is a bit lacking, for my ears atleast. I`ve tried to compensate the weakness in midrange/treble with PEQ but the speakers just not have it in them. .I tried adding separate bullet horn tweeters (I know they are Big Satan here :) ) to boost the treble and it does what it was supposed to do (even though they create some expected emphasised SSS-sound here and there in the ultra the top register but it´s partly tamed a with a provisory baffle.

Isn´t it optimal, for bookshelf speakers, with woofer + midrange and a treble tweeter added in a separate micro cabinet that can be easly placed/directed? Like this AI pic:
1790420563388.png


Would it be worth, as a budget tweak, to replace the crossover with a 3-way and the 95mm tweeter in the NX with a midrange and then add a proper treble tweeter in a separate cabinet as in the picture. Is it a big chance I would end up with frustration and a lot of surplus elements lying around and maybe an experince richer (as in the normal outcome for such projects:))?
 
Last edited:
Why not experiment?
There's lots of ASR talk about timing, distances, phase, and all sorts of measurements but really, if you come up with something that sounds nice to you, it's all good.
Or zero the HPF and set XO on the sub only - after all, those bookshelf speakers alone don't go very low. A small sub may be bleeding in the midrange of the main speakers. Experiment.
Or just try other speakers in your room.
 
Last edited:
Why not experiment?
There's lots of ASR talk about timing, distances, phase, and all sorts of measurements but really, if you come up with something that sounds nice to you, it's all good.
Or just try other speakers in your room.

The issue is you are very unlikely to come up with something that sounds good to anyone without considering all those metrics.

Better speakers would be a wiser use of ones money, or ditch the extra tweeter and just use EQ to fix the top end.
 
I would just buy a speaker that you actually like. Any of these mods need proper measurement equipment and some knowledge to lead to a proper result.

Maybe just experiment with some EQ? It’s free and needs zero hardware changes.
 
I should have added that I`ve tried to compensate the weakness in midrange/treble with PEQ but the speakers just not have it in them. (the bullet horns are just temporary experiment, that works but they are not quality elements, and do not lift midrange).
 
Last edited:
The issue is you are very unlikely to come up with something that sounds good to anyone without considering all those metrics.

Better speakers would be a wiser use of ones money, or ditch the extra tweeter and just use EQ to fix the top end.
I know this! Sometimes it's good to be encouraging people to do their own experiments - these are the people that end up learning the most.
 
Why not experiment?
There's lots of ASR talk about timing, distances, phase, and all sorts of measurements but really, if you come up with something that sounds nice to you, it's all good.
Or zero the HPF and set XO on the sub only - after all, those bookshelf speakers alone don't go very low. A small sub may be bleeding in the midrange of the main speakers. Experiment.
Or just try other speakers in your room.
Good points. I´ve already tried the above and ended up lifting off some lows from the speakers with the HPF, and tweeked the sub. It made a clear improvement. Seems to sound best with freq and volume somewhere in the middle on the sub when listening to music a little bit over "tv-volume".
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom