• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Revel M106 Bookshelf Speaker Review

Can I ask, what woofers you used, and is that box about 2 cubic foot?
I love that idea. Basically makes it a 3 way.....

I currently have 2 Velodyne 12" subs with my Wharfedale 12.1s and while good to a degree, are very similar to the M106 as far as most aspects, and would benefit in the same way as your setup.
I'm using the Eminence KappaLite 3012LF in about 1ft^3 sealed, just a little bigger than the recommended "Small Sealed Design" from their Cab Design .pdf linked here:


The midbass units are themselves high-passed at 80HZ, 12dB/oct. and a mono sealed subwoofer takes over below. So ultimately a 4-way.

I really like the sound and feel of a lightweight, high-sensitivity midbass driver as opposed to just high-passing the bass drivers in a floorstander, for example. I actually experimented for a bit with an older pair of Klipsch Heresy III used as dedicated midbass speakers as proof-of-concept under my M106 before building the ones shown. Looked silly but proved the concept to me. :)
 
I'm using the Eminence KappaLite 3012LF in about 1ft^3 sealed, just a little bigger than the recommended "Small Sealed Design" from their Cab Design .pdf linked here:


The midbass units are themselves high-passed at 80HZ, 12dB/oct. and a mono sealed subwoofer takes over below. So ultimately a 4-way.

I really like the sound and feel of a lightweight, high-sensitivity midbass driver as opposed to just high-passing the bass drivers in a floorstander, for example. I actually experimented for a bit with an older pair of Klipsch Heresy III used as dedicated midbass speakers as proof-of-concept under my M106 before building the ones shown. Looked silly but proved the concept to me. :)
Awesome! and thanks for the info. What do you use for the low pass on the Midbass units?

And is the higher sensitivity and issue with blending with the Revel?
 
Awesome! and thanks for the info. What do you use for the low pass on the Midbass units?

And is the higher sensitivity and issue with blending with the Revel?
I think in this iteration I was just using my Sublime Acoustic K231 active crossover. No problem at all with different sensitivities being a partially active system with individual level controls.

It's since changed and gotten a bit more complicated with the Revel replaced by more DIY and going fully active:


 
Last edited:
Thanks so much for the review, @amirm. I have owned my M106's for about a year and really enjoy them. I do find that they are senstive to placement to the front and side walls. I read on another review that Revel suggest a minumum of 1.1m from any of those walls. I tested this, subjectively only, and it made a significant difference to me. Just interested in how they were setup for your testing.

Also, my good friend has a set of Salon 2's, like yourself, and I find that the M106 is quite similar apart from the low bass. What are your thoughts in this regard? I added a SVS SB-2000 sub to help in that respect.
I have a room that is 36x15x8.5. I need to put this within 12 inches of the front wall. Will these work? How much of the sweetness is lost?
 
Per Revel the beryllium tweeter in the M126Be has lower distortion than the aluminum tweeter in the M106.

Having owned both the F208 and F228Be, I was able to listen to Be version louder and over a longer period of time as there is no listening fatigue. The F208 is also a very good speaker but there is a little bit of listening fatigue.

With the scarcity of beryllium, I’d thought I’d mention this as there are more M126Be in the used market and it may be worth the investment.

This is an interesting take. I've been able to sit down with my M106 speakers and REL HT1003 sub, give it some good juice, and go on for a long listening session. I don't find the M106 fatiguing one bit.
 
I wonder how much of this is due to preferred listening levels?

I think some people might look at two speakers like this, and spend a load more cash on the more expensive one, where they’ll rarely/never listen at volume where they’d notice a difference.

It’s okay saying you should demo and make up your own mind, but potentially you need maybe an hour listening to each. Often that’s just not going to be practical.
 
That widening at the 2-8khz range isnt ideal and could sound bit bright depending on the side wall proximity. I prefer more uniform and constant off axis radiation myself.
 
Hi to All ! i would like to get some opinions about my belief i.e. this is the plot that shows the range of usability of a speaker

1788939630106.png


this extremely interesting graph is very fundamental to me. When established the maximum bearable distortion level on the Y axis immediately the usability range of the speaker shows up
I.E. if we accept a 2% distortion level the speaker is usable from about 150 Hz up (THD curve)
if we can get along with 5% THD then the speaker can be used from about 100Hz up
Conclusion ... this speaker cannot provide a a full range emission
or two subs one per side ... even better
Lately i compared a very good small 2 ways with a bigger old 3 ways JBL speaker
the experience listening to the 2 ways small speaker was like listening to a radio ... the comparison has been eye opening ... well ears opening
some instruments with a lot bass content just need a great response in the bass
If not a piano will sound likle a well-tempered harpsichord :facepalm:
 
Lately i compared a very good small 2 ways with a bigger old 3 ways JBL speaker
the experience listening to the 2 ways small speaker was like listening to a radio ... the comparison has been eye opening ... well ears opening
some instruments with a lot bass content just need a great response in the bass
If not a piano will sound likle a well-tempered harpsichord
There is so many variable in the experiment you conducted that your conclusion is not valid.
You have every right to prefer the sound of the 3 way JBL in the circomstances of your set up.
We all know here that more bass is prefered by a majority of listener.
If a piano sound like a harpsichord on a good small 2 way speaker, then the set up is wrong, not the speaker, or it is not a good small 2 way speaker.
 
There is so many variable in the experiment you conducted that your conclusion is not valid.
You have every right to prefer the sound of the 3 way JBL in the circomstances of your set up.
We all know here that more bass is prefered by a majority of listener.
If a piano sound like a harpsichord on a good small 2 way speaker, then the set up is wrong, not the speaker, or it is not a good small 2 way speaker.

Hi ! thank you for your kind and valuable reply
i believe in direct experience ... take a Bach Toccata e Fuga track and play it on the system
The inadequate speakers will rattle at high SPLs
The very good speakers will make the room wall to rattle
I mean ... a full range instrument will be only realistically reproduced by a true full range speaker
In a piano the lower notes are on the same level of higher notes
The small speakers with small woofers have no chance to give back a really satisfactory experience
The real driver of small speakers has been the WAF they accept also slim towers ... again not good for full range sound
 
So good = massive output under 100hz ?

To me, M106 is a great speaker.
But it is still a small speaker.

Would you be happier if it went flatter to a lower frequency ?

Would you be happier if it went louder at a said under 100hz frequency ?

Can it punch or rumble as good as a 12-15” 3-way ?

Probably not.
It is a 6” 2-way speaker.

Sterophile has a restricted low frequency speaker catagory for a reason.

Now, put the m106 crossing say at 250-300hz to a 12 or a 15, that could be my end game speaker.
 
Last edited:
put the m106 crossing say at 250-300hz to a 12 or a 15, that could be my end game speaker.
Hi exactly what i have in mind
This is my favorite approach for a full range speaker
A sat above a bass box
And I much prefer the woofer placed in a dedicated enclosure mechanically decoupled by the small two ways
If we take a really great three ways and take out mid and tweeter and place them in a separate box the final speaker will sound quite cleaner in the mids and highs
The combinations are infinite
 
True.

I would say a sat over a woofer box instead of a subwoofer.

80hz - 300hz is my fun zone.
Yup. I posted mine earlier. Crossing to a sub is a great start but adding a dedicated lightweight midbass specialist in that range for each channel is transformative.
 
Arent there some sibilance on these speakers at 3-7khz? looking at the polar and SP and ER there is some widening at the treble, looks almost like my old genelec 8040B
 

Attachments

  • Genelec 8040B 0-30 off axis.jpg
    Genelec 8040B 0-30 off axis.jpg
    183.8 KB · Views: 67
This is a review and detailed measurements of the Revel M106 bookshelf speaker. It was kindly purchased and drop shipped to me. It is not a new sample but came to me with full packaging and protective wrapper. The M106 costs US $1,000 each or $2,000 for a pair. It is only sold through dealer channel so these are "list prices."

NOTE: our company, Madrona Digital is a dealer for Harman which includes Revel speakers. So please feel free to read as much bias as you like in this review.

The M106 is one of the heaviest and densest speakers I have lifted for its size:

View attachment 70816

The finish is first class and glass smooth. Back panel is highly curved which should reduce diffraction effects:

View attachment 70817

Sorry about leaving the protective plastic on. I try to keep as much as these things on so the finish is preserved when the owner gets the unit.

Measurements that you are about to see were performed using the Klippel Near-field Scanner (NFS). This is a robotic measurement system that analyzes the speaker all around and is able (using advanced mathematics and dual scan) to subtract room reflections (so where I measure it doesn't matter). It also measures the speaker at close distance ("near-field") which sharply reduces the impact of room noise. Both of these factors enable testing in ordinary rooms yet results that can be more accurate than an anechoic chamber. In a nutshell, the measurements show the actual sound coming out of the speaker independent of the room.

I used over 800 measurement point which was sufficient to compute the sound field of the speaker.

Spinorama Audio Measurements
Acoustic measurements can be grouped in a way that can be perceptually analyzed to determine how good a speaker can be used. This so called spinorama shows us just about everything we need to know about the speaker with respect to tonality and some flaws:

View attachment 70818

There are some variations in the on-axis frequency response but some go away in the listening window (average of a few degrees around the direct axis). The large disparity in size between tweeter and woofer also creates some directivity error where the woofer starts to "beam" (its radiation narrows) yet the tweeter starts with a wider beam width causing a dip in off-axis response.

There are no signs of serious resonances though which is good.

Early window reflections are pretty smooth making this speaker easy to place in a room and have it sound good:

View attachment 70819

Putting on-axis and reflections together we get a predicted in-room frequency response in a hypothetical average room:

View attachment 70820

This is really good folks! Some of the variations in on-axis are filed away resulting in almost ideal frequency response. Since what you hear in your room is the sum of direct and indirect sounds, this type of response bodes well for actual performance in one's room.

I read some place that Kevin Voecks (most visible person behind Revel line) said that there was strong effort to reduce distortion and that they had managed to push it below audibility in mid to higher frequencies. So let's measure that:
View attachment 70821

Wow, seems true! At 86 dB the graphs essentially hugs the bottom of the graph. Even when pushed to 96 dB, there is hardly any rise in distortion. This is the type of performance we expect to see in high-end active studio monitors, not home bookshelf speakers.

Putting the distortion in context at 96 dB we get:

View attachment 70822

Usually I set the lower limit at -50 dB as shown. But received a good request to show it down to lower levels so here we are. We can see that distortion products linearly go down and hit some of their lowest where our hearing is most sensitive (2 to 5 kHz). Second harmonic dominates across the board. Third harmonic does peak up near 3 kHz but otherwise is not dominant.

Looking at how wide of a "beam" the speaker projects we get about 100 degrees:

View attachment 70823

The drop off is smooth:

View attachment 70824

Vertical is not bad for this type of speaker and gives you some wiggle room with respect to the height of your stance and your ear level:

View attachment 70825

You don't want to go so high or low below tweeter axis as to land in these "eyes" around 2 kHz.

Directivity is reasonably smooth as well again, given the type and design.

Impedance shows the typical minimum impedance:

View attachment 70826

So don't let the small size make you think you need a small little amplifier to drive it.

You all know I am not a big fan of waterfall graphs but this one sure looks clean and uneventful:

View attachment 70827


Subjective Speaker Listening Tests
For testing, I go through my reference track list, often playing 20 to 30 seconds before going to next one. This way, I can quickly get a sense of speaker's overall performance across wide range of content with different spectrum. Well, that didn't happen here. As soon as I played the first track, I froze in place. The sound was so incredibly smooth and beautiful that I could not hit "next" on my player! Incredible amount of detail. Resolution to die for. The note decay was tremendous. This was that first track, Youn Sun Nah - My Favorite Things:


The Youtube version sounds poor. I have the 88 kHz high-res download. Get a copy of this track and if it doesn't make you melt in your seat with audiophile bliss, you have the wrong speaker/system!

I go to the next track, Snowflake from Kristin Asbjørnsen


The starting strings seem to jet out of the speaker with startling realism. And then the beautiful vocals came through, with nice layering and separation.

Sit .... back... down. This is not some subjectivist speaker review. To wit, my wife was in the bedroom getting ready to go to sleep but she did not come out to tell me how great the speaker was!

Back to my testing, after listening to a dozen reference track and being most impressed with them all, I switched to bass heavy ones. There is no deep bass here but what is there is incredibly clean. And this speaker can play them loud. Really loud with no sign of strain. I had no trouble filling my huge space with just a single speaker playing. Tracks like the classic Samba by Jean Claude Kerinec & Staff Elmeddah could not be more dynamic coming out of this little speaker:


Words really fail me to describe the clarity, fidelity and yes, neutrality of this speaker.

Conclusions
The Revel M106 is not cheap in a sea of bookshelf speakers selling for 1/5 its price or even lower. But I am here to tell you that it achieves a level of fidelity many of us strive for. Its objective frequency response is very good. But I think part of the superb fluidity and clarity it brings to delicate notes is its extremely low distortion. I wish you could be here to listen to it and experience what I did. To say that I am impressed by it is an understatement.

The Revel M106 is one of the most perfect bookshelf speakers I have heard. As such, I am going to give it my strongest recommendation.

------------
As always, questions, comments, recommendations, etc. are welcome.

Here is my routine every night: eat dinner, go to the garden and dig, de-weed, put compost on plants, fertilize and water them. The come inside at 9:30 pm (it doesn't get dark till after that!) and wash all the dirt from under my nails. Then go in the garage measure speakers, process them and stumble into bed at 1:00 am. If this didn't make you cry and want to write me a big donation check, I don't know what will: https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/how-to-support-audio-science-review.8150/

Amir! I just sold my F208's I was nearly crying when they left, but I am using them with 2 21" SKRAM subwoofers that I cross at 115hz and thus the huge size and weight, all the work that produces the fine low, was useless.

However, this is actually the F208 in a bookshelf? I always referred to the M116 and that speaker not everyone likes. I'm glad I found this post. I am dabbling in DIY horn+midbass cabs and boy did I make a mistake there. It sounds great, fine, sharp and it suits my SKRAMS better but I will never ever find the balance of Revel, the F208 was so sweet I loved them like kin. Thank you for this reminder even if the post is 6 years old.
 
Back
Top Bottom